Sci-tech wants skilled worker cap on PhD and shortage jobs scrapped

Limit 'undermines business confidence', groups tell

By Rebecca Hill


Forty industry bodies have called on UK government to rethink its cap on skilled workers' visas, which has been reached for the last three months running.

Skilled non-European workers wishing to work in the UK must enter through the Tier 2 (General) Visa route, which is used for most hires in the science and tech sectors, as well as healthcare.

However, government has capped entry through this route since 2011. The limit is currently set at 20,700 a year – a figure widely condemned by science and tech bodies and employers as arbitrary and unhelpful.

A fixed number are available each month – although government can sometimes "borrow" or carry over allocations – and once this cap is reached, any other applicants are prioritised on a points basis.

Jobs on the shortage occupation list – like physics teachers, nurses or mechanical engineers – and those that require a PhD will be ranked higher, with salary as the deciding factor. Anyone coming to the UK with a job offer of more than £159,600 escapes the cap entirely.

Up until recently, the cap had been hit only once, in June 2015, when it was revealed that some 66 applicants had been refused for engineering roles.

However, it has now been reached for each of the past three months, meaning government will prioritise shortage jobs first, followed by those with the highest salary.

For instance, MP Stuart McDonald said in parliament last month that in December 2017, people essentially had to have a salary of £55,000 or above to qualify for a certificate.

It also means unsuccessful applicants will reapply in the following months, which will have a knock-on effect on the cap further down the line.

As such, pressure is mounting on government to address the cap, and a group of 40 organisations have today written to ask prime minister Theresa May to take "urgent action" to ensure UK firms can attract the best talent from overseas.

"Productivity will suffer if firms cannot access the talent they need," the signatories write.

"Due to the cap on Tier 2 (General) visas being reached in each of the last three months, hundreds of business-critical roles across the economy are going unfilled. Employers need a predictable immigration system. The implementation of the cap on Tier 2 visas undermines business confidence and could damage productivity."

The group – led by Sarah Main, director of the Campaign for Science and Engineering – includes the Council of Professors and Heads of Computing, the Institution of Mechanical Engineers and the BioIndustry Association, and the British Chambers of Commerce.

They argue that government has recognised the importance of research and innovation in its industrial strategy, but this runs counter to the cap, and urge it to take action to "resolve the tension" between the two.

"The repeated rejection of skilled workers due to the Tier 2 cap being reached is already damaging the UK's international appeal," the letter stated.

Since the PhD-level roles and those on the shortage occupation list are already given priority, the group called for them to be totally exempt from the gap. This would also allow "other business-critical roles to be given due consideration", the group said. ®

Sign up to our NewsletterGet IT in your inbox daily


More from The Register

Salesforce boss Marc Benioff objects to US immigration policy so much, he makes millions from, er, US immigration

Billionaire bashed with 'hypocrisy' stick by activists

Campaigners call for immigration exemption in UK's Data Protection Act to be scrapped

Judicial review into law launched

British government to ink deal for yet another immigration database

Exclusive Only £347m wasted in last overhaul

Stop slurping NHS data to enforce immigration laws? Not on your nellie, huffs UK Home Office

NHS Digital boss suggests public concern has caused 'lack of balanced debate'

Trump’s immigration policies costing US tech jobs says LogMeIn CEO

If you can’t bring people in, you build bigger offices offshore

ATO, Dept of Immigration wrist-slapped for failing security audit, again

Both promise to implement mandatory controls real soon now

Tech VCs sue Uncle Sam over President Trump's immigration chill

We can't throw money at nerds if they can't get here, wail Silicon Valley's sugar daddies told: Scrap immigration exemption from Data Protection Bill or we'll see you in court

Campaigners say proposed law would create a 'discriminatory' system for data access rights

Australian Taxation and Immigration depts fail infosec audits

They've had years to fix things up, but they can't even deliver on known best practice

Javid's in, Rudd's out: UK Home Sec quits over immigration targets scandal

'Necessary hashtags' Rudd replaced by local gov sec