Personal Tech

Google's cell network Project Fi charged me for using Wi-Fi – lawsuit

Ad giant billed subscribers for Wi-Fi data, punters claim

By Thomas Claburn in San Francisco


Google's mobile telecom service Project Fi is billing customers for internet data delivered over home and public Wi-Fi networks, according to a lawsuit filed in the US on Monday.

The claim, submitted to a San Jose district court in northern California, alleged that Google is charging Project Fi subscribers for data it doesn't actually deliver.

Project Fi is a mobile virtual network operated by Google that aggregates service from different mobile carriers, specifically Sprint, T-Mobile USA, and US Cellular in America. In theory, Google bills customers $20 per month plus $10/GB of data sent over cellular networks, then compensates whichever mobile carrier's network was involved as appropriate.

According to the complaint, filed on behalf of plaintiff Gordon Beecher and seeking certification as a class action, Google tracks all data flowing through subscriber devices rather than just data traversing mobile network cell towers.

"This means that Google takes credit, and bills customers, for data delivered over the customers' home networks and public Wi-Fi connections that are available to the customer independent of Google and its mobile data partners," the complaint claimed.

"Google bills users for data obtained through alternate connections even if Google is not providing access to that data service and in many cases the customers are paying the third parties who actually provide the service."

Google's Project Fi stated explicitly that customers "are not charged for the data [they] use when connected to open or home Wi-Fi."

The complaint describes how Beecher was supposedly billed for data Google did not provide, resulting in overcharges of more than $200 for his first three months on Project Fi.

It further states that others have reported similar billing errors, citing posts on Reddit and the Project Fi Help Forum.

The lawsuit charges Google with unfair business practices and false advertising in violation of California law, as well as breach of contract.

The Register asked Google for comment, but has not heard back. ®

Sign up to our NewsletterGet IT in your inbox daily


More from The Register

OK, Google. Music in 2019 isn't what it was, but Play nice, will ya?

Bug appears to hate tunes released this year

Google Play Store spews malware onto 9 million 'Droids

How did these get through the net?

FYI: Drone maker DJI's 'Get it on Google Play' website button definitely does not get the app from Google Play...

Updated Quadcopter slinger rudely palms folk off to .apk download

Latest Google+ flaw leads Chocolate Factory to shut down site early

52.5 million accounts at risk, tens of people are worried

Here you go, cloudy admins: Google emits NATty odds 'n' sods

Google Cloud Next Incremental titbits aimed at time-poor techies

Google's secret to a healthy phone? Remote-controlling your apps

Look Ma, no not much malware!

Thanksgiving brings together Apple's Siri and Google Assistant

A divided tech nation embraces, uncomfortably

Roses are red, we've received about fifty. Google's next trick? Pixels for the thrifty

Cheap Google mobes this year, at least according to Nikkei

Google hands out roses to preferred Android MDM vendors

Lucky few get Chocolate Factory's endorsement as Enterprise Mobility Management

Google-whisperers beat reCaptcha voice challenge with 90% success rate

Code's up on Github and Google's fine with that