Emergent Tech

Artificial Intelligence

Facebook gives its 007s license to kill M, its not particularly intelligent AI

Personal assistant that needed human help gets the boot

By Katyanna Quach


Facebook is axing M, the wobbly digital personal assistant tacked onto its Messenger chat app.

A spokesperson for the social network told The Register on Monday: “Today we shared with the people who have access to our M closed beta project, first announced in August 2015, that January 19th is the last day the service will be available.”

It’s no surprise that the project failed, really. There were warning sirens going off in April last year when it emerged that when M faced questions it couldn’t understand, it would fall back to a team of humans to answer the queries. There was obviously no way it was going to scale out from its limited beta test of about 2,000 people in the US to the billion or so people who log into Mark Zuckerberg's empire every day.

M was heralded as a Siri-like personal assistant that you could natter to via text message, and that it would be useful and smarter than today’s clumsy rule-based chatbots by answering questions and carrying out requests for stuff.

Over time, however, it was relegated to a research experiment when it was clear M was not much better than other dumb bots. Some of the technology will continue in the form of M suggestions, which pop up during Messenger chat to suggest stickers, booking a cab ride, and so on.

Facebook didn't want to go into why M is being retired. The Silicon Valley biz has only told us that it launched the project to “learn what people needed and expected of an assistant, and [it] learned a lot.”

A spokesperson declined to explain specifically why M was being killed off, how many human handlers it had, and how much money was blown on research and development for the project. “Regarding your questions, I don’t think we have anything else to add,” the rep told El Reg.

In an earlier statement to the press, first shared with The Verge, Facebook said: “We're taking these useful insights to power other AI projects at Facebook. We continue to be very pleased with the performance of M suggestions in Messenger, powered by our learnings from this experiment.”

The lesson that should be learned from M is clear: it’s 2018, and digital assistants still suck. ®

Sign up to our NewsletterGet IT in your inbox daily


More from The Register

Software dev-turned-councillor launches rubbish* chatbot

*By which we mean missed bin collections, fly-tipping etc.

Kick-Kaas: NetApp gobbles cloudy Kubernetes upstart StackPointCloud

CEO to stay on as NetApp Kubernetes takes to the skies

Thwack... boing: Amazon EFS rival Elastifile flings out multi-cloud file store through Google

Ain't no marketplace like a third-party marketplace

Amazon's creepy facial recog doorbell, Facebook open sources machine learning code and much more

Roundup Plus: Listen to some new classical piano generated by an algorithm

Europe plans special tax for Google, Apple, Facebook, Amazon

French minister says around two per cent of turnover sounds about right

Who wants to read 34 pages about getting VMware Private Cloud to run on NetApp HCI?

Deployment in 'less than 30 min' – but not including reading the manual

Microsoft's Chinese chatbot inspired by images to write poetry

Xiaoice's verse is 'disgusting' say rival human poets

NetApp puts MAX Data, er, ONTAP and StorageGRID gets flash acceleration

Offers a no-details flash performance guarantee

Facebook caught up in court battle with Amazon and pals over 'ageist job ads' that targeted young

How's this any different to advertising in a teen mag, asks social network

When it comes to AI, Pure twists FlashBlade in NetApp's A700 guts

You see, it all becomes clear when you provide numbers