Business

Apple vs. Samsung to climb back into rounded rectangle of justice

Retrial over amount of patent-pinch damages okayed by Californian judge

By Richard Chirgwin

6 SHARE

Samsung has won a retrial to reconsider damages in its patent suit against Apple.

Chaebol-versus-Cupertino was revived courtesy of Judge Lucy Koh in the Northern District of California, who agreed with Samsung that it's worth revisiting the 2012 decision that handed Apple US$399 million. Samsung's also seen other decisions compelling to pay over half a billion in total damages.

Ever since Samsung wrote those cheques, it has been trying to flip the verdict. After losing in various jurisdictions, it fronted the Supreme Court in 2016.

Its argument was that the original case applied patent too widely: given a smartphone might contain a quarter of a million patented technologies, Samsung argued, damages applying to the whole profits from a device were excessive when only a handful of infringements occurred.

The Supreme Court decided in favour of the South Korean company in December 2016, sending the case back down the line, leading to this week's decision [PDF] by Judge Koh.

She writes that “the Court finds that the jury instructions given at trial did not accurately reflect the law and that the instructions prejudiced Samsung by precluding the jury from considering whether the relevant article of manufacture for the purpose of §289 was something other than the entire phone.”

That reasoning means Judge Koh has adopted the position put forward last year in an amicus brief from the Department of Justice, which proposed a four-part test for such cases:

Submissions for the retrial are set for December, and the jury trial is currently scheduled to start in May 2018. ®

Sign up to our NewsletterGet IT in your inbox daily

6 Comments

More from The Register

Samsung left off Google's new official Androids-for-biz list

Five carriers make the cut, plus 32 mobile management apps - and four Chinese phone-makers

A pretty and helpful user interface? Nahhh. Is that really you, Samsung?

Mobe UX goodies for 2018 leak

Samsung escapes obligation to keep old phones patched

Dutch court rules orphan kit doesn't endanger users

Koh YEAH! Apple, Samsung finally settle iPhone patent crusade

Judge Lucy is rid of bickering billionaires... for perhaps a week or so, we guess

Samsung ready to fling Exynos at anyone who wants a phone chip

Including ZTE?

Give Samsung a hand: Chaebol pulls back Arm to strike Intel's chips

10nm? Ha, try 7, or even 5

No one wants new phones – it's chips that keep Samsung chugging

I'll keep the smartie I've got, thanks

By gum, that's chewy: Samsung's NF1 fattens M.2 card capacity with wider gumstick format

8TB drive can give 2U diskless servers 576TB capacity

Samsung Electronics teases record Q1 profit

And yet its shares slumped. The reason? Fears of memory glut

Dear Samsung mobe owners: It may leak your private pics to randoms

Bundled messages app caught emitting photo albums at 2am without permission, say punters