Russia tweaks Telegram with tiny fine for decryption denial

FSB wanted keys, messaging outfit said Nyet

By Richard Chirgwin

Posted in Security, 17th October 2017 03:03 GMT

Encrypted messaging app Telegram must pay 800,000 roubles for resisting Russia's FSB's demand that it help decrypt user messages.

The fine translates to just under US$14,000, making it less of a serious punishment and more a shot across the bows.

However, it does seem to entrench the principle that the Federal Security Service of the Russian Federation (FSB) can demand decryption.

Moscow signalled its intention to crack down last year with legislation put to the Duma, proposing fines up to a million roubles for the administrative offence of not giving keys to the FSB.

Telegram's head office received its summons in July, according to this Russian-language report from the BBC. The summons demanded information about six numbers registered on the Telegram.

Judge Yulia Danilchik of the 383 Meshchansky District Court of Justice made the guilty finding and imposed the fine.

Telegram founder Pavel Durov has posted to Russian social site VK.com that it's not possible to comply.

“In addition to the fact that the requirements of the FSB are not technically feasible, they contradict Article 23 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation: 'Everyone has the right to privacy of correspondence, telephone conversations, postal, telegraphic and other communications,'” he wrote.

He indicated his intention to appeal, and keep doing so “until the claim of the FSB is considered by a judge familiar with the basic law of Russia - its Constitution”. ®

Sign up to our NewsletterGet IT in your inbox daily

18 Comments

More from The Register

New law would stop Feds from demanding encryption backdoor

The Secure Data Act has returned and is lookin' for love

Oz government says UK's backdoor will be its not-a-backdoor model

Investigatory Powers Act suggested as good model for local crypto workaround

Infosec bods: This is a backdoor in Skype for Macs. Microsoft: No.

Dodgy API let apps and plugins silently pry into chat logs, record calls and more

Belgian court says Skype must provide interception facilities

Microsoft classified as a telco, so told to cough up. It may gaufre an appeal

Skype for Biz users: Go watch nature vids. Microsoft wants you to get good at migration

New roadmap for Teams does everything but name Skype's death date

They're back! 'Feds only' encryption backdoors prepped in US by Dems

Feinstein, Vance to try yet again to create magic math

ISO blocks NSA's latest IoT encryption systems amid murky tales of backdoors and bullying

Experts complain of shoddy tech specs and personal attacks

WordPress captcha plugin on 300,000 sites had a sneaky backdoor

WordFence says a fix has landed

Telegram chat app founder claims Feds offered backdoor bribe

Pavel Durov flings Twitter dooky at rivals Signal, says US govt funds their encryption

WD My Cloud NAS devices have hard-wired backdoor

UPDATE This is serious: some of the messed-up machines can host VMs and databases