Fear the SAP-slap? Users can anonymously submit questions about licensing naughtiness

Better than having to stump up £54.5m in back payments

By Rebecca Hill

Posted in Software, 11th October 2017 10:01 GMT

SAP is to offer feedback on anonymised indirect licensing as concern and confusion about the rules grows among customers.

The German firm's rules on indirect access mean customers can be hit with licensing fees to cover any and all software that connects – even indirectly – to data stored on SAP systems.

Following a high-profile court case in which booze multinational Diageo was ordered to pay SAP £54.5m in additional fees after introducing two Salesforce.com systems, there were fears others would be pursued by SAP sparking calls for clarification on the terms.

In response, SAP promised to simplify the rules, and published a white paper that aimed to offer more clarity on three common scenarios – Order to Cash, Procure to Pay and Static Read.

It also promised not to pursue back maintenance payments for customers who "proactively engage with us in good faith".

However, few users were persuaded. A recent straw poll of 50 users found that 30 per cent feared the consequences of speaking up, 36 per cent said they'd have concerns and 10 per cent said they wouldn't be happy to talk.

"The problem for most organisations is they have no idea whether they are correctly or incorrectly licensed," said Paul Cooper, chairman of the UK and Ireland SAP User Group.

"SAP's Indirect Access white paper is a start and it is good to see some clarity around three of the most popular processes SAP supports, but it is by no means comprehensive.

"Despite SAP's assurances it won't ask for back maintenance payments from organisations that are under-licensed, members have understandably been reluctant to speak with their account managers."

In a bid to encourage this conversation, SAP has created the SAP Licensing Transparency Center, to which user group members can submit anonymised use cases or scenarios and then get feedback from SAP.

The UK and Ireland user group said in a statement that the feedback would be "generic" and will "depend on the level of information provided by members".

Nonetheless, Cooper welcomed the move and hoped it would allow members to more openly seek clarification from SAP.

"Licensing remains an incredibly complex topic, so it is imperative that SAP provides as much information and education to customers as possible, with working examples that they can clearly understand," he said.

"Although members will only get generic responses to their anonymised questions, from the first couple of enquiries we have submitted, the input has certainly been useful." ®

Sign up to our NewsletterGet IT in your inbox daily

14 Comments

More from The Register

SAP 404s sap.com blog post that said it's fallen behind on SaaS subs

Partner-penned post said SAP might be as good as Google or IBM ... one day

SAP okays Java EE being Eclipsed, six months after Oracle's announcement

But warns it will bail if something better comes along

Teradata lobs sueball at SAP, alleges HANA based on its 'trade secrets'

Claims German biz used ERP to 'lure' them into joint venture

SAP's Business Client can own entire apps, DDOS them into dust

And that's the worst of ten patches awaiting lucky, lucky SAP admins

SAP made a mistake on its own blog - mobile platform to survive

UPDATE Cloud-herding plan still in force

Researchers slap SAP CRM with vuln combo for massive damage

Directory traversal + log injection = I can see your privates

SAP Anywhere is gonna be absolutely nowhere: We're 'sunsetting' this service, biz tells punters

Exclusive Updated Have a refund... if you agree not to sue

SAP customers won't touch the fluffy stuff... so here's another on-prem HR data tool

ERP giant overstated cloudy SuccessFactor's success

SAP hopes to blow the doors off Salesforce with a block of C/4HANA

It's war for biz customers as ERP king eyes up CRM lands

Cocky SAP struts stuff after cloud sales pass €1 BEEELLION

Salesfor.... who? CEO predicts CRM crown will be his