Space boffins competing for $20m Moon robot X-Prize are told: Be there by March 31 – or bust

Teams get extra wiggle room to hit final deadline

By Andrew Silver

Posted in Science, 17th August 2017 03:58 GMT

The X-Prize Foundation has cut some slack for teams vying to be the first to land a robot on the Moon and scoop millions of dollars as a result.

Launched in 2007, the Google-backed Lunar X-Prize contest promises to hand out $20m to the first private company that gets a bot trundling at least 500 metres on the Moon's surface while beaming back HD video and snaps to Earth. Second place will get $5m. Roughly $6m has already been handed out to five groups for completing various milestones.

Those finalists are: SpaceIL in Israel; Moon Express in the US; Synergy Moon, based around the world; TeamIndus in India; and HAKUTO in Japan.

On Wednesday this week, it was announced the competition's finalists no longer have to launch their Moon droids by the end of this year.

Instead, they have until March 31, 2018, to complete all the goals set by the judges. This date was actually set back in 2016: what's changed is that the requirement to get lunar robots into space by the end of 2017 is gone, so now it's just the Moon or bust before April next year.

An X-Prize spokesperson told The Register it has adjusted its deadlines a few times in the past to take into account the availability of launchers, and so on: "When a competition spans years, and we are asking teams to do something that literally has never been done before, the reality for the competing teams can shift dramatically."

The contest's organizers also added two more milestones: complete one orbit around the Moon, or enter a direct descent approach to the lunar surface, and win $1.75m; and transmit from the surface and bag $3m. Essentially, you get milestone prizes for completing various tasks, and the $20m jackpot for being first to cover all the mission requirements, and $5m for second place.

"There were several teams making good progress," Ryan Russell, an aerospace engineer who studies spaceflight mechanics at the University of Austin Texas, told The Register. He added the scrapping of the end-of-year launch deadline was "not surprising [because] the lunar competition was extremely ambitious."

Clemens Rumpf, a space systems postdoctoral researcher at University of Southampton in the UK, told us removing the launch deadline constraint will "give some of these teams a reasonable chance to win the competition."

They may have had unforeseen and last-minute gremlins, or need to overhaul their designs, he said. It "might not even be their fault" if they couldn't make the end-of-2017 deadline: there could be backlogs in rocket launch schedules that would stall their plans, forcing them to miss the goal. Last year, for example, SpaceX temporarily delayed launches after its Falcon 9 rocket blew up.

An X-Prize spokesperson told The Register: "Both X-Prize and Google want to see this competition won, and remain hopeful that we will see one or more teams complete their missions by the March 31, 2018 date."

The Moon Express team welcomed the removal of the launch deadline constraint. Although its spokesperson said it is confident it will hit the final deadline, it now has more time to reduce the risk of failure and test its equipment. It also hopes to perform three lunar expeditions by 2020.

The other teams were not available for immediate comment. ®

Sign up to our NewsletterGet IT in your inbox daily

20 Comments

More from The Register

Sailor Moon? More like sail to the Moon: Japan vows to set foot on lunar soil by 2030

All part of the wider plan to visit the dusty wasteland of Mars

NASA says New Horizons' next stop might have a moon

Remember that 747 with an open door and a telescope? It spotted a moon-esque blip

Japan finds long, deep tunnel on the Moon

With fewer meteors, lower radiation and better weather, this is a nice place for a colony

Google yanks cash firehose from Lunar X Moonshot comp. The actual Moon shot one

$30m prize will go unclaimed after repeated extensions

Trump to NASA: Fly me (or some other guys) to the Moon

POTUS also wants to Make Mars Great Again

India to launch moon mission in March 2018

Chandrayaan-2 will send a rover and an orbiter to Luna

NASA budget shock: Climate studies? GTFO. We're making the Moon great again, says Trump

Cheer up – by 2030, we'll have flying cars, too

What does the Moon 4bn years ago and Yahoo! towers this week have in common? Both had an awful atmosphere

Huge explosions belched foul gases, but enough about Y!...

Space.. the fi, er, New Frontiers: NASA to hurl space robot at duck comet – or Saturn moon

Can we, can we hitch a ride?

Moon trumps Mars in new US space policy

Veep Pence calls for Luna to become stepping stone for farther missions, constant US presence in low-Earth orbit