On-Prem

Intel breathes $2bn sigh of relief over patent trial

Jury finds that chip giant did not infringe on AVM patent


Intel is breathing two billion dollars lighter Thursday, after a jury in Delaware decided that the chip giant had not infringed on a dynamic logic circuit patent.

AVM Technologies, which holds US patent 5,859,547, first sued Intel back in 2010 claiming that the Intel Pentium 4 and Core 2 designs infringed its intellectual property – but it was dismissed for insufficient evidence.

In January 2015, AVM refiled [PDF], claiming that Intel was continuing to infringe the patent in its Sandy Bridge, Ivy Bridge and Haswell designs.

Earlier this month, a six-day jury trial considered the years of arguments and hundreds of submissions and ultimately reached the same conclusion as the earlier case: there was insufficient evidence.

The co-inventor of the patent, Joseph Tran, is president of AVM. His earlier company, Translogic, had licensed a number of its patents to Intel, but not the '547 patent. When, in 2006, he came across an article that described technology very similar to his patent, he contacted Intel and had a number of licensing discussions with executives.

In the end, the chip giant refused to license it because it said Tran was not able to show which Intel product specifically infringed the patent. Tran claims he did not have the money to afford the "extremely expensive infringement analyses demanded by Intel."

Things were looking good for AVM and Tran just two months ago, when the judge refused Intel's motion to dismiss the entire case for being overly broad: that broadness being a key component in the massive $2bn estimate for damages if found guilty. The jury dismissed Intel no fewer than eight times when it tried to kill the case piece by piece.

But in the end, it went the other way and after the six-day trial (the transcripts won't be available until August) the jury found [PDF] that Intel had not infringed AVM's patent. ®

Send us news
1 Comment

Gelsinger woos Musk as Intel seeks to drum up Foundry Services business

It's just not economical for Chipzilla to be the factories' only customer these days

Intel scores $8.5B in government cheddar to supercharge fab builds

Department of Commerce says it's the largest such investment in US semiconductor manufacturing

Intel Meteor Lake makes unexpected leap to socketed motherboards

But not, we repeat, not on the desktop

Suppliers to Intel and TSMC's Arizona fabs now face build delays

You know where plants are much cheaper to construct? Asia

Biden to inject Intel with CHIPS fab cash 'next week'

Samsung and TSMC apparently slated to receive $6B and $5B

Intel's $699 Core i9-14900KS turbos to 6.2GHz – assuming you can keep it cool

If you can live with a measely 6GHz the standard i9 is a $110 cheaper

Reddit gets a call from Nokia about patent infringement ahead of going public

That's a juicy-looking IPO you've got there. Be a shame if someone took a licensing bite

Pentagon said to have pulled $2.5B Intel defense chips grant

Plus: Trump reportedly gave chipmaker license to sell to Huawei back in the day...

Beijing issues list of approved CPUs – with no Intel or AMD

2024 may be the year of Linux On The Arm-or-RISC-desktop as China moves away from Western tech

We asked Intel to define 'AI PC'. Its reply: 'Anything with our latest CPUs'

If it has a GPU and NPU, plus VNNI and DP4a instructions, it qualifies. But it's not a brand like vPro or Ultrabook

Linux 6.9 will be the first to top ten million Git objects

For now, have Linux 6.8, which Linus Torvalds could find no reason to delay

Intel inches closer to $3.5B contract to build secret fabs for Uncle Sam

They can't have x86 goliath building military chips out in the open now can they?