Server techies 'stiffed on overtime pay' banned from ganging up on HP

Judge orders megadeth for Dave Mustain's class action

By Shaun Nichols in San Francisco

Posted in The Channel, 14th July 2016 20:20 GMT

Hewlett-Packard has succeeded in breaking up a class-action lawsuit brought by its tech support workers who say the IT giant stiffed them on overtime pay.

In an order [PDF] handed down yesterday, Judge Beth Labson Freeman said the enterprise field-support technicians can't band together against the Palo Alto goliath, and must take on the biz one-on-one.

The class, filed in a northern district court of California and led by named plaintiffs Eric Benedict and David Mustain (not that one), accused HP of illegally making their positions exempt from overtime pay when they worked more than 40 hours per week.

After notice of the suit was filed in 2013, 1,385 workers signed on to join the class. Salaries for the workers ranged from below $40,000 to $100,000 yearly.

One slightly confusing aspect of this legal fight is that the lawsuit is pursuing Hewlett-Packard Company, but the organization broke in half in 2015 into HP Inc (which flogs PCs and printers) and Hewlett-Packard Enterprise (which flogs servers and similar gear). Still, lawyers acting on behalf of Hewlett-Packard Company are battling away with Benedict and Mustain. No one was able to clarify exactly which bit of HP is being sued.

Before the split, HP claimed that the employees were not eligible to sue in a class action, as their various positions were not similar enough to warrant a single claim. Rather, HP argued (and the court agreed), the employees should be forced to file their cases separately.

The court notes that the employees taking part in the class covered multiple roles and service tiers, some responding to field calls directly and others providing remote work or developing programs within HP. Many reported to different managers at different locations. Additionally, the filing noted, some of the class members had been able to define or add responsibilities to their roles.

"Plaintiffs' attempt to gloss over significant differences in Collective Members' job duties by relying on their shared Job Title and HP's blanket exemption policy fails to show that they are similarly situated for several reasons," Judge Freeman wrote.

"The fact that an employer classifies all or most of a particular class of employees as exempt does not eliminate the need to make a factual determination as to whether class members are actually performing similar duties."

Because of this, the court agreed with HP's argument that the class action was too broad to be tried as a single case.

In doing so, HP will make it harder for the individuals to successfully sue, as they will no longer be able to pool into a large class to fight the company's massive legal team.

Both sides have said, in a separate filing, that they are actively in settlement negotiations with a mediator. ®

Sign up to our NewsletterGet IT in your inbox daily

14 Comments

More from The Register

Windows Update borks elderly printers in typical Patch Tuesday style

Updated Epson old-timers go from dot matrix to not matrix

US cops go all Minority Report: Google told to cough up info on anyone near a crime scene

Police cyber-hunt reveals massive gap in legal protections

Oh Brother: Hackers can crash your unpatched printers – researchers

Updated DoSsing for fun and profit not just a 'nuisance', they warn

Firmware freakout sends Epson Wi-Fi printers into reboot loop

Have you tried not turning it off and on again?

Super Cali's futuristic robo-cars in focus. Even though a watchdog says tech is quite atrocious

If we have to remote control it, we hope you'll never notice

Disengage, disengage! Cali DMV reports show how often human drivers override robot cars

Driverless tech not ready, to shock of nobody

Driverless cars will lead to data-sharing – of the electrical kind

AEV Bill Tell the grid how much juice your auto autos are sucking, says UK transport sec

IT resellers, this is your future: Shifting driverless cars within 5 years

Canalys Channels Forum Yeah or maybe not

London seeks trials of Google's robo-cars

Deputy Mayor for Transport Isabel Dedring says Google has met city officials

US trade watchdog boss goes all Kendrick Lamar on self-driving cars

Sit down Kitt, be humble