The Channel

Microsoft's paid $60 per LinkedIn user – and it's a bargain, because we're mugs

Until we price our personal data we'll keep on being fleeced

By Andrew Orlowski


Analysis How can you explain the $25.4bn price tag for Microsoft's acquisition of widely-loathed social network LinkedIn? It's easy. It's all about your personal data, of course. But the price Microsoft puts on your personal data is of particular interest here.

Two years ago, Facebook splurged $18.4bn for the over-the-top IM app WhatsApp, a BBM clone with a dozen staff. That worked out at $42 per address book.

WhatsApp at the time had a "mere" 310 million users, zero revenue, and the technology was primitive. With Facebook's ubiquitous presence and vastly superior development teams, why not just blow WhatsApp out of the water?

WhatsApp had only one advantage, but that appeared to be crucial to its buyer. WhatsApp is tied to your phone number, and you can't keep your address book private from WhatsApp. As soon as you log on for the first time, up it goes.

From that point of view, the $42 per address book looked like a bargain. Microsoft has paid more, but in return, acquires the "social graph" as well as the address books of even more active users. It's only paid slightly more: $60.51 per LinkedIn address book. And it's got that social network info "thrown in" for free.

In a poll two years ago, two thirds of internet users quizzed in four European countries thought the platform provider got a better deal from harvesting personal data than the punter did. But it got really interesting when pollsters asked people what they thought each piece of personal information was actually worth.

How much would you sell your gender or address for? Or your marital status or sexuality? It added up to £140 (€170/US$191) per consumer.

The $42 and $60 suggest not that Facebook and Microsoft paid too much, but that they paid too little.

Jaron Lanier called the info-harvesting platforms "siren servers," which he defined as internet companies that "depend on accumulating and evaluating consumer data without acknowledging a monetary debt to the people mined for all this 'free' information."

Lanier's Swiftian suggestion was consumer action: to recognise that we're data producers, and start demanding a fair price for this data.

In neither case does the well-worn phrase "you are the product" sound smart, but it's too clever. You are not the product, you are a data producer who's agreed to a rotten deal. The worker who's trusted his wage negotiations not to a union, but to the boss. Is it a surprise that your output is undervalued?

The idea of a rational economic actor is out of fashion today, as "behavioral" economics holds sway. But unless we start acting rationally and putting a price on personal data, we'll keep getting fleeced. Some people are happy with the bargain of handing over their data for free stuff – but many more are not, Orange's survey reminded us. Unless we begin to price our data, we're just there to be fleeced, time after time. ®

Sign up to our NewsletterGet IT in your inbox daily


More from The Register

Home users due for a battering with Microsoft 365 subscription stick

Job opening at Redmond points to new consumer services

US Department of Defense to sling an estimated $3.17bn at Microsoft resellers

Cash to be splashed over 10 years on software sporting a Microsoft badge

It's the wobbly Microsoft service sweepstake! If you have 'Teams', you've won a lifetime Slack sub

Just kidding, no one deserves that. But you'd be right

Pull request accepted: You want to buy GitHub, Microsoft? Go for it – EU

Eurocrats reckon that anti-competitiveness from Redmond would be a massive foot-shooting exercise

New era for Japan, familiar problems: Microsoft withdraws crash-tastic patches

Upcoming calendar change more than Office can handle

Microsoft has signed up to the Open Invention Network. We repeat. Microsoft has signed up to the OIN

That 60,000 patents in your pocket or are you just pleased to see us?

Microsoft Germany emerging from behind Deutsche Telekom cloud

Frankfurt, Berlin regions to launch end of 2019, T-Systems 'trustee' deal to be retired

Microsoft wants to cart your data away in a box and punt it onto Azure

Ignite 1PB of Fedex-able rack-on-rollers

Microsoft claims Office 364 back to business as usual. Oh no it isn't, say suffering sysadmins

Utilitarian fix leaves minority of users still moaning

Microsoft polishes up Chromium as EdgeHTML peers into the abyss

When you gaze long into an abyss, the abyss gazes into you. Or is that just Windows Hello?