Net neutrality victory: FCC approves 'open internet' rules in 3-2 vote

Telcos, start your litigation as US broadband faces regulation

By Kieren McCarthy in San Francisco

Posted in Policy, 26th February 2015 18:02 GMT

US watchdog the FCC today approved its strongest ever rules governing internet access. The regulations were passed in a 3-2 vote by commissioners.

"It's a red letter day for the internet," said FCC chairman Tom Wheeler just prior to calling the vote. "Today history is being made." The vote fell along partisan lines, with the chairman and two Democratic commissioners voting in favor and the two Republican commissioners voting against.

The "net neutrality" rules will bring broadband access under Title II legislation, designed for the telephone industry back in the 1930s.

This means broadband will be treated like a phone service, which is strictly regulated: it's possible ISPs may not be able to do things like prioritize a particular website's traffic to the detriment of others, for example.

It is a controversial decision but one for which many, including the President, have actively campaigned for. The decision is also expected to have a worldwide impact given the United States' dominant position in internet services.

Despite being hailed as a victory by advocates of an open internet, the rules are expected to be almost immediately challenged in the courts. Critics of net neutrality rules argue they represent government overreach, pulling regulation into a field that has thrived in many respects because of the lack of rules and regulations.

The Republican-controlled Congress is also threatening to pass legislation that would overrule the FCC's rules, although such a law would likely be vetoed by President Obama and not achieve sufficient support from Democrats to overcome that block.

Advocates of net neutrality say the FCC was given little choice but to apply the rules following a successful legal challenge to its previous Open Internet rules by telecoms giant Verizon, and the rejection of a proposed "hybrid" model put forward briefly by FCC chair Tom Wheeler.

The cable companies' proposed solution (apply the far lighter section 706 of legislation passed at the very beginning of the internet's commercial development) would have given significant leeway to cable companies to apply controls and fees. That sparked fears that the internet would become increasingly dominated by large corporations able to pay for preferential treatment – internet fast lanes to squeeze out smaller rivals, in other words.

The full impact of the regulations will take time to evaluate however, not least because the FCC's chairman has refused to publish a copy of the net neutrality rules.

"We cannot possibly imagine what happens next," said Wheeler. Verizon's and AT&T's lawyers have a pretty good idea however. ®

Sign up to our NewsletterGet IT in your inbox daily

72 Comments

More from The Register

One year late, US senators act on fake net neutrality comments that drowned the FCC

It's not a real problem until a Congressman is affected

Dems push Ryan to vote to help save America's net neutrality measures

Deadline looms as Senators nudge House

California Senate OKs net neutrality law, gives FCC cold hard long stare

F U FCC say lawmakers as bill passes to Assembly

Net neutrality advocates freak out as lobbyists pull rug from California's draft net neutrality law

Legislation 'could have been written by AT&T and Comcast'

Pressure mounts on FCC to cough up answers over fake net neutrality comments

Analysis House Dems send snotagram to watchdog boss

NRA gives FCC boss Ajit Pai a gun as reward for killing net neutrality. Yeah, an actual gun

Decorum isn't even visible in the rear-view mirror at this point

Democrats need just one more senator (and then a miracle) to reverse US net neutrality death

It won't pass but hey, why pass up a partisan punch-up?

Washington (no, not that one) to pass hardcore net neutrality law: All ISPs in state must obey

US tech hotbed steps up with strictest traffic protections yet

OK, who had 'Montana' in the net neutrality state pool? Congratulations

Updated Big Sky state first to pass mandate to bar throttling

Verizon whips out Big Johnson to lure FCC into axing US states' net neutrality, privacy rules

'Light touch' must be enforced with a heavy hand, says telco