Judge: You can't call someone a c*nt, but a C∀NT is a cunning stunt

So long as you stay silent and put it on a sign you're clever and not criminal

Got Tips? 21 Reg comments

At a time when far-right websites are being denied domain names, debate about the limits of free speech may never have been more fierce. And now an Australian court has weighed in with a decision that it is okay to call the nation's former Prime Minister Tony Abbott a c*nt.

In a glorious moment for jurisprudence in Australia, a judge has decided that the word is “inappropriate and in poor taste”, but that using it doesn't necessarily justify a charge of offensive behaviour. District Court Judge Andrew Scotting also ruled that the law in question (the Australian State of New South Wales' Summary Offences Act) makes it a crime to utter the word in some contexts.

Politicians and their views are often subject to criticism in public that can extend to personal denigration.

The accused in the case, a sandwich-board-sloganeer and sometime senatorial candidate named Danny Lim, didn't drop the c-bomb. He merely displayed it on one of the signs he totes around Sydney.

The court agreed that c*nt is what Lim meant when he composed one of his sandwich boards and included the word “C∀NT", which judge Scotting records in his judgement thus:

PEACE SMILE
PEOPLE CAN CHANGE TONY YOU CUNT
LIAR, HEARTLESS, CRUEL
PEACE BE WITH YOU

We believe that the strikethrough attempted here is because Lim used Unicode's inverted A (∀) and the court transcription service couldn't reproduce it.

Whatever the typographical niceties involved, a member of the public took offence at Lim's sign and notified the local constabulary, who packed Lim off to court. Magistrate Lisa Stapleton concurred and Lim was convicted of “behaving in an offensive manner in a public place”, because Lim “by inverting a rounded capital 'A' in the word 'can't' on the front of the sign had referred to the then Prime Minister as a 'c*nt'.”

Lim appealed, using the argument that merely using offensive language is not automatically offensive, and Judge Scotting agreed.

“Politicians and their views are often subject to criticism in public,” his decision reads. “This is an essential and accepted part of any democracy. That criticism can often extend to personal denigration or perhaps even ridicule, but still maintain its essential character as political comment. There is no reason to conclude that the Prime Minister, as the leader of the Federal Government, should be treated any differently to any other person who holds or seeks political office”.

The decision continues: “The front of the sandwich board, at the height of the prosecution case, conveyed no more than a reference to the Prime Minister in derogatory terms.”

While perfectly satisfied that Lim's sandwich board was “inappropriate and in poor taste”, that's not enough to make it offensive to a criminal degree: “I am not satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that it was offensive”.

As to the application of the Summary Offences Act to the case, the judge is clear: “The word 'using' in Section 4(2) means speaking or uttering offensive language and the appellant has not made out this contention” (emphasis added).

Lim remained confident throughout his legal odyssey, it seems, since last year he applied his Word-Art level typography (and gonzo spelling) to current Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull:

After all, as the judge notes, Shakespeare referred to the c-word in Hamlet. What more can we say? ®

Sponsored: Webcast: Simplify data protection on AWS

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR WEEKLY TECH NEWSLETTER


Keep Reading

young woman looks through blinds

Sunday: Australia is shocked UK would consider tracking mobile data to beat pandemic. Monday: Australia to deploy drone intimidation squads

Updated Bloody poms are full of great ideas
unlocked phone

Poor, poor mobile networks. UK's comms watchdog plans to stop 'em selling locked-down handsets

First OTT apps nick their SMS revenue, now this...

Back when the huge shocking thing that felt like the end of the world was Australia on fire, it turns out telcos held up all right

Or as well as they could once the power went out - yet report says reliance on electricity isn't a resilience issue
Google Chrome logo

Better late than never... Google Chrome to kill off 'tiny' number of mobile web ads that gobble battery, CPU power

Could have done with this years ago to stave off rise of advert blockers but fine, OK, whatever, now it's coming
Two people, man and woman, pleading

Google begs for US Entity List exemption to let Huawei use its mobile services – report

We couldn't have anyone upsetting the Android monopoly, could we?
Burning 5G against dark background

Microsoft buys Affirmed Networks to provide cloudy services for 5G network operators

Vodafone, Orange, AT&T, and Softbank are already users, will soon have Azure option
A person wearing a mask next to map of China

Roses are red, IBM is Big Blue. It's out of RSA Conference after coronavirus review: IBMers will not attend infosec event over 'health concerns'

Updated Who will join the IT giant in staying away from San Francisco?
fed up

A lot has changed since Android 11 was but a twinkle in Google's eye – so mobile OS has been delayed a month

'Extra time for you to test,' you lucky, lucky developers

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2020