LaCie Starck

We connected the drive to a PC and ran CrystalDiskMark. Next, we plugged the drive into a Mac and performed our customary file-transfer tests using a 2GB file and a 1GB folder containing 100 10MB files.

Not for juicing lemons

The Starck performed well in comparison with other 2.5in drives in our real-world file-transfer tests and in CrystalDiskMark, so we've no concerns about that aspect of the drive. Price is another matter, and LaCie's tariff puts the tested 320GB drive at £85 and the 500GB model at £110. Both are about a tenner more than average, but then 2mm-thick machined aluminium cases and Philippe Starck's design nous don't come cheap.

Aluminium, at least, has practical benefits: it dissipates heat, potentially boosting the drive inside's longevity - it was a Samsung in the review unit, by the way - and will give the drive a measure of shock resistance. Some buyers will appreciate its weight and the air of solidity it brings to the proceedings. Others will think it too big - it's certainly bigger than most of today's 2.5in external HDDs.

Ultimately, though it's about whether you like the look or not, and whether you're willing to pay a wee bit extra for a snazzier drive than most.

Verdict

Does design matter in an external hard drive? Even if you don't, LaCie's Starck is a decent performing drive that wins points for the built-in USB cable. No wobbly mini-USB connects here, we're pleased to say. But you have to be prepared to pay extra for the looks, which won't be to everyone's taste. ®

More 2.5in External HDD Reviews...

Iomega eGo

LG XD2

Freecom ToughDrive Sport

Samsung S1 Mini