Original URL: http://www.theregister.co.uk/2003/12/03/sony_ericsson_p900_smartphone/

Sony Ericsson P900 smartphone

The P800 updated at last

By Andrew Orlowski

Posted in Reviews, 3rd December 2003 04:35 GMT

Reg Review Visually stunning, the Sony Ericsson P900 smartphone is a redesigned version of its predecessor, the P800, which built up an enthusiastic following. It's a GSM/GPRS - alas, not EDGE - video/camera phone that runs the UIQ flavor of Symbian applications, and has removable storage.

It looks like a regular candy bar phone, but the keypad flips down to reveal a 320 x 208 pixel screen for pen input, much like the original Palm PDA. The flip is removable. This new look gives it a much more businesslike feel, but inside it's essentially the same phone. (The P900 shares the same processor and RF hardware, but a different memory footprint, making more RAM available for applications). However the P900 features hundreds of small design changes, to both hardware and software, which alleviate many of the frustrations of using its predecessor.

Sound and Vision

The most startling improvement is the dazzling 65,000 color screen. Rather than the washed-out look of the P800, which was even more pronounced when using a mandatory screen protector, the P900 has a display sharp and rich enough to compensate for the digitizer.

It's slightly smaller and slightly lighter than its predecessor. In place of the iMac-inspired, bulky translucent-blue of the P800, the P900 is much squarer and sleeker. Both the P800 and its predecessor, the Ericsson R380, used mechanical pins on the flip that physically pressed on the screen when being it was being used with the flip closed. By dispensing with this design, and using electrical connectors to the flip, Sony Ericsson has been able to shave off much of the earlier bulk. The designers are clearly enamored with their choice of materials: the box features the P900 in pornographic close-up. (It's a welcome trend: Handspring's Treo 600 and Sendo's X1 have debuted using premium materials, and although the P900 is plastic, it doesn't feel cheap. And the horrible translucent plectrum has been replaced by a 'real' stylus.

One drawback of the P800 was its poor reception. Although the electronics is essentially the same, the P900 has marginally better gain. It's enough to make a small difference in my back room, but clearly inferior to the Nokia 3650's internal antenna - although that's a larger phone.

P900Sony Ericsson has given the phone an additional loudspeaker, so that ringtones, alarms and speaker calls sound much clearer. There's little chance of sleeping through an early morning alarm, which to my cost, I discovered was one of the drawbacks of the P800.

Another significant drawback was the power-guzzling display, which when combined with Bluetooth, meant that users would be fortunate to get through two days of use without a charge. Despite the improved display, Sony Ericsson has tamed the beast in the P900, largely through aggressive power management. Some activities, such as playing games, or listening to MP3s have a noticeable effect on battery life: and these are two areas that Sony Ericsson is pushing hard.

However it's the smaller touches that show that Sony Ericsson has been listening to early adopters. The new flip design means that more screen is visible in 'flip closed' mode: 208x208 pixels versus 208x144 pixels, which the vendors says adds up to three more lines of text. Overall, it's a pleasure to use in this traditional flip closed mode, particularly with the addition of an outstanding implementation of T9 text input. Most of the gripes with the P800 related to 'flip open' mode.

It's now much easier to lock the phone, and the 'virtual flip' design has been improved: it's now bigger. The P900 now uses one plane of the five-way jog dial to navigate the menus, rather than switch between default applications. We found this small improvement made a big difference in 'flip open' mode. As with PalmOS devices, there's no easy default to switch between running tasks: a conscious decision on the part of the designers. Other small improvements abound: the P900 sports themes, and a contact manager. The camera now takes videos (with sound) and now makes use of the jog dial.

The P900 proved much more robust than its predecessor, and hasn't crashed or required a single reboot in three weeks. (To be accurate, read "unwanted" reboot, as the phone reboots when being backed up). Multitasking, allowing you to browse while collecting email in the background, remains a strength. When collecting POP3 email on the Treo, we couldn't use the device for anything else.

The P800, like the first versions of the Nokia Communicator and the Treo exhibited some strange radio behavior, at times appearing to lose the signal and struggling to regain it. US networks are notoriously sketchy, and the hilly terrain of San Francisco is a challenging environment for a phone. But the ghost of Lars M Ericsson will be pleased to know we had a smooth reception throughout.

What's not to like?

UIQ, Phone Home

Well, smartphone user interface designers still have some work to do to provide a really human interface: one that's based around how people use the devices. I've expanded on this here, but I think Handspring's designers (now at PalmOne) did an excellent job of making the phone the 'home'. Out of the box, the P900 doesn't have the flexibility, and new owners will want to race over to Symbianware, whose skinnable Tracker software performs this function and much more, such as 'today' view. (There are some pretty outlandish skins there, my choice being Hazem Haddad's very orange CdeB Orange. Did I mention it was orange?

Although Symbian's UIQ is fast and functional, and makes good use of the space, it could use a buff. A particularly frustrating aspect of UIQ is what the designers call "persistence", but it actually means the opposite. What this means is that when an application is sent to the background, it reverts to a default state. Although this was designed with the best intentions, it costs me time every day. For example, you'll often call someone and discover that they're out of the office. You want to try another number, or send an email. On UIQ, you'll return to the contacts application to find you're looking at the Rolodex view. And because there's no 'recently viewed' list, you have to 'find' the person all over again. An intelligent UI ought to invite the user to call another number, or shoot an email, but failing, that a MRU list in the contacts book itself would save a lot of time. (Enhancing the phone's call log - which is a MRU list) to integrate with the contacts would be another way of doing this).

Thankfully 'persistence' doesn't apply to the MP3 player - switching away doesn't drop you back into a silent playlist, which would be plain silly… but entirely consistent with the UI guidelines. Doh!

Talking to the PC and the Mac

On the plus side, Windows users can browse the device from Explorer (the System folder remains hidden). The P900 is bundled with synchronization software that merges notes, tasks, contacts and email synced with Outlook and Notes, over Bluetooth, infra red or the supplied USB deskstand. It also supports over the air synchronization. There's no Mac software, but this isn't bad as it may appear. Apple provides its own Calendar and Contacts applications, which are a welcome relief from the bloated Outlook, and Apple has worked hard to develop its own iSync software. On the Mac, I found that using the latest version of iSync failed to take all the fields to the device; most crucially phone numbers weren't sync'd. (iSync only supports one Symbian device at a time, so I had to delete the Nokia). But given the Cupertino Strangler's affection for the P800 and Apple's strong commitment to Bluetooth, users should feel confident that the bugs will be fixed. Eventually.

As PC users are likely to use the deskstand the most (as it doubles as a charger), the drawback here is the speed. While subsequent incremental backups are rapid, the USB connection needs to be much faster for transferring large files. Over on the Mac, I barely achieved 20 kb/s on Bluetooth transfers, and rued that iPhoto doesn't (yet) integrate with the P900's camera. And Symbian really must fix the dreadful application installer, which looks like it dates back to Windows 3.0 and worst of all, appears to install applications twice. (It installs .SIS to the phone, then installs them on the phone. Someone must have has a good explanation for this confusing behaviour, but we don't want to hear it).

Bundled applications

The software suite is largely untouched in the P900, although the built-in messaging client has been improved. It now allows headers, or the first few kilobytes of a message to be delivered, and the display shows subject as well as sender. In practice I noticed an annoying screen redraw, as the display flickered about a dozen times when opening my email inbox (but not, curiously, the SMS inbox) in both flip open and flip closed modes.

Sony Ericsson lists seven corporate email solutions in its Enterprise white paper for the phone, and while it's true that smartphone business users will rightly be steered towards a RIM or Good setup, professional consumers will be a little disappointed by the offering.

The already excellent MMS composer in the P800 has got even better. The P900 handles vector-based SMIL presentations.

The built-in viewer handles Microsoft formats, PDF, and the usual graphics suspects. To edit Office documents, you'll need the venerable QuickOffice. The browser is unchanged, but most people will load up Opera as soon as the battery is charged: until Nokia unleashes its Series 90 next year, Sony Ericsson has best mobile browsing experience in Opera by a wide margin.

More significantly for developers, the P900 features MIDP 2.0, which promises to take Java out of the dark ages with support for messaging and graphics.

Who needs one?
The jostling for position amongst the smartphone vendors is intriguing. All want a slice of the consumer market while stressing their business credentials. The P900 is a terrific multimedia device, but alas as a music player it's hampered by support for the expensive Memory Stick Duo, and only Sticks of 128MB at that. With 1GB memory cards common next year, this is a short sighted move. Hardcore gamers may find the hardware interface restrictive (not enough buttons, and the jog dial is far from optimal), but given that the processor has plenty of power and a glorious screen, the potential remains.

Curiously, for all its whiz-bang features, the P900 could appeal to conservative buyers from both markets. With its 6600, Nokia has adopted a similar low-key styling, and both designs are about taking the 'geek' out of smartphone. SonyEricsson's gamble is that there are users who want a phone first and who want rich access to rich Web and PDA, but don't want to be reminded of it (the bulkier RIMs, Treo and Nokia Communicator are the reverse: they're messaging devices first) all the time. Here's where the pen and flip design that Ericsson has persisted with for so long finally comes into its own. The P900 is the easiest phone I've used one handed and the flip doesn't compromise viewing richer material. That's quite a nice place to be.

It's also a niche that Nokia wants to be with its 6800 series, the scissors phone that has a fold-out keyboard, that Nokia positions as a corporate messaging device. And it's also a market that cheaper smartphones running OpenWave's impressive V7 and Picsel's quite amazing browser/viewer suite can target.

(For Sony Ericsson to succeed, the price needs to drop still further to match the latest competitive discounts on the Treos. The greatest competition for the P900, and the Treo, is Sony Ericsson itself: as P800s are available on some networks for free with a new contract).

The market is vast enough to support lots of interesting form factors - for example, I'm a died in the wool keyboard user - currently with few options. With PalmOne largely abandoning the pen niche (although we really do hope to see a smaller Treo without a keyboard) Sony Ericsson has a great opportunity to convince phone owners that they just need a little more data under the lid, or in this case, the flip. ®

Sony Ericsson P900 smartphone
Pros — Graceful balance between phone and computer
— Excellent display
— Probably the best mobile web companion for your money
— Reliable, good multitasking
Cons — Offers only incremental improvements for P800 owners
— Removable storage capped too for MP3 use
— UI needs a buff
Price around £300 with contract
More info The Sony Ericsson web site

Buy the Sony Ericsson P900 or the PalmOne Treo 600 from The Reg Mobile Store.

Recent reviews
Sony Ericsson GC79 WLAN + GPRS card
Dell Axim x3i Wi-Fi Pocket PC
Elonex eXentia Media Center PC
Rock Pegasus CTS notebook
PalmOne Treo 600 smartphone
Rio Chiba 256MB MP3 player