Excel hell messes up ~20 per cent of genetic science papers

Australian boffins say the problem is between users' ears and in the spreadsheet's formatting genes

Scientific literature often mis-names genes and boffins say Microsoft Excel is partly to blame.

“Automatic conversion of gene symbols to dates and floating-point numbers is a problematic feature of Excel software,” wrote Mark Ziemann, Yotam Eren and Assam El-OstaEmai, of the Baker IDI Heart & Diabetes Institute in Australia, in a paper titled Gene name errors are widespread in the scientific literature.

Among the things Excel does to gene names includes changing “SEPT2”, the name of a gene thought to have a role in proper formation of cell structure, to the date “2-Sep”. The “MARCH1” gene becomes “1-Mar”.

The paper notes that this is a problem that's been known for more than a decade, but one which remains pervasive. The trio studied 35,175 Excel tables attached to 3,597 scientific papers published between 2005 and 2015 and found errors in “987 supplementary files from 704 published articles.”

“Of the selected journals, the proportion of published articles with Excel files containing gene lists that are affected by gene name errors is 19.6 per cent.”

It's not hard to change the default format of Excel cells to avoid this problem; you can get it done in a click or three. Much of the problem in these papers is therefore between scientists' ears, rather than within Excel itself. The paper is silent on why genetic scientists, who The Register will assume are not short of intelligence, have been making Excel errors for years.

The paper offers two workarounds. One is to use Google Sheets, which in the authors' tests “did not convert any gene names to dates or numbers when typed or pasted; notably, when these sheets were later reopened with Excel, LibreOffice Calc or OpenOffice Calc, gene symbols such as SEPT1 and MARCH1 were protected from date conversion.”

The authors also cooked up scripts to find Excel errors and have made them available to download on Sourceforge.

The Register could suggest that gene boffins just stop using spreadsheets for jobs to which they are not entirely-well-suited, but we suspect the idea would be as futile in that field as it is in every other. ®


Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2017