Feeds

Alex Salmond's fantasy of a tidal-powered Scotland washed away

SNP's King Canute 'in a minority of one' on Pentland potential, says boffin

  • alert
  • submit to reddit

Combat fraud and increase customer satisfaction

One of Alex Salmond's ambitious dreams for an independent Scotland - that it would soon become rich by exporting clean green electricity pouring from tidal powerplants in the Pentland Firth - has been destroyed this week by new research showing that the Firth's potential output is far less than Salmond had thought.

The wild-eyed Scots politico, announcing early efforts in the Firth in 2008, went so far as to suggest that not only could Scotland power itself on Pentland 'leccy, but that it would be selling electricity in substantial amounts to less fortunate nations.

"The sort of power that potentially could come from this area is not some hundreds of megawatts, it's not just like one conventional power station, its 20 gigawatts and more than that, that's like 20 conventional power stations," he enthused back in 2008.

"We have to get in a position where we have a supergrid, not just to England but across to Europe to sell that energy to people who need it," added the would-be premier of an independent Scotland.

A steady twenty or even thirty gigawatts as envisioned by Mr Salmond would indeed be more than sufficient to meet all of Scotland's energy needs, not just that much smaller amount supplied today in electric form. At the moment (pdf page 4) Scotland consumes around 13,301 kilotons-of-oil-equivalent of energy in all forms (electricity, coal, oil, gas, all of it). Even in a future with fully electric transport, industry, heating etc, such a level of demand would equate to steady production of well under the Pentland's supposed 20 gigawatts, leaving a sizeable surplus for export to energy-starved England and the Continent.

There's just one problem with that: it's a load of rubbish, according to a new study published by a group of engineers based at Oxford uni and in Ireland and Australia. They write in the Proceedings of the Royal Society A:

It is found that three rows of turbines extending across the entire width of the Pentland Firth and blocking a large fraction of the channel can theoretically generate 1.9 GW, averaged ... generation of significantly more power than this is unlikely to be feasible as the available power per additional swept area of turbine is too small to be viable.

"We are happy our number is very robust," lead author Thomas Adcock tells the Guardian, describing the adviser who had given Salmond his figures as being "in a minority of one" among subject-matter experts.

Tellingly, the Scottish government webpage "Energy in Scotland: Get the facts" has now been amended to remove claims of 14GW tidal potential, though the foolish figure can still be seen in the Google cache for the moment.

So in fact the Pentland Firth, described as "the world's best site for tidal power" by Grauniad enviromation correspondent Damian Carrington today*, could at the outside maximum supply about 10 per cent of Scotland's energy needs (that is, less than a single percentage point of Britain's as a whole). The figure would almost certainly be a lot less in the real world, as the Firth is a busy shipping route and full exploitation would mean closing it completely.

The cost of doing this would be massive compared to that of simply building a nuclear power station with the same output (in the Severn estuary the proposed barrages were costed at six to ten times as much as equivalent nuclear plants). The price difference would have to be made up by government action to force electricity prices up much higher than they would otherwise be - and such government action has already been responsible for the bulk of the electricity price rises of the past decade. The scope for even more gouging is probably limited.

Comment

Carbon emissions may perhaps, as climate alarmists contend, be a terrible and immediate menace. But the allied idea that the carbon-driven power sources of today can really be replaced in any meaningful or affordable fashion by renewables looks madder and madder every day. ®

Bootnotes

*He seems to have forgotten about the Severn estuary. At one point, enthusiastic tidal developers were pushing plans for a massive barrage there from Minehead to Aberthaw, which would have produced averaged output of 2.9 gigawatts, making the Pentland look rather small. Disappointing work from the "head of environment" at a major newspaper, really. Perhaps he means "world's best site for tidal power where plans for tidal power have not yet been formally scrapped".

Wondering about the word "enviromation"? It comes from The Day Today, whose Rosie May was more like an accurate picture of many mainstream media environment correspondents than a parody.

Keen on tidal power? Enthusiastic Scottish nationalist? Love The Day Today? Think the author of this should be fired, or killed? None of the above but keen to have your say anyway? Fire up a thread in our lovely forums!

3 Big data security analytics techniques

More from The Register

next story
EU: Let's cost financial traders $400m a day, because EVIL BANKERS. Right?
Wait 'til this one hits your pension fund where it hurts
Systems meltdown plunges US immigration courts into pen-and-paper stone age
Massive outage could last four weeks, sources claim
Lavabit loses contempt of court appeal over protecting Snowden, customers
Judges rule complaints about government power are too little, too late
UK.gov chucks £28m at F1 tech for buses and diggers plan
Well, not really F1 but who's heard of LMP and VLN*?
Don't let no-hire pact suit witnesses call Steve Jobs a bullyboy, plead Apple and Google
'Irrelevant' character evidence should be excluded – lawyers
Record labels sue Pandora over vintage song royalties
Companies want payout on recordings made before 1972
Edward Snowden on his Putin TV appearance: 'Why all the criticism?'
Denies Q&A cameo was meant to slam US, big-up Russia
Ex-Tony Blair adviser is new top boss at UK spy-hive GCHQ
Robert Hannigan to replace Sir Iain Lobban in the autumn
Judge halts spread of zombie Nortel patents to Texas in Google trial
Epic Rockstar patent war to be waged in California
prev story

Whitepapers

Securing web applications made simple and scalable
In this whitepaper learn how automated security testing can provide a simple and scalable way to protect your web applications.
3 Big data security analytics techniques
Applying these Big Data security analytics techniques can help you make your business safer by detecting attacks early, before significant damage is done.
The benefits of software based PBX
Why you should break free from your proprietary PBX and how to leverage your existing server hardware.
Mainstay ROI - Does application security pay?
In this whitepaper learn how you and your enterprise might benefit from better software security.
Combat fraud and increase customer satisfaction
Based on their experience using HP ArcSight Enterprise Security Manager for IT security operations, Finansbank moved to HP ArcSight ESM for fraud management.