The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Feeds

Google's teeny UK tax bill 'just not right', thunders senior MP

Hodge on Schmidt: Aiding the economy and paying corp tax is NOT an 'either/or'

5 ways to prepare your advertising infrastructure for disaster

Top Labour MP Margaret Hodge has told The Register that it's "just not right" for Google to get away with paying so little corporation tax in the UK.

Hodge, who heads up Parliament's influential Public Accounts Select Committee, rejected the advertising giant's executive chairman Eric Schmidt's defence of his company's tax record in Blighty. The search supremo claimed Google was "driving a lot of economic growth for the country".

But Hodge said this cannot make up for shifting profits around the globe to avoid paying taxes. Google's UK sales reached £2.5bn in 2011, according to its financial filings, but it paid just £3.4m in corporation tax. In 2012, the web giant globally banked an operating income of $12bn (£7.9bn) on $50bn (£32bn) revenues.

“I accept that Google create jobs and invest in our economy, but this is not an ‘either/or’. The majority of businesses contribute to our economy and pay their fair share in tax," she told El Reg.

"And let’s not forget that one of the reasons Google is so successful in this country is that they benefit from public goods funded by the British taxpayer, like the talent produced by our education system and a functioning transparent system."

The barb-trading is the latest in the row over multinationals' tax bills, stoked by austerity measures in Blighty's public sector following the global financial meltdown. Huge companies are accused of basing their regional headquarters in tax havens in order to cynically but legitimately avoid paying levies.

The select committee's members conducted an investigation of the weeny tax bills of the likes of Google, Amazon and Starbucks last year and concluded that while the tech giants were sticking to the letter of the law, their money-shifting shenanigans were "immoral".

Hodge stood by that stance today.

"All we are saying is that multinational companies should pay an appropriate amount of tax relative to the profits they make from their economic activity in this country," she insisted.

"Instead companies like Google are creating artificial structures and abusing current tax legislation to move profits offshore in order to avoid tax. That is just not right, and people like Eric Schmidt need to understand the legitimate public outrage that behaviour generates.”

Schmidt said yesterday that his company behaved just like everyone else and this is just the way taxes are done. He had said last year that he was "very proud" of Google's corporate structure, adding rather remorselessly: "It's called capitalism." ®

5 ways to prepare your advertising infrastructure for disaster

Whitepapers

Microsoft’s Cloud OS
System Center Virtual Machine manager and how this product allows the level of virtualization abstraction to move from individual physical computers and clusters to unifying the whole Data Centre as an abstraction layer.
5 ways to prepare your advertising infrastructure for disaster
Being prepared allows your brand to greatly improve your advertising infrastructure performance and reliability that, in the end, will boost confidence in your brand.
Reg Reader Research: SaaS based Email and Office Productivity Tools
Read this Reg reader report which provides advice and guidance for SMBs towards the use of SaaS based email and Office productivity tools.
Avere FXT with FlashMove and FlashMirror
This ESG Lab validation report documents hands-on testing of the Avere FXT Series Edge Filer with the AOS 3.0 operating environment.
Email delivery: Hate phishing emails? You'll love DMARC
DMARC has been created as a standard to help properly authenticate your sends and monitor and report phishers that are trying to send from your name..

More from The Register

next story
Would you hire a hacker to run your security? 'Yes' say Brit IT bosses
We don't have enough securo bods in the industry either, reckon gloomy BOFHs
Elop's enlarged package claim was a cock-up, admits Nokia chairman
'Twas an 'accident' to say whopping £15.6m payoff was unremarkable
Oracle's Ellison talks up 'ungodly speeds' of in-memory database. SAP: *Cough* Hana
Plus new, RAM-heavy hardware promises 100x performance improvement
BlackBerry Black Friday: $1bn loss as warehouses bulge with hated Z10s
Biz plan in full: (1) Keep pumping out phones NO ONE WANTS (2) ??? (3) Er, no profit
OUCH: Google preps ad goo injection for Android mobile Gmail app
Don't worry, fandroids, wallet-plumping serum won't hurt a bit
Global execs name Apple 'most innovative company' – again
Google bumped down to number three by Apple arch-rival Samsung
prev story