The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Feeds

'Wireless charging' in Galaxy S4 will betray Samsung's best pal

Qualcomm thrown under a bus in Qi battery top-up rumour

Samsung will embrace Qi wireless charging for its highly anticipated Galaxy S4 flagship smartphone, due to emerge on Thursday, we're told.

By plumping for Qi, Sammy will betray Qualcomm: both companies are founding members of the Alliance for Wireless Power, which touts an over-the-air charging system called A4WP. This rivals the competing Wireless Power Consortium's Qi technology.

But the Samsung Galaxy S4 mobe will be topped up by the consortium's Qi compatible chargers, rather than the Samsung-backed alliance's A4WP tech, according to industry rumours reported by DigiTimes.

The alliance's A4WP is entirely incompatible with the consortium's Qi standard. A4WP emerged from Qualcomm's acquisition of WiPower and Samsung's existing work in the area, while Qi came out of Amway's love of filtered water, so we'll take some convincing that Samsung plans to abandon its own work and embrace the latter.

The two standards use different wavelengths so they'll be no compromise, and Samsung's partner Qualcomm has always been very bullish in arguing that the technical advantages of A4WP would wipe out the first-mover advantage achieved by Qi, despite both Google and Nokia being firmly in the Qi camp.

A4WP's killer advantage is distance: it can charge devices from several centimetres away so a charger in a car chair can provide power to the phone in one's pocket. Qi still requires devices to be placed in just the right place although it is becoming more flexible on that front.

Apple will also start using wireless charging this year, according to the rumourmill, using a proprietary standard. The iPhone maker's technology, if it exists, will likely boast distance charging, based on both Cupertino's patent in the area and the fact that distance charging can really offer a new experience: the idea is that one never directly "charges" one's phone; the gadget just picks up power when it can, and that can only be achieved with separation.

When the Galaxy S3 was launched, Samsung promised a replacement case that would enable wireless power charging, but that never arrived and announcing the same thing for the S4 would open the company to ridicule at the very least. Given the A4WP specification was completed in November and published in January, the S4 would be the obvious device to showcase what it can do, or perhaps the last chance to show that the race to dominate wireless charging isn't yet over.

If Digitimes is right, and Samsung is boarding the Qi bus, then surely it's all over for the A4WP, and Qualcomm will have to file it with Mirisol, MediaFLO and BREW-MP as technologies that could have ruled the world but never quite did. ®

Re: Frying of testicles

I can see why owners of aluminium goolies might be concerned, but unless I've missed a big advance in prosthetics technology the risk would seem to be manageable?

11
0

Re: Potentially useful but needs a proper standard

Hang on, I just need to practise my surprised face when this happens...

There we go. Carry on

7
0

Re: Potentially useful but needs a proper standard

Wait, you're concerned that Apple will use a proprietary system that's completely incompatible with everyone else's?

Next you'll be concerned that the next Pope will be Catholic

6
0

"See if you can challenge their belief. Take them to a room that's secretly a Faraday cage (or just a very VERY dead wireless zone) and see if they can correctly call it."

A group of us went to a cottage in Yorkshire, miles from anywhere. A friend's now ex-girlfriend was 'WiFi sensitive' (and also allergic to magnesium, the 4th most abundant mineral in the human body, apparently).

I remember her saying how much clearer her head felt without all that wireless interference. As I downloaded a book onto my Kindle from the MiFi sitting no more than 2 feet from the back of her head.....

6
0

Re: Is distance charging really such a good idea?

And. You are broadcasting power and most of that will disappear into the void so a miniscule percentage will get into the object you wish to charge. Efficiency requires coupling and this is what you do not have with distance charging.

It might work but whilst the rest of us are trying to save the planet it is a load of phooey.

6
0

More from The Register

iPhone 5 totters at the top as Samsung thrusts up UK mobe chart
But older Apples are still holding their own
Japan's naughty nurses scam free meals with mobile games
Hungry women trick unsuspecting otaku into paying for grub
 breaking news
Turn off the mic: Nokia gets injunction on 'key' HTC One component
Dutch court stops Taiwanese firm from using microphones
Next Xbox to be called ‘Xbox Infinity’... er... ‘Xbox’
We don’t know. Maybe Microsoft doesn’t (yet) either
AMD reveals potent parallel processing breakthrough
Upcoming Kaveri processor will drink from shared-memory Holy Grail
Barnes & Noble bungs Raspberry Pi-priced Nook on shelves
That makes the cheap-as-chips e-reader cool now, right?
Sord drawn: The story of the M5 micro
The 1983 Japanese home computer that tried to cut it in the UK
Nudge nudge, wink wink interface may drive Google Glass
Two-finger salutes also come in handy, as may patent lawyers