Space Shuttle Columbia disaster remembered 10 years on

What really happened to the mission that grounded NASA's orbiter fleet?

SANS - Survey on application security programs

Taking the heat

The familiar black and white motif that has adorned the Space Shuttle fleet is not so much for styling, but a consequence of the three types of thermal protection materials employed to protect it from the immense heat of re-entry. White tiles are a low density silica material known as LRSI (Low-temperature Reusable Surface Insulation) which can withstand temperatures up to about 1200°F. The black tiles on the underbelly of the orbiter are dubbed HRSI – you guessed it, High-temperature Reusable Surface Insulation – and are made of a similar voided silica compound.

Space Shuttle Columbia foam debris

Blink and you'll miss it: Debris disintegration on Columbia.
Credit: NASA [page 34 of the Columbia Accident Investigation Board's report (Volume 1, PDF)]

These tiles are unique in that not only do they insulate the vehicle, but they also reject heat absorbed by radiation through emission in a different wavelength. This makes them very effective on most of the outer skin, but they cannot survive the extreme temperatures on the leading edges. HRSI tiles reach their limit of stability at 2300°F, and as such the wing edges need the protection of RCC panels (Reinforced Carbon-Carbon). This is a carbon-ceramic material, similar to that used in Formula 1 braking systems.

At T+81.7 seconds, video footage showed that a chunk of foam parted ways with the external tank support and collided with the left wing. Measuring at 21-27in long and 12-18in wide, its impact at around 500mph left a lasting and ultimately fatal impression. However, the foam strike was not observed in real-time and was only discovered during review of the launch footage, as the Columbia mission continued. Given that no abnormal readings were reported by any of the on-board sensors, it could have easily gone unnoticed.

Spacewalks, spysats and telescopes

Analysis of the tapes suggested that the impact occurred on the underside of the wing and if any damage was sustained, it would be to the black HRSI tiles. The NASA guidelines for such a situation mandated simulation of the event with the Crater analysis program. Crater was developed as the result of a series of tests performed in 1999 following the conclusion of reports on extensive tile damage in previous flights. Inputting data gathered from the video generated a result from Crater that this would not result in a safety of flight issue. Columbia would sustain re-entry.

Space Shuttle Columbia trails

Columbia streaks past the Very Large Array radio telescope in Socorro, New Mexico

Not everyone was convinced with the Crater result though. A NASA engineer is quoted from an email exchange as writing:

“As a reference if the debris was 1.211kg... the kinetic energy would have been equivalent to a 500lb safe impacting at 75mph. If the debris was 28.7kg, that would be the equivalent of a 500lb safe hitting the wing at 365mph. If the wing is off.. or has a big hole in it you're not going to make the runway. Any more activity today on the tile damage or, are people just relegated to just crossing their fingers and hoping for the best?”

Options for further observations were suggested, but summarily dismissed by bureaucrats and bean counters, as too costly and unnecessary given the Crater analysis findings. A spacewalk was an obvious solution, but not something that was planned for the mission, thus given the associated risks it was not deemed favourable. Also on the cards were remote observations using ground based telescopes or US Navy spy satellites, but access to these systems was also refused on a cost basis.

Space Shuttle Columbia Mission Control

Mission Control monitors Columbia's fated flightpath

February 1st, 2003: De-orbit

16 days after launch saw the successful completion of all mission objectives and at 08:10 EST Houston issued the GO command for Columbia to begin de-orbit procedures. Following a 2mins 38secs burn and roll manoeuvre the Shuttle crossed the 400,000 feet atmospheric entry point at 08:44. Careening across California at Mach 23 (15,000mph at 230,000 feet) the orbiter passed through the point of peak heating, with wing temperatures exceeding 2800°F at the leading edge.

Space Shuttle Columbia path

Re-entry path timeline composite showing data recovered from the flight recorder
Click for a larger image

Space Shuttle Columbia path

Re-entry path timeline composite from first off-nominal event to loss of signal
Click for a larger image

Public observations indicated that the first debris separation was sighted at 08:53:46 EST, but re-entry appeared entirely routine at Mission Control until 08:54:24. At this point four hydraulic sensors in the left wing reported off-scale low readings, indicating failure. Five minutes later total loss of landing gear tyre pressure was reported. The crew’s response to this news was truncated at 08:59:32 and the vehicle is known to have been disintegrating as of 09:00:18, as witnessed by ground observers.

Space Shuttle Columbia trails

Columbia is lost: Visual confirmation from both sides

Twelve minutes passed while NASA attempted to regain contact with Columbia until visual confirmation was received that the craft had been lost. At this point, Flight Director Leroy Cain issued the command to seal the facility and preserve all data, documents and communications for the impending investigation.

Top three mobile application threats

Next page: The Investigation

More from The Register

next story
Red-faced LOHAN team 'fesses up in blown SPEARS fuse fiasco
Standing in the corner, big pointy 'D' hats
KILLER SPONGES menacing California coastline
Surfers are safe, crustaceans less so
LOHAN's Punch and Judy show relaunches Thursday
Weather looking good for second pop at test flights
Discovery time for 200m WONDER MATERIALS shaved from 4 MILLENNIA... to 4 years
Alloy, Alloy: Boffins in speed-classification breakthrough
Curiosity finds not-very-Australian-shaped rock on Mars
File under 'messianic pastries' and move on, people
Elon Musk's LEAKY THRUSTER gas stalls Space Station supply run
Helium seeps from Falcon 9 first stage, delays new legs for NASA robonaut
Top Secret US payload launched into space successfully
Clandestine NRO spacecraft sets off on its unknown mission
New FEMTO-MOON sighted BIRTHING from Saturn's RING
Icy 'Peggy' looks to be leaving the outer rings
Melting permafrost switches to nasty, high-gear methane release
Result? 'Way more carbon being released into the atmosphere as methane'
prev story


Designing a defence for mobile apps
In this whitepaper learn the various considerations for defending mobile applications; from the mobile application architecture itself to the myriad testing technologies needed to properly assess mobile applications risk.
3 Big data security analytics techniques
Applying these Big Data security analytics techniques can help you make your business safer by detecting attacks early, before significant damage is done.
Five 3D headsets to be won!
We were so impressed by the Durovis Dive headset we’ve asked the company to give some away to Reg readers.
The benefits of software based PBX
Why you should break free from your proprietary PBX and how to leverage your existing server hardware.
Securing web applications made simple and scalable
In this whitepaper learn how automated security testing can provide a simple and scalable way to protect your web applications.