Feeds

Opposable thumbs for FISTS, not finesse, say bioboffins

Hands evolved to fight for sex, not to play Paganini

Secure remote control for conventional and virtual desktops

A pair of researchers at the University of Utah have published a paper arguing that our hands did not evolve merely so that our ancestors could perform delicate tasks, but also so that the males of the species could knock the crap out of one another in competition for mates.

"There are people who do not like this idea, but it is clear that compared with other mammals, great apes are a relatively aggressive group, with lots of fighting and violence, and that includes us," the paper's lead author, biology professor David Carrier told Science Daily. "We're the poster children for violence."

As Carrier and coauthor Michael Morgan write in "Protective buttressing of the human fist and the evolution of hominin hands", published in The Journal of Experimental Biology, "We propose that the derived proportions of hominin hands reflect, in part, sexual selection to improve fighting performance."

Compared with chimpanzees, we humans have stronger thumbs and shorter fingers and palms, which enables us to clench our fists and strengthen the resulting structure by folding our thumbs. Chimp fingers, on the other hand – no pun intended – form an open doughnut shape when curled, Carrier explained when announcing his research.

That research was sparked when he and fellow biomechanic Frank Fish discussed a paper Carrier had published which argued that whales could use their spermaceti organs as battering rams. "Frank didn't buy the argument," Carrier recalls, "and at one point he raised his fist and said, 'I can hit you in the face with this, but that is not what it evolved for'."

Open hands of chimpanzee and human

The structure of a chimpanzee's hand (left) is less well-adapted for punching than is man's (right)
(source: The Journal of Experimental Biology)

Carrier thought that Fish might be wrong, and decided to explore the offensive powers of the human hand. He and Morgan gathered a number of test punchers and slappers – "Fortunately, Michael had a lot of experience with martial arts and he knew people who were willing to serve as subjects," Carrier says – and had them deliver six types of blows, as hard as they could, to a punching bag that could measure the force of their strikes.

Surprisingly to Carrier and Morgan, all six types of aggression – overhead hammer fists and slaps, side punches and slaps, and forward punches and palm shoves – registered the same total amount of force. However, due to the fact that a straight-on punch concentrates that force into a smaller area, the amount of oomph delivered at the impact point with a clenched fist was 1.7 to three times greater than that of a slap.

"Because you have higher pressure when hitting with a fist, you are more likely to cause injury," Carrier says.

Carrier and Morgan then measured the ability of their subjects' clenched – or, as they say, "buttressed" – fist versus that of their hands with the fingers merely bent, not pressed aginst their palms and strengthened by that all-important thumb folded across them.

These tests showed that buttressing the fist resulted in a four-fold stiffening of the knuckle joint and a doubling of the ability of the fingers to transmit force, mainly due to the thumb helping hold them in place.

"Because the experiments show the proportions of the human hand provide a performance advantage when striking with a fist," Carrier says, "we suggest that the proportions of our hands resulted, in part, from selection to improve fighting performance."

Human fist before and after a punch

A pre-punch fist (grey) compresses only slightly (black) post-punch, with force being transmitted to the wrist
(source: The Journal of Experimental Biology)

Current evolutionary thinking, Carrier explains, is that when our ancestors dropped out of their arboreal homes and started walking upright on the ground, the hand evolved in order to better manipulate objects and to create and use tools.

"An alternative possible explanation," he says, "is that we stood up on two legs and evolved these hand proportions to beat each other."

And why did we want to beat each other? "Because the mating systems of great apes, including humans, are characterized by male–male competition, which can subject males to intense sexual selection on fighting performance," Carrier and Morgan write, "it is appropriate to question the role that this selection may have had on the evolution of the human hand." ®

Bootnote

Carrier's interest in punching and mating did not begin with his argument with Frank Fish. In May 2011 he published a paper describing research that compared the delivery of blows while hunched over on all fours to those delivered while standing, with results that he said "are consistent with the hypothesis that our ancestors adopted bipedal posture so that males would be better at beating and killing each other when competing for females."

Not only that, he said. "It also provides a functional explanation for why women find tall men attractive."

Intelligent flash storage arrays

More from The Register

next story
FORGET the CLIMATE: FATTIES are a MUCH BIGGER problem - study
Fat guy? Drink or smoke? You're worse than a TERRORIST
Renewable energy 'simply WON'T WORK': Top Google engineers
Windmills, solar, tidal - all a 'false hope', say Stanford PhDs
Rosetta probot drilling DENIED: Philae has its 'LEG in the AIR'
NOT best position for scientific fulfillment
SEX BEAST SEALS may be egging each other on to ATTACK PENGUINS
Boffin: 'I think the behaviour is increasing in frequency'
HUMAN DNA 'will be FOUND ON MOON' – rocking boffin Brian Cox
Crowdfund plan to stimulate Blighty's space programme
Post-pub nosh neckfiller: The MIGHTY Scotch egg
Off to the boozer? This delicacy might help mitigate the effects
I'M SO SORRY, sobs Rosetta Brit boffin in 'sexist' sexy shirt storm
'He is just being himself' says proud mum of larger-than-life physicist
NASA launches new climate model at SC14
75 days of supercomputing later ...
LIFE, JIM? Comet probot lander found 'ORGANICS' on far-off iceball
That's it for God, then – if Comet 67P has got complex molecules
prev story

Whitepapers

Choosing cloud Backup services
Demystify how you can address your data protection needs in your small- to medium-sized business and select the best online backup service to meet your needs.
A strategic approach to identity relationship management
ForgeRock commissioned Forrester to evaluate companies’ IAM practices and requirements when it comes to customer-facing scenarios versus employee-facing ones.
High Performance for All
While HPC is not new, it has traditionally been seen as a specialist area – is it now geared up to meet more mainstream requirements?
Getting ahead of the compliance curve
Learn about new services that make it easy to discover and manage certificates across the enterprise and how to get ahead of the compliance curve.
Saudi Petroleum chooses Tegile storage solution
A storage solution that addresses company growth and performance for business-critical applications of caseware archive and search along with other key operational systems.