The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Feeds

Apple rejects NAKED HIPPIE ebook, despite apple coverup

'Censorship threat to a major part of the Danish cultural heritage'

Supercharge your infrastructure

Photos A Danish author's ebooks documenting freewheeling hippie nudity have been rejected from Apple's iBookstore in that country, even after the author and publisher covered up the offending naughty bits – with images of ripe red apples.

"Apple founder, Steve Jobs, marketed himself as a child of the hippie movement," author Peter Øvig Knudsen wrote in an open letter (Google Translate) to the Danish Minister of Culture Uffe Elbaek.

"Jobs has said that he got some of his most important insights from LSD and was driven by the desire to ensure peoples of the world easy access to art and knowledge," Knudsen wrote. "Our experience shows the exact opposite."

At issue are two ebooks for the iPhone and iPad (Google Translate). These are not mere tacky T&A teasers; 14 of the images are from acclaimed photographer Gregers Nielsen – "perhaps his generation's greatest documentary photographer," Knudsen argues – and 15 are by well-recognized artist Bjørn Nørgaard.

"We are talking about a censorship threat to a major part of the Danish cultural heritage", Knudsen writes.

Danish hippie, photographed by Gregers Nielsen, from Peter Øvig Knudsen's book 'Hippies 2', censored for – and rejected by – Apple's iBookstore

Perhaps the choice of apples rather than neutral black blocks offended Apple's pride more than its prudery

Knudsen's Hippie Company (Google Translate) first tried to get uncensored version of the two ebooks Hippie 1 and Hippie 2 into Apple's iBookstore, but as Hippie Company reported in a press release (Google Translate), Apple required the images to be censored. The publisher then did so by placing red apples over the exposed breasts, penises, and what have you, then resubmitted the two ebooks.

Danish hippies, photographed by Gregers Nielsen, from Peter Øvig Knudsen's book 'Hippies 2', censored for – and rejected by – Apple's iBookstore

A smoke and a smile, circa 1970

Apple then accepted them, and put them up on its Denmark iBookstore. However, Hippie Company's witty censorship methodology was apparently not appreciated: after four days, they were removed. The publisher has asked Apple to explain the removal, but has not received a reply.

"I and Hippie Company ... tried to get into negotiations with Apple and explain to them that there is a serious, historical-documentary book reproduction of Danish press photo and works of art from the period 1967-70," Knudsen writes.

Knudsen has a point. The two publications document Denmark's flourishing hippie movement, with Hippie 2 focusing on "the great experiment in creating a new society in a field near the village Frøstrup in Thy." Surely both sociologists and cultural historians would find the books of interest – as would anyone else who enjoys the sight of youthful ... mmm ... exuberance.

"The case was already absurd, and now it becomes difficult to find the words," Knudsen writes. "Will Apple prohibit using apples to perform the censorship they require?"

Danish hippies, photographed by Gregers Nielsen, from Peter Øvig Knudsen's book 'Hippies 2', censored for – and rejected by – Apple's iBookstore

Ah, 1970, when many played the guitar and many sunbathed nude

To be sure, the books can be easily purchased from Hippie Company in many formats, but The Reg believes that Knudsen made a valid point in his open letter to Elbaek. "I am deeply concerned," he wrote, "about a development in which a single foreign player via a high market share may eventually determine which e-books actually are widely available on the Danish market."

You can form your own opinion of the offensiveness quotient of the images that prompted this censorship squabble by viewing the decidedly Not Safe For Work photos of those frolicking hippies, both before and after the application of their censoring apples (Google Translate), on Hippie Company's website. ®

5 ways to reduce advertising network latency

Whitepapers

5 ways to reduce advertising network latency
Implementing the tactics laid out in this whitepaper can help reduce your overall advertising network latency.
Avere FXT with FlashMove and FlashMirror
This ESG Lab validation report documents hands-on testing of the Avere FXT Series Edge Filer with the AOS 3.0 operating environment.
Reg Reader Research: SaaS based Email and Office Productivity Tools
Read this Reg reader report which provides advice and guidance for SMBs towards the use of SaaS based email and Office productivity tools.
Email delivery: 4 steps to get more email to the inbox
This whitepaper lists some steps and information that will give you the best opportunity to achieve an amazing sender reputation.
High Performance for All
While HPC is not new, it has traditionally been seen as a specialist area – is it now geared up to meet more mainstream requirements?

More from The Register

next story
Elop's enlarged package claim was a cock-up, admits Nokia chairman
'Twas an 'accident' to say whopping £15.6m payoff was unremarkable
Oracle's Ellison talks up 'ungodly speeds' of in-memory database. SAP: *Cough* Hana
Plus new, RAM-heavy hardware promises 100x performance improvement
BlackBerry Black Friday: $1bn loss as warehouses bulge with hated Z10s
Biz plan in full: (1) Keep pumping out phones NO ONE WANTS (2) ??? (3) Er, no profit
Would you hire a hacker to run your security? 'Yes' say Brit IT bosses
We don't have enough securo bods in the industry either, reckon gloomy BOFHs
OUCH: Google preps ad goo injection for Android mobile Gmail app
Don't worry, fandroids, wallet-plumping serum won't hurt a bit
Global execs name Apple 'most innovative company' – again
Google bumped down to number three by Apple arch-rival Samsung
Google tentacle slips over YouTube comments: Now YOUR MUM is at the top
Ad giant tries to dab some polish on the cesspit of the internet
prev story