Post-pub nosh deathmatch: Souse versus scrapple

El Reg mixes it up with the Pennsylvania Dutch

Our popular post-pub nosh deathmatch series takes a decidedly Pennsylvania Dutch turn this chilly November, as we present for your drunken dining pleasure two stateside dishes suggested by our gourmet readers.

The contenders weighing in for this culinary clash are souse and scrapple, a couple of carnivore-friendly concoctions requiring dedicated pre-boozer prep, but offering immediate deployment from the fridge when you stagger home from a night on the tiles.

First up to the plate is souse - a cold cut related to "head cheese", aka "brawn" in England, "potted heid" in Scotland, or Sülze in Germany.

In its most basic form, head cheese is the the meat from the boiled head of a calf or pig, left to set in the natural gelatin from the unfortunate animal's skull.

There are plenty of international variants on the theme using different beast bits, such as pig's trotter, and which may include seasoning, vegetables, and other extravagances not available to the medieval peasantry who first discovered the delights of skull scrapings in aspic.

The Pennsylvania Dutch version of head cheese, dubbed souse or pon haus, uses tongue, pig's ear and trotter as its basic ingredients - the latter to provide vital gelatin, although extra will be required to ensure a solid final result.

The recipe is not to be confused with Caribbean souse, which is an entirely different animal made up of pickled meat and trimmings soaked in water, lime juice, hot pepper and further flavoursome delights.

We don't mind admitting that it was with a certain amount of trepidation that we approached the assembled souse raw ingredients...

The ingredients for souse

...which are specifically:

  • 1 beef tongue
  • 1 pig's trotter
  • 2 pig's ears
  • 20g salt
  • 2 onions, chopped
  • 1 Italian sweet pepper
  • 350ml white wine vinegar
  • 1g garlic powder
  • 3g dried sage
  • 1g ground black pepper
  • 8 peppercorns
  • 8 cloves
  • 2-3 bay leaves
  • 15g gelatin

So, let's get down to it:

The first six step to preparing souse

The second six steps in souse preparation

The final six steps in souse preparation

Once you've got your souse brew into the bowl, you should leave it for a couple of hours at room temperature, until it starts to gel, then stick it in the fridge overnight. This is what it looks like the next morning...

The finished souse, before removal from the bowl

...and here's the finished result, after careful removal from the bowl:

Katarina presents the demoulded souse

A slice of souse

Sponsored: Network DDoS protection

Next page: Bootnote