The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Feeds

Engineer designs glass slipper on Quora

You shall go to the ball, Cinderella

  • print
  • alert

Requirements Checklist for Choosing a Cloud Backup and Recovery Service Provider

This is merely a diversion, but a delightful one nonetheless: a mechanical engineer has answered a question posed on Quora, “What qualities would the glass in Cinderella's slippers need to have in order for her to walk and dance comfortably (and hold her weight)?”

In the kind of what-if that probably has Randall Munroe over at xkcd saying “I wish someone had asked me that”, mechanical engineer Antariksh Bothale gives the perhaps-unsurprising answer that the slipper needs to be made out of something better than ordinary glass – thermal toughened glass should do the trick.

But the pleasure of the post is the journey rather than the destination. From the assumption that Cinderella probably weighed in at around 50 kg – not, therefore, the product of a fast-food diet – he works out a force of 500 N across the whole slipper.

Standing still, Cinderella is safe enough: she develops a compressive stress across the material of 33 KPa, and ordinary glass can handle compression of 50 MPa. However, if she’s walking or dancing, the shoe – particularly its heel – will undergo a twist.

That, Bothale writes, gets a stress of 19 MPa in the heel which (because engineers like to make conservative assumptions) is “dangerously close” to the 50 MPa limit. Hence his decision to favour toughened glass, which can stand more like 200 MPa.

Lovely: even with the killjoy first-comment who points out that “glass” is merely a confusion in translation, and the original slipper was probably fur. ®

Customer Success Testimonial: Recovery is Everything

Pretty Sure

The original didn't have a pornstar heel as well.

5
0
Anonymous Coward

Killjoy comment obviated

Snopes says the bit about it being fur (not fir, as the Richard got the urban legend wrong...) is debunked...

http://www.snopes.com/language/misxlate/slippers.asp

3
0

Re: Fir?

Try reading the link in the first post.

In terms of engineering, this needs to be looked at in terms of low probability high impact event (LPHI) in that failure of the slipper would sends shards of glass deep into the wearers foot, particularly up the heel. Unlike today where idiots abound taking stupid risks because they believe modern medicine will save them from arbitrarily bad injuries, in the Middle Ages a chunk of glass 10cm up your heel would easily prove crippling for life, if not outright fatal. Hence the need to have very large margins in the glass slipper design.

2
0

More from The Register

Reg hack prepares to live off wondergloop Soylent
Our man puts eating people powder Food 2.0 to the test
ROBOT COW teaches Saudi kids where milk comes from
Udderly ridiculous bovine intervention is beyond the pail
Chewbacca held up by TSA stormtroopers for having light sabre
'Mrauuun' 'Right, Chewie, giant man do need giant cane'
 breaking news
I told you I'd be back: Arnie set for another career revival
Don't worry voters, Schwarzenegger's talking about Terminator 5
 breaking news
Who's to be the next Dr Who? Sherlock beats Maurice - says you
Cumberbatch EXTERMINATES Ayoade, Atkinson, Pegg - and Tilda Swinton
Waving an Eye-of-Sauron pulsating mock cock? STOP IMMEDIATELY
Mains-powered sex aid recalled ... Ultimate O turns into ultimate OH NO
At #guardiancoffee, we can now TASTE THE FUTURE through a PRISM!
I have measured out my life in espresso spoons
Oracle's Ellison outlines plans for Hawaiian Electriclarryland
Solar-sourced eau d'Oracle the key to island revival
BEYOND Marxism: What Google learned from staring Glassily at Norks
Boobs, Noobs and Juche-oriented networked facilitators
 breaking news