Hackers claim to have Mitt Romney's tax records
But beware bait and switch fakery
Various media outlets, including El Reg, have been sent a message claiming to be from a hacking group that has stolen the tax records of Mitt Romney and threatens to release them on September 28.
The writer claims to have taken Romney's 1040 filings from the offices of PricewaterhouseCoopers in Franklin Tennessee and copied them onto flash drives. A copy has been sent to both the Republican and Democratic parties and the author includes a code phrase for use in further emails. Similar messages have also mentioned that the files are available for sale to anyone willing to hand over a million dollars in bitcoins.
PWC has said that as far as it is aware nothing is missing and that the Secret Service has been asked to investigate. The local Republican headquarters in Tennessee has confirmed that it received a package, but handed it straight to the police.
Republican presidential candidate Romney has come under fire in recent months for releasing very little information about how much tax he paid before 2010, although he assures the electorate he has paid at least 13 per cent a year, well below the national average. Democrats have called for him to make more information public, but he is refusing to do so.
But before you get all excited it's worth taking a step back and thinking this through, as we did at El Reg offices when the message came in. The case has strong similarities to a case eight years ago that also come up during the height of the presidential campaign: The Killian Papers.
In 2004 President Bush the Younger was facing a re-election campaign against his opponent John Kerry. Kerry had got the nomination in part because he was a Vietnam veteran, whereas Bush had sat out the war as a reservist in Texas.
In September 2004 CBS went public with what it claimed were conduct reports from Bush's National Guard days, written by his old commanding officer Lieutenant Colonel Jerry B. Killian. The documents stated that Bush had missed a scheduled medical and that pressure was placed on Killian to give the president-to-be a favorable job review.
After the story had broken it almost immediately started to fall apart. Some of the documents were clear forgeries and the person who supplied them to CBS admitted that they had been made up. There were several resignations and the whole thing effectively killed the issue from a political standpoint.
So with this in mind at El Reg we've been stepping carefully, checking all available sources and waiting until we saw some evidence before making wild claims. Now that the Secret Service is involved it's a story of sorts, but even if the final documents do get wide release El Reg would recommend readers keep their skeptics hats on tightly until some proof can be found.
Of course, the simple thing to sort out the whole mess would be for Romney to release more than a couple of years of tax information and let people decide for themselves – a practice Romney's father followed but that the son has yet to emulate. ®
"PWC has said that as far as it is aware nothing is missing "
PWC, demonstrating to us its inability to understand the concept inherent in the statement "we took COPIES".
BTW, am I the only one who thought the Killian Papers were organised by the Bush camp in order to downgrade his lack of military record?
Obama's school transcripts
are the stupidest conservative meme of the decade.
For the uninitiated, Republicans love to drop hints that Obama only got in to the most prestigious law school in the US despite underwhelming at undergraduate level because he was a black guy. Hence this 'release your transcripts' meme.
The snag is real universities, unlike degree mills, recruit based on overall potential, not just exact grades. And it's a matter of public record that Obama graduated in the top 10% of his year at said hyper-prestigious school. Which to me would tend to suggest that...Harvard offering him a place despite middling grades was the right decision? But to Republicans, it's proof that RACISM AGAINST WHITE PEOPLE and WE WON'T BELIEVE YOU'RE A REAL PERSON UNLESS WE SEE YOUR TRANSCRIPTS. Or something like that.
Re: Romney is no dummy...
You would like to think anybody that is going to hold a high level position in government would be forced to reveal their tax details for the last 10yrs, along with their ongoing expenses, as part of the job.
I'm sure I've heard the phrase, "nothing to hide, nothing to fear" various times though that only ever seems to apply to the masses.