The Register®

Original URL: http://www.theregister.co.uk/2012/03/05/samsung_apple_patent_ruling_mannheim/

German court tosses out Samsung AND Apple patent sueballs

Chaebol dodges slide-to-unlock claim while Cupertino dodges 3G patent suit

By Anna Leach

Posted in Mobile, 5th March 2012 17:32 GMT

Watch Now : Virtual Machine Movement with Hyper-V

Friday saw two new rulings in the ongoing Apple v Samsung patent squabble in Germany.

Slide to unlock, iPhone screengrab

Judge Andreas Voss handed down one ruling in Samsung's favour (kicking out a claim by Apple over the slide-to-unlock patent) and one in Apple's favour (quashing a claim by Samsung that the iPhone had infringed one of its 3G network patents).

The Foss Patents [1] blog suggests that the death of Apple's slide-to-unlock claim against Samsung in Mannheim won't affect the success of Apple's slide-to-unlock win against Motorola in Munich [2].

The companies are likely to appeal both of Friday's rulings.

Samsung has taken out seven patent lawsuits [3] against Apple in Mannheim. Apple has at least another six pending.

The battle continues. ®