Kindle Fire: An open letter to Jeff Bezos
Google no go-go
I love everything about Amazon. You have created a world where I can sit on my couch, read War and Peace, listen to Lady GaGa and order toilet paper - all from the same company and now, with the Kindle Fire, from a single device.
I have raved for months on Twitter, Google+ and on my podcast, Nekkid Tech that in a few years, Amazon will rule the world. The company I work for even sells virtual storage gateways that use Amazon Web Services on the backend. You have built a truly amazing company.
So you can imagine the tears of joy that rolled down my face as I went to BestBuy to buy a Kindle Fire for myself and for each person on my Christmas list. For the first time in years, those on my Christmas list were going to get more than a gift card I purchased for them on Christmas Eve.
The Kindle Fire looked like everything your average consumer would need in a device: ease of use and access to everything Amazon –books, music, shopping, the internet and my favorite apps - in a beautiful user interface that was crazy simple to use.
After my purchase, I quickly shared with the world that my Christmas shopping was done and I was all too eager to get home to start using my Kindle. It was as if Christmas had arrived on November 15th (the Kindle Fire's US shipping date) and the excitement brought me back to my childhood: I couldn’t wait to start using my Kindle Fire.
As soon as I arrived home I ripped open my box to view my new Kindle Fire. So beautiful and so simple, there are no instructions, I simply powered it on and it walked me through the setup with complete ease. After the device updated itself, my next task was to set up my personal email … after all, I had to email everyone I knew that I was finally set-up with the Kindle Fire.
Is this really the user experience you wanted to create?
I realize the Kindle Fire has a generic email application but I wanted to use the enhanced functionality of the native Gmail app for Android. I quickly went to the Amazon App store to get the Gmail app for Android and was shocked that it wasn’t available.
Like millions of other users, Google Apps (Gmail, Voice, Google+, etc.) are a core function of my online experience. The Yahoo Mail app is on the Amazon App Store (and for the ten users still on Yahoo this is a nice app) but there is no Gmail app. After some quick searches I discovered that it was easy to side-load applications that were not in the Amazon store so I was briefly relieved.
I was wrong.
No Block Party here
I'm sorry Greg. I can't do that
As you are probably aware, you cannot side-load or run any Google app that requires a login on the Kindle Fire. That means no Gmail, Google+, Google Voice (I need to text my peeps) or Google Docs. I should have carefully researched the Amazon app store before I bought the Kindle Fire. I falsely assumed that since you built the Kindle Fire to run Google’s operating system, Google apps would not be a problem to run.
Maybe there are strategic business reasons to block Google apps but if I could side-load and run the Nook app on the Kindle Fire, surely I’d be able to run an app like Gmail that was not competitive to Amazon. Other competitive services like Netflix and Hulu are directly available on the Amazon App Store.
So, Jeff, I’m confused – why would you not include a family of apps that are broadly used by the same consumers of Amazon’s services? Since the Kindle Fire connects me to the internet as much as it connects me to Amazon, Google Apps are essential.
You are much smarter than I am, but I can’t piece together the logic of alienating so many people like myself. Blocking access to Google Apps on the Kindle Fire seems wholly unnecessary.
It’s also bad for the internet. What if Google decided to block the Amazon App Store or the Amazon Cloud Player from their market for some unknown reason? Do your users want access to their essential apps decided for them by Amazon? Is this really the user experience you wanted to create? Apple went through this briefly with Google Apps and we know how it turned out.
I can’t say for certain this was a bad decision by Amazon since I don’t understand the logic behind blocking Google apps on the Kindle Fire. However, I do know that buying the Kindle Fire was a mistake as was my blind faith in the ecosystem Amazon has been creating. I want to like Amazon but not if my experience is going to be this over managed and constrained.
Unfortunately, I need to return my Kindle Fire to Best Buy and get some gift cards. I sincerely hope you’ll reconsider blocking Google Apps from the Kindle Fire. ®
Greg Knieriemen runs NekkidTech, a podcast that covers enterprise tech.
"dump all the amazon spyPad software"
"You'll have all your google apps"
You dislike the thought of Amazon potentially spying on you but you'd welcome the master spies at Google to read your email, documents, know all your web browsing habits, your social circle and much more? What exactly makes Amazon scary but Google completely harmless?!
Except it's not Amazon blocking anything
It's not Amazon "blocking" anything -- it is a well-known issue among the Android community that certain devices ship without the core Google apps - GMail, for example -- and lack the Google Services Framework that is required to run many of the Google apps. Even CyanogenMod, one of the most-used custom ROMs for Android devices, received a C&D from Google saying "Stop bundling our apps into the ROM you distribute." (However, they do provide a separate package for the GApps.)
And Google won't allow their apps in a different app store. Again, it's not Amazon being weird, it's Google, understandably, controlling the distribution of the core apps for their operating system.
And it's actually fairly trivial to get most of the GApps running on the Fire -- all but the Android Market will install just fine without rooting the device as far as I've tried.
*Enable "Unknown Sources" (under Settings -> Device)
*Track down copies of the Google Services Framework APK as well as the APK for whatever GApps you want to install (don't try the Android Market unless you want to root the device) and place them on the Kindle Fire using the USB computer (or you can e-mail using one of the other apps, which do work pretty well, which may negate the need for a file manager. Not sure, though.)
*On the Amazon App Store, track down "Easy Installer" or a file manager.
*Using Easy Installer or the file manager, install the Google Services Framework APK first.
*Reboot the Kindle Fire.
*Install the Google Apps you want.
*A reboot may be required.
This is a LOT less painful than it could be. Trust me.
Android itself is open source, but Google's apps (Gmail, Maps, Market) are not, and manufacturers are not allowed to distribute them without Google's consent.
I'd be surprised if Google was willing to license their proprietary apps (like Gmail) to a competitor like Amazon without requiring the Market app to be preloaded as well. Amazon on the other hand is selling the Kindle Fire more or less at cost and needs to make money by selling content, so preloading Google's Market app on the device is probably the last thing they want to do.
What did you expect?
No sympathy here...
How was this device marketed? As a kindle or a full blown android tablet like the Xoom?
That's right, a Kindle. If you want the full functionality that comes with a full tablet, then you buy one of those.
I am waiting for my Kindle Fire to arrive, and I'm looking forwards to a device I can use for the things a Kindle is meant for...
I thought it was Google
who decided which devices could run Google apps. Android maybe open source (or not depending on your outlook, but that's another story) but Google apps aren't. I can appreciate your frustration at not having these apps on your Fire, but I think you should be writing to Google, not Amazon.
source - http://android-developers.blogspot.com/2009/09/note-on-google-apps-for-android.html