Feeds

Oracle mobile Java licensing suit boomerangs

Breach-of-contract allegations fly

Securing Web Applications Made Simple and Scalable

Oracle and a hot-selling Java mobile software maker have fired lawsuits at each other over who controls Java - and at what price.

Oracle and Myriad Group have filed dueling suits in the US, both alleging unfair competition and breach of license agreements, among other charges.

Both suits were filed on December 10, with the Myriad's suit disclosed in a slightly confusing Bloomberg article. You can read both companies' claims here and here (warning: PDF).

Myriad claims that first Sun Microsystems and now Oracle - who bought Sun earlier this year along with the rights to Java - breached the company's right to a Java Test Compatibility Kit (TCK) under fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory (FRAND) terms.

A Java licensee since 1995, Myriad claims Sun engaged in unfair competitive practices by not granting it a FRAND license under the Java Community Processes' (JCP's) governing agreement, the Java Specification Participation Agreement (JSPA).

Myriad says it was forced to license Sun's HotSpot reference implementation of Java along with the accompanying TCK at a cost to the company since 2004 of $120m and customers overcharged $100m.

Myriad claims it's a global leader in mobile technology, with its mobile browsers, widget, messaging, and other mobile platform technologies shipping with more than 3.7 billion applications on more than 2.2 billion phones.

Myriad is asking the court to force Oracle to honor a perpetual royalty free license to the TCKs, ban the company from collecting royalties, provide access to the Java TCKs, and stop the assertion of IP rights in a way that prevents Myriad from proving its Java is compliant. Myriad's also seeking a "disgorgement" of the $120m plus damages.

Over to Oracle, who's also claimed there's been a breach of agreement, along with unfair competition and infringement of Oracle trademarks and copyright. Oracle lodged its case on the other coast, filing with a court in the Northern District of California.

Oracle focused on Sun's community and commercial licenses and the fact that- according to Oracle - Myriad continued to use its old TCKs and ship product as Java compliant despite the expiration of a Master Support Agreement on June 29, 2010.

By continuing to ship Java products, Oracle claims Myriad is competing unfairly, infringing on its copyrights, and it claims that Myriad can no longer use the Java brand. Oracle also claimed that Myriad owes $3.5m in royalties under various commercial licenses, with the company being guilty of "deliberate and willful failure to pay" these royalties.

Oracle is seeking damages of more than $150,000, and it wants Myriad to destroy any and all TCKs it might be using to test and certify its implementation of Java.

Myriad's case ties into the simmering dispute between Oracle and Google – not to mention to dispute between Oracle and the Apache Software Foundation (ASF). Oracle has refused to grant Apache a Java for the TCK to certify its independent implementation of Java Standard Edition, called Project Harmony. A version of Harmony's used by Google's Android in the phone operating system's Java Virtual Machine (JVM) called Dalvik.

Apache has resigned from the JCP to protest the restrictions Oracle placed on the TCKs, after fellow JCP members except Google and one independent voted in favor an Oracle Java roadmap without forcing any changes to the accompanying Java license. Apache also claims Oracle has broken the JSPA by not granting its independent Java implementation a license.

Meanwhile, Google is being sued by Oracle, who alleges that Android violates the Java patents it bought with Sun.

It's possible Myriad has sprung into action to help prove a test case for Google and Apache against Oracle in the US courts, and settle the issue of over the JSPA and field-of-use restrictions imposed on where and how Java is used and licensed. The field of use restrictions pre-date Oracle, having started under Sun but have now passed to Oracle.

Adding some conspiracy theory spice is the fact Myriad offers something called Dalvik Turbo, that it calls "a seamless, high performance replacement for the Android Dalvik Virtual Machine increasing application execution speed by up to five times.

It also offers Myriad J2Android, which Myriad calls "a simple and efficient converter for MIDlets" that lets "phone manufacturers, mobile operators and mobile application stores can bring thousands of existing Java applications to Android devices."

Intellectual property activist Florian Mueller has pointed out here that Myriad is represented by law firm Potter, Anderson, Corroon and King and Spalding. The latter is also defending Google against Oracle's on Android.

Rating Myriad's chances, Mueller pointed out FRAN would not necessarily have granted Myriad unfettered access to the TCKs its fighting over. "Field-of-use restrictions come with many FRAND licenses, so one cannot claim categorically that such restrictions constitute a failure to honor FRAND licensing commitments. It really depends on the specifics of the case," he said.

He said Myriad, Google, and Apache are likely tackling Oracle from different directions, to wear down its position.

"There's Google, which claims as part of its defense against Oracle's patent infringement suit that it's entitled to do what it does. There's Apache, an open source entity. A non-profit that represents a part of the community. And now there's Myriad, which raises unfair competition issues and claims that it has suffered economic harm," Mueller said. ®

Bridging the IT gap between rising business demands and ageing tools

More from The Register

next story
NO MORE ALL CAPS and other pleasures of Visual Studio 14
Unpicking a packed preview that breaks down ASP.NET
DARPA-derived secure microkernel goes open source tomorrow
Hacker-repelling, drone-protecting code will soon be yours to tweak as you see fit
Cheer up, Nokia fans. It can start making mobes again in 18 months
The real winner of the Nokia sale is *drumroll* ... Nokia
Put down that Oracle database patch: It could cost $23,000 per CPU
On-by-default INMEMORY tech a boon for developers ... as long as they can afford it
Google shows off new Chrome OS look
Athena springs full-grown from Chromium project's head
Apple: We'll unleash OS X Yosemite beta on the MASSES on 24 July
Starting today, regular fanbois will be guinea pigs, it tells Reg
HIDDEN packet sniffer spy tech in MILLIONS of iPhones, iPads – expert
Don't panic though – Apple's backdoor is not wide open to all, guru tells us
prev story

Whitepapers

Designing a Defense for Mobile Applications
Learn about the various considerations for defending mobile applications - from the application architecture itself to the myriad testing technologies.
Implementing global e-invoicing with guaranteed legal certainty
Explaining the role local tax compliance plays in successful supply chain management and e-business and how leading global brands are addressing this.
Top 8 considerations to enable and simplify mobility
In this whitepaper learn how to successfully add mobile capabilities simply and cost effectively.
Seven Steps to Software Security
Seven practical steps you can begin to take today to secure your applications and prevent the damages a successful cyber-attack can cause.
Boost IT visibility and business value
How building a great service catalog relieves pressure points and demonstrates the value of IT service management.