The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Feeds
85%
Cyberlink

Cyberlink v. Nero media authoring suites

Taste the difference

  • print
  • alert

Requirements Checklist for Choosing a Cloud Backup and Recovery Service Provider

Review Back in the day, Cyberlink was best known for DVD player software, while Nero was a developer of CD-writing ('burning') utilities. Now both companies are producers of very successful creative multimedia suites that play DVDs, burn discs and a whole lot more. For an embarrassingly low price, both packages offer audio, video and image editing along with media file management, DVD and Blu-ray video authoring and playback, plus disc burning, label design and data backup. But which suite is better?

Cyberlink

Cyberlink Media Suite PowerStarter looks slick and presents the tasks you want to do
Click for a larger image

Suite Launcher

Cyberlink and Nero have designed launchers utilities, which you might assume to be a bit childish, yet when faced with juggling a dozen unfamiliar programs in the Start menu, you soon realise how valuable these launchers are. Cyberlink's Media Suite PowerStarter is a slick, task-based program launcher with attractive animated visuals. Once you get a better idea of the programs that make up the suite, you can add your most commonly used tasks to a 'Favourites' section for even quicker access.

Nero

Nero StartSmart fails to offer simple tasks, preferring wordy explanations instead
Click for a larger image

Nero's StartSmart can be confusing, for example, clicking on 'Create Video and Photo Slide Show' doesn’t let you edit video at all. For that, you click on the ‘Advanced' option, then Neo Vision Xtra opens, asking what you want to do... which seems to negate the whole point of having a launcher to begin with.

Media file management

Both suites provide a program for browsing and organising photos, videos and audio files. Nero MediaHub is a clean, uncomplicated browser with resizeable thumbnails. You can switch quickly between Music, Photos and Videos, while also being able to manage playlists and set up attractive slideshows. The Search field locates files quickly, and you can sort them in a number of ways. Alas, you can’t add metadata tags, flags or ratings for additional organisation.

Nero

Nero MediaHub is limited to browsing but you can trigger a disc burn directly from here
Click for a larger image

More useful is the way you can use the program for importing images from connected cameras by clicking on the 'Import from Device' button. You can also open images for editing and send selected files for burning to disc or uploading to the Internet from the main window.

Cloud storage: Lower cost and increase uptime

But I don't want either of them

I really don't like this monolithic approach. It seems a bit like world domination to me.

I look at either of these, and the density of what I'm being asked to absorb just makes my brain shut down. Why would I want a disc burner that edits video? It's like going to buy a car and being offered something that has helicopter blades and a JCB digging arm on the back. Your first thought will be 'it won't fly well, and you can't do much digging with that blade whizzing round".

I use programmes that do one thing well, like Brasero or CDBurnerXP. If I want to edit MP3 tags, I use Kid3-qt. If I want to edit audio use audacity. To rip CDs I use Rythmbox or EAC

I can't believe that any of these huge bundles of software are really very good at everything they try to do. And I worry that they devote so much time to bit-twiddling graphical apps that they forget to pay attention to the basic task of burning discs.

6
0

Why?

Expensive, pointless bloatware the pair of them.

Neither have been useful for years.

I wouldnt even bother paying £4 for the OEM versions.

A couple of freeware apps from ninite.com that weigh in at maybe 30Mb each and away you go.

Printing labels for CDs....how very turn of the century. Scribble on em with a felt-tip like everyone else.

3
0

How cleanly do these install?

One element I would like to see in these kind of software reviews is: how much crap do these suites want to install, such as, start-up services to scan for media, automatic update downloaders, etc etc

How difficult is it, really, to create software that does not crap all over my boot-up time and my running processes? I want software that will run only run after I click on the icon, not every freaking time i boot my computer!

3
0

More from The Register

Interwebs taunt Sir Jony over Apple eye candy makeover
Hey Ive, Ive... add more unicorns, willya?
Apple: iOS7 dayglo Barbie makeover is UNFINISHED - report
Plus: You don't like the icons? Blame marketing
Red Hat to ditch MySQL for MariaDB in RHEL 7
So long, Oracle! Don't let the door hit you on the way out
Java EE 7 melds HTML5 with enterprise apps
New release arrives with GlassFish, NetBeans support
 breaking news
'Office Facebook' firm Tibbr wants you to PAY for mobe-meetings app
Great idea. Punters won't cough for it though
SCO vs. IBM battle resumes over ownership of Unix
Zombie lawsuit back and wants to suck the brains out of Linux
 breaking news
The only Waze is Google: Ad giant tipped to gobble map app 'for $1.3bn'
Pac-Man-satnav-ish upstart in bidding war with Apple, Facebook
 breaking news
PM Cameron calls for modern, programmable computers! (We think)
IT education musings to G8 chiefs to mystify IT industry
Apple at WWDC: Sleek new iOS, death of the big cats, pint-sized Mac Pro
CEO Cook: 'The biggest change to iOS since the introduction of the iPhone'
Chrome and Firefox are planet-wreckers, IE cuddles dolphins
Microsoft-commissioned study finds IE sucks less power than rival browsers