Feeds

Does FCoE really need TRILL?

Cisco says no - so?

Designing a Defense for Mobile Applications

Comment Does Fibre Channel over Ethernet (FCoE) require TRILL (Transparent Interconnection of Lots of Links)? Brocade and NetApp say or imply it does. A distinguished engineer from Cisco says it doesn't.

The background to the issue is that FCoE is going to run over Ethernet networks and these run at layer 2 in the OSI 7-layer network reference model, lacking routing and multi-pathing; having more than one link between switches. Both of these issues are separate from the carrying of Fibre Channel frames inside Ethernet frames and having them cross the Ethernet network without frames being dropped, a showstopper for Fibre Channel fabric-using applications.

The routing is needed for multi-hop FCoE.

A Brocade FCoE handbook (pdf) states: "TRILL provides a Layer 2 (L2) multi-path alternative to the single path and network bandwidth limiting Spanning Tree Protocol (STP), currently deployed in data centre networks.

TRILL will also deliver L2 multi-hop routing capabilities, which are essential for expanding the deployment of DCB/FCoE solutions beyond access layer server I/O consolidation and into larger data centre networks."

A NetApp document (pdf) states: "TRILL is a new draft standard being created by IETF to accommodate FCoE converged networks and is scheduled to be completed later this year.

"The goal of TRILL is to create an L2 shortest path robust multipath and mult-ihop routing protocol that eventually will replace the limited and restricted L3 STP. The more resilient L2 will fulfill the needs of 10Gb Ethernet networks with virtualised ecosystem and data migration. TRILL will also enable multi-hop capabilities for FCoE environments."

The implied conclusion here is that TRILL is needed for multi-hop FCoE networks beyond access layer concentration.

Lincoln Dale, a Cisco distinguished engineer, says: “TRILL is not needed for FCoE; the reason is simple: Spanning Tree (STP) is NOT used for FCoE, at all, ever."

He adds: "From a NetApp perspective, TRILL is neither here nor there,  because TRILL is something that is done on a 'network' port (switch to switch), you still have 'classical Ethernet' behaviour on 'edge' ports. I think the paper basically says the same thing.

"The paper does talk about TRILL as being the 'replacement' for STP - I agree with that, but it implies that its necessary for 'multi-hop FCoE'.  That is not correct."

"There is nothing preventing multi-hop FCoE today.  it is part of the FC-BB-5 (FCoE) standard. What it requires are the 'unified I/O' switches to support it. There is no pre-requisite for STP - or TRILL - because FCoE is based on FC-BB-5 which uses all the FC [Fibre Channel] aspects to provide a switch and its services."

Interestingly Cisco is going to support TRILL with a software upgrade for its Nexus 7000 F-Series I/O module, saying: "It supports the Data Centre Bridging and TRILL standards with Fibre Channel over Ethernet (FCoE) to be enabled in the near future through a software upgrade." ®

The Power of One eBook: Top reasons to choose HP BladeSystem

More from The Register

next story
Apple fanbois SCREAM as update BRICKS their Macbook Airs
Ragegasm spills over as firmware upgrade kills machines
Auntie remains MYSTIFIED by that weekend BBC iPlayer and website outage
Still doing 'forensics' on the caching layer – Beeb digi wonk
Attack of the clones: Oracle's latest Red Hat Linux lookalike arrives
Oracle's Linux boss says Larry's Linux isn't just for Oracle apps anymore
THUD! WD plonks down SIX TERABYTE 'consumer NAS' fatboy
Now that's a LOT of porn or pirated movies. Or, you know, other consumer stuff
EU's top data cops to meet Google, Microsoft et al over 'right to be forgotten'
Plan to hammer out 'coherent' guidelines. Good luck chaps!
US judge: YES, cops or feds so can slurp an ENTIRE Gmail account
Crooks don't have folders labelled 'drug records', opines NY beak
Manic malware Mayhem spreads through Linux, FreeBSD web servers
And how Google could cripple infection rate in a second
prev story

Whitepapers

Designing a Defense for Mobile Applications
Learn about the various considerations for defending mobile applications - from the application architecture itself to the myriad testing technologies.
How modern custom applications can spur business growth
Learn how to create, deploy and manage custom applications without consuming or expanding the need for scarce, expensive IT resources.
Reducing security risks from open source software
Follow a few strategies and your organization can gain the full benefits of open source and the cloud without compromising the security of your applications.
Boost IT visibility and business value
How building a great service catalog relieves pressure points and demonstrates the value of IT service management.
Consolidation: the foundation for IT and business transformation
In this whitepaper learn how effective consolidation of IT and business resources can enable multiple, meaningful business benefits.