Feeds

Sunbelt buckles up for anti-bloatware drive

Slow, fat rivals taken to task

Top 5 reasons to deploy VMware with Tegile

The anti-virus bloatware problem is getting worse despite what some vendors may claim, according to figures from Sunbelt Software.

The Florida based vendor's marketing claims tap into a deep well of discontent about anti-virus products but are not supported by the latest results from independent testing labs, such as AV-Test.org, and therefore ought to be treated with caution.

What's not in dispute is that slow, bloated anti-virus engines chew up system resources. The problem has been a continual source of frustration for Windows users for years, and something their Mac and Linux-using peers always cite in operating system arguments.

Worse yet, each new version of the leading Windows anti-virus products from Symantec, Trend and McAfee et al can increases the demand on CPU and memory by a significant factor, Sunbelt claims. This can effectively reduce the useful life of existing machines which, according to Sunbelt, need 20 per cent more grunt (extra CPU power and RAM) for each update.

Lip up fatty

Vendors such as Trend and Symantec have publicly acknowledged that their products have been resource hogs in the past. Since Norton AntiVirus 2008, Symantec has developed technology so that its software uses less computing resources. Sunbelt brags that even these competing products still use triple the memory of Sunbelt’s comparable Vipre Software.

End-users have complained about the bloatware problem for years but it's a discussion vendors have historically avoided, much like the members of a weight watchers club might diplomatically avoid comparing dress sizes. Sunbelt's internal figures - which have not been subjected to independent testing - serve at least as a starting point in a decision that's long overdue.

Sunbelt's internal research compared the performance and resource utilisation of the most popular commercial enterprise antivirus products on the market: McAfee VirusScan v8.7.0.155, Sophos Enterprise Security and Control v3.1, Trend Micro OfficeScan v8.0+SP1_R3, Symantec Endpoint Protection v11.0.2010.7, Webroot AntiSpyware Corporate Edition with AntiVirus v3.5.1 and Sunbelt Vipre Enterprise v3.1.2978. Each were tested on a two-year-old machine with a 2.8 GHz Intel Processor and 1GB of memory, running Windows XP Pro SP3 with MS Office 10.

Vipre Enterprise used 27 per cent of CPU resources during a manual scan compared to more than 70 per cent for Webroot, 57 per cent for Sophos and around 46 per cent for Sophos and Trend. McAfee came the closest with around 29 per cent.

However, McAfee used 130 MB of RAM during a manual scan, compared to VIPRE Enterprise use of only 49 MB RAM. Symantec 118 MB RAM usage during the process compared to 75MB RAM for Sophos and 62MB for Trend Micro.

Sunbelt also makes a direct speed comparison between the speed of scanning of its software and that of arch-rival Webroot. Vipre Enterprise's scan Speed was 13.95 MB/Sec on the test hardware, with 26 per cent CPU utilisation compared to Webroot's 16.54 MB/sec using 72 per cent CPU during a manual scan.

Level playing track?

These are internal tests, since applied to marketing purposes, and ought to be viewed with caution as a result. Symantec Endpoint Protection has firewall features that may be absent in other products, such as Sunbelt's Vipre, and this needs to be factored into consideration when considering the tests.

Sunbelt said it turned off Symantec's firewall during the test.

Phil Owens, a sales engineer at Sunbelt Software, said that the efforts of rival security firms to control bloatware have so far been focused on consumer products.

"Symantec has been making efforts on the consumer side, but it hasn't yet moved these improvements to the enterprise side which is where the issue of bloatware is most prevalent,” Owens said.

“McAfee uses a lot of different components and add ons (ie an Antivirus agent on the users PC, an antispyware module and an EPO agent); whilst it acknowledges it is an issue it needs to address it seemingly hasn't taken too many steps in the right direction to rectify it."

Rival products can start off OK then gradually get slower as additional updates are applied. This depends on their architecture, Owens explained.

Security for virtualized datacentres

Next page: Testing times

More from The Register

next story
'Kim Kardashian snaps naked selfies with a BLACKBERRY'. *Twitterati gasps*
More alleged private, nude celeb pics appear online
Home Depot ignored staff warnings of security fail laundry list
'Just use cash', former security staffer warns friends
Hackers pop Brazil newspaper to root home routers
Step One: try default passwords. Step Two: Repeat Step One until success
UK.gov lobs another fistful of change at SME infosec nightmares
Senior Lib Dem in 'trying to be relevant' shocker. It's only taxpayers' money, after all
Who.is does the Harlem Shake
Blame it on LOLing XSS terroristas
Snowden, Dotcom, throw bombs into NZ election campaign
Claim of tapped undersea cable refuted by Kiwi PM as Kim claims extradition plot
Freenode IRC users told to change passwords after securo-breach
Miscreants probably got in, you guys know the drill by now
THREE QUARTERS of Android mobes open to web page spy bug
Metasploit module gobbles KitKat SOP slop
BitTorrent's peer-to-peer chat app Bleep goes live as public alpha
A good day for privacy as invisble.im also reveals its approach to untraceable chats
prev story

Whitepapers

Providing a secure and efficient Helpdesk
A single remote control platform for user support is be key to providing an efficient helpdesk. Retain full control over the way in which screen and keystroke data is transmitted.
A strategic approach to identity relationship management
ForgeRock commissioned Forrester to evaluate companies’ IAM practices and requirements when it comes to customer-facing scenarios versus employee-facing ones.
Saudi Petroleum chooses Tegile storage solution
A storage solution that addresses company growth and performance for business-critical applications of caseware archive and search along with other key operational systems.
WIN a very cool portable ZX Spectrum
Win a one-off portable Spectrum built by legendary hardware hacker Ben Heck
The next step in data security
With recent increased privacy concerns and computers becoming more powerful, the chance of hackers being able to crack smaller-sized RSA keys increases.