The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: Google starts selling unlocked G1

Delivery 

Posted Monday 8th December 2008 17:59 GMT

Have they formed an alliance with Dell or what?!

unlocked 

Posted Monday 8th December 2008 18:08 GMT

Linux

The phone is supposed to be for developers.

Moreover, one of the interest for developers is that the bootloader is specific and allows you to completely reflash the OS.

And for shipping costs, read the small lines ...

"Outside the US

For Orders shipping outside the US, shipping pricing includes cost of

shipping service and the applicable customs, duties, import and

country specific other fees."

why the hell 

Posted Monday 8th December 2008 18:34 GMT

Thumb Down

would you want to feed the googlebeast?

@Alex 

Posted Monday 8th December 2008 18:58 GMT

Alert

Because you want to do business with a company which produces products that work better than anything else out there?

Remember when Google Maps came out? The best that the other mapping people could do was 'click here to scroll left... in thirty seconds. Maybe. By half a screen length.' Then they'd added satellite view before the rest had done smooth scrolling, and then added the ability to look around at street level - which, despite El Reg's bizarre (and ironic, given their home country) obsession with cameras, is a really *fucking* useful tool if you're trying to find your way around, say, Manhattan.

Oh, and gMail? And let's not forget that little search thing.

That's why you'd want to feed the googlebeast. If there's gonna be a beast, it might as well be one that's so fucking GOOD at what it does.

I don't buy it 

Posted Monday 8th December 2008 19:24 GMT

These things are built in china, like everything else.. the whole 'outside the US' thing is just an excuse to charge a premium.

Hell it doesn't normally cost that even direct from the US via UPS (which I would never use anyway because the have a habit of slapping extra charges on the recipient for fun). No idea where they're getting numbers like that from.

typical ebay scam 

Posted Monday 8th December 2008 19:54 GMT

half decent prices and rip-off shipping.

No doubt there will also be VAT to pay...

Sam

So, like, an open phone that actually works? 

Posted Monday 8th December 2008 21:10 GMT

I suppose this is a stupid question, but one likes to know for sure - does this mean that I can buy this and then put Debian on it with little to no fuss? And thereby get the equivalent of an Openmoko Freerunner that actually, y'know, works, and has a hardware keyboard to boot, albeit at half the screen resolution? Because if so, I'm sold...

woaha Wiernicki!! 

Posted Monday 8th December 2008 22:18 GMT

"Because you want to do business with a company which produces products that work better than anything else out there?"

googleshill?

seriously, its not that good, there's considerably better GPS systems than googlemaps and isn't manhattan just a big grid? gmail, not really particularly amazing now is it, be honest! and as for that search thing, don't believe the hype Dave!

if you don't mind being tracked 247 and your (highly detailed) profile (inc movements) being sold to the highest bidder you carry on. Its touching to see how they love the googlebeast.

Sucky frequencies 

Posted Monday 8th December 2008 22:31 GMT

Stop

Watch out for the frequencies on the 3G bands, it only uses 1700/2100, which makes it useless for anybody in Canada or South America.

http://brad.livejournal.com/2399739.html?thread=15222011&style=mine#t15222011

@Alex (re "woaha Wiernicki!!") 

Posted Tuesday 9th December 2008 02:51 GMT

I'm not totally sure about this, but I thought David Wiernicki's larger point was that you're basically being tracked, butt-probed, and sold to the highest bidder anyway. So that being the case, you might as well go with the one that allegedly provides at least some kind of halfway-useful service in exchange. And although I'm not totally sold on that line, I don't really think there exists a single provider that DOESN'T basically view you as just an insignificant little morsel of meat to be sucked dry and spat out. So if the Googlebeast gives you something of value, why not?

@ Anonymous 

Posted Tuesday 9th December 2008 11:46 GMT

Thumb Up

Yes, you could put Debian on it --- that's just a matter of wiping the userland and replacing it --- but you may not want to; in order to be a functional phone you'll need to load the radio stack software onto the other processor, have a UI for making calls, etc, and AFAIK that's all done by the userland. If you just want an ARM in a box that'll run code, I'd suggest the BeagleBoard instead, which is a lot cheaper (and, interestingly enough, will run Android).

@David Given 

Posted Tuesday 9th December 2008 16:29 GMT

Thank you for clarifying that.

Regarding the BeagleBoard idea, I'd love to do something like that... In fact, "an ARM box that'll run code" is precisely what I want, with, as Kryten would say, just two small problems: I have yet to find anyone, anywhere who will actually sell a 640x480 (or even 800x480) LCD in the ten to thirteen centimeter size range in unlts of fewer than a bazillion at a time. I know that I could, if I wanted to put up with the baked-in suck and lock-down, theoretically get a Sharp Zaurus or a Nokia N810, but both seem horribly crippled by design in so many ways. My Google-fu fails me.

So... You wouldn't happen to know where I could get such a thing (specifically, the LCD), would you? I mean, all the OTHER necessary hardware (BeagleBoard, Gumstix, other parts, etc) is all available, but as far as I can tell, not a screen to go with it.

Sign up, sign up for The Register's weekly mobile & wireless newsletter - click here

Don’t Miss