The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: Stratus fault tolerants embrace cut-rate VMware

Not quite 

Posted Wednesday 3rd December 2008 08:36 GMT

Boffin

"With fault tolerant architectures, server components are doubled up and cross-coupled in such a way as to present a single image to end users, with the two duplicate systems running in absolute lockstep."

That's a fair description of the way Stratus provides a fault-tolerant hardware platform. Tandem's approach is more software based, with keep alive messages between duplicate software instances allowing seamless takeover from a failed process. No lock-stepped CPUs are involved.

There are advantages and disadvantages to each. It's more difficult to port third party apps to a Tandem platform, but OTOH software is a much more frequent cause of system failures than is hardware.

Re: Not quite 

Posted Wednesday 3rd December 2008 12:30 GMT

Happy

I believe that the observation "Tandem's approach is more software based, with keep alive messages between duplicate software instances allowing seamless takeover from a failed process. No lock-stepped CPUs are involved." is not quite right.

Tandem does use lock-stepped processors; a pair forms a single 'self-checked' processor. Each of the primary and secondary processes (forming a duplicate software unit with keep alive messages etc ) runs on a distinct 'self-checked' processor.

Don’t Miss

HP LogoWill HP 3PAR high-end storage arrays?

Comment Crossroads for ex-EMC man Dave Donatelli

3comHPcom spells 'IT disaster,' says UK firm

Save the 3Com customers foundation

Data centre boxesEurope clamours for data centre capacity

Price rises on the way

AMD lays out 2011 PC roadmap

Bobcat riding a Bulldozer