Sky mulls PVR software rollback
Blames problems on hardware modders
Updated Sky is considering reversing an update to the software on its PVR boxes after it froze customers out of the programme guide and left them unable to record TV.
The update to Sky+ boxes, described as minor by the firm, was pushed last week over the air. Customers noticed the OS version number had changed when they were locked out last Tuesday.
A spokesman said the problem continues to affect customers who have carried out a DIY hard disk upgrade to one of its set-top box models, which is installed in about five per cent of the more than four million Sky+ homes. He refused to name the model, but forum discussions point to the Pace V2, which came with only 40GB of storage.
Sky sent this statement:
We regularly upgrade the software in Sky+ boxes as part of routine maintenance and product enhancements. All software is tested rigorously against each hardware type of the box before being downloaded to customers' boxes.
We're investigating reports from a small number of Sky+ customers whose boxes are experiencing problems following a recent software update. Although our investigation is continuing, the problem appears to be isolated to a small minority of owners of a particular type of box, which in turn represents about 5 per cent of all Sky+ boxes. After reviewing call centre data and customer feedback, it appears that in the vast majority of cases the boxes concerned have had their hard disk drive changed for a non-standard component.
While our investigation continues, we are reviewing whether to reverse the software update to provide a short-term fix for the affected boxes. We'll consider longer-term steps once we've confirmed the scope of the problem.
Sky said it would carry out more testing today, and hopes to know whether to go ahead with the rollback by tonight.
Some people affected by the problems were told by call centre staff they would need a £65 engineer call-out to fix their box. Sky says customers shouldn't modify their set-top box, as it invalidates the warranty in the first year and makes it impossible to know for sure if software updates are bug-free later. ®
Update Thursday November 26
Sky indeed reversed the update last night and users report it has fixed the problem. Many Reg correspondents dispute Sky's version of events however, and say their unmodified Pace V2 was borked by the new software.
@Not just DIY Sky+ boxes
>>"t is not just the DIY modded boxes that have been affected, those which have the original disk as supplied by Sky have also been affected."
>>"In typical Sky fashion, they have ignored the full facts and acknowledge only what they perceive to be the issue."
Funny, I thought that in the quoted statement they actually said:
>>"..it appears that in the vast majority of cases the boxes concerned have had their hard disk drive changed for a non-standard component."
Which I took to mean that they were acknowledging that some unmodded boxes *were* affected.
Maybe only a fraction of unmodded boxes were affected.
Maybe modders are more likely to notice, and complain early and often.
Maybe Sky *were* putting a bit of anti-mod spin on the real figures.
And as for the conspiracy angle, it's hard to see what would be the point of breaking modded boxes. Even if secrecy was guaranteed (unlikely) Pace and Sky would seem likely to lose a fair bit and gain nothing obvious.
It's working again...!
I woke this morning to find my box was in Standby mode even though I've left it switched on the past few days to ensure this problem didn't arise, but, after pressing the on button in trepidation, I'm pleased to confirm that it's working properly again.
Hopefully (hah!) Sky will learn from this...
Rollback done ?
Some people on the Digital Spy forum are saying that their boxes have now been rolled back to the old software and it has cleared the problem.
I haven't had a chance to check mine to confirm though.
THEY'VE DONE IT!
Sky have rolled back the software to the previous version overnight (26th-27th). Everyone (so far) on the Digitalspy forum is reporting that this has fixed the issues. Thanks to El Reg for running the story - I am not sure it would have happened otherwise.
Btw it was not just modified boxes. I suspect there aren't many unmodified ones around any more but there were reports that unmodified units had the same problems.
Woke up this morning to find my Pace PVR2 has had its software rolled back to the previous version.