The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: iPod cans menace pacemakers

cellular phones .... 

Posted Monday 10th November 2008 12:26 GMT

Alert

Vibrate alert? In a top pocket? The magnets in those things are surely many times as powerful as headphones!

Once again... 

Posted Monday 10th November 2008 12:30 GMT

Thumb Down

Once again, researchers (or maybe just Reg hacks) put the word "iPod" in the headline to attract as much attention to their "study/news", even though it applies equally to ANY headphones with magnets in them (pretty much all of them?).

It's been known for a long time that magnets can affect pacemakers - it's nothing new - so ANYTHING with magnets in could potentially cause problems, not just iPod headphones.

What's next? A report that concludes that rubbing your chest against the magnetic latch on a laptop (Macbook of course) is not advisable?

Or perhaps we need pacemaker warnings on fridge magnets in case you put one in your shirt pocket on the way home from whatever cheesy tourist attraction you visited?

MP3 players? 

Posted Monday 10th November 2008 12:32 GMT

Boffin

So these boffins are only concerned about "the magnets in iPod headphones and those used by other MP3 devices"? The headphones I hook up to my PC are safe? Or does it depend whether WinAmp happens to be playing an MP3 or a FLAC file? I guess it must be some feature specific to the MP3 format which interferes with pacemakers. Very strange.

cheap marketing trick from The Register 

Posted Monday 10th November 2008 12:34 GMT

Mentioning iPod when its about ANY headphones regardless of what they are plugged in to ... in fact they probably don't even need to be plugged to cause the effect!

tut tut .. trying to drive page views.

News 

Posted Monday 10th November 2008 12:47 GMT

This can't be a new problem, or have headphone designs changed since the 80s?

Disk drive magnets 

Posted Monday 10th November 2008 13:00 GMT

Alert

They are f*cked if I start playing with my stash of disk drive magnets then! I used to gauss CRTs from the other side of a wall. It was fun!!

Some music 

Posted Monday 10th November 2008 13:08 GMT

Joke

really is heart stopping.

Brave or stupid? 

Posted Monday 10th November 2008 13:20 GMT

Paris Hilton

Where did they find those 60 people?!

Who on earth would allow some white-coated gimps to monkey around with the running of their heart!

"Don't worry mate, if your heart stops we'll try to get it going again. Hopefully we won't have broken the pacemaker. Here goes....."

/not even Paris would submit to that

Only Reg Hacks.... 

Posted Monday 10th November 2008 14:08 GMT

Alien

Can manage to make a piece about headphone magnets affecting medical equipment into a headline attacking Apple.

Just how low in the barrel are you guys scraping in your hatred for all things Apple?

An Alien, because its more relevant than this Apple-Bashing rag has become.

WARNING worlds most boring post 

Posted Monday 10th November 2008 14:30 GMT

This is a bad conclusion.

Pace makers need better shielding would be a more responsible conclusion.

After all picking up loudspeakers, wearing magnetized pendants and numerous other unpredictable activities would also have to be avoided.

No Icon cause nothing can save the mind numbing dullness of this post (Sorry)

FFS 

Posted Monday 10th November 2008 19:25 GMT

Dead Vulture

Don't propagate this nonsense, or next time I go to the doctor's clinic I'll see a notice saying 'PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR I-POD TO PROTECT VISITORS WITH PACEMAKERS', accompanied with a suitably naff clip art picture of a 1960's tape recorder and headphones.

It's just like mobile phones at petrol stations all over again.

magnets 

Posted Tuesday 11th November 2008 08:34 GMT

Coat

surely all magnets will do this not just those in earbuds. So.... the magnets in your Feder Stratocaster, which of course you hold across your chest , will do the same and standing beside your floor standing HiFi speakers will also do the same ... but what a way to go!!!!!!

Don’t Miss