Hands on with SanDisk's SlotMusic SD-not-CD player
Crazy or canny?
First Look SanDisk's upcoming
cassette Micro SD personal stereo, SlotMusic, will be coming to the UK and the rest of Europe early next year, Register Hardware can reveal after having a play with the gadget.
The ciggie-lighter sized player is a model of simplicity: a Micro SD slot at one end, 3.5mm earphone socket and power key at the other. On one edge you'll find the play/pause and track skip keys, all implemented as simple rubber covered switches.
There's no display, but SanDisk sees the SlotMusic Player as a single-album device. The main body section is actually a slide-off U-shaped sleeve, and each album comes with a sleeve-shaped sticker: peel it off and slap it on the sleeve, and not only do you have the album art on the front, but a track list on the back so you can skip to the track you want.
SanDisk will sell the SlotMusic Player bundled with an album, so the US price of $35 includes a $15 album, so the hardware's actually only $20. In addition to the album art, there's a generic SlotMusic sleeve sticker.
SanDisk's SlotMusic Player: cheap and cheerful
Removing the sleeve reveales the Player's battery bay: it takes a single AA alkaline battery, included with the Player, so you're ready to go and there's no need to ever connect it to a computer. Actually, you can't - there's no USB, for starters - but that's the whole point.
Each SlotMusic card is 1GB in capacity, and the Player will take generic Micro SDs of up to 2GB. The songs are stored in 320Kb/s MP3 format, so there's no DRM and you're free to play the tracks on other devices, copy them, back them up, format the card etc. The Player's own sound quality isn't great but it is adequate.
In the States, SanDisk is partnering with WalMart and BestBuy to sell Players and SlotMusic albums. Over here, no retailers have yet - publicly, at any rate - been signed up, but SanDisk say it's talking to all the major music retailers, from specialists like HMV and Zavvi to generalists like bookshop chains and grocers.
The Micro SD SlotMusic card comes in a small plastic case, itself inside a CD-style jewel case. Packaging overkill, yes, but it's retail friendly, allowing SlotMusic racks to show up as well as CD racks do, and even be stacked among the discs - with suitable 'does not contain a CD' messaging, we hope.
SanDisk also reckons buyers will want to stack their SlotMusic purchases with their CD library, which is another reason why it's packaging the products in CD jewel cases.
Not only does SlotMusic use an entirely open and accessible music format but SanDisk also says it's publishing the spec - such as it is - to allow other Micro SD vendors to strike deals with labels and release SlotMusic albums of their own.
The company's not daft - it knows it needs more widespread adoption of the format if SlotMusic is to become the de facto successor to the CD it wants it to be.
It also knows it needs consumers, and it believes there are plenty of folk out there who either aren't yet ripping CDs to PCs and copying the songs to players. Some are just uncomfortable with the process - we know people who do this for non-techie partners. Other people simply don't want the hassle - they want to buy an album, slot it into the player and start listening immediately.
SlotMusic albums also bundle a very slim USB adaptor, so Micro SD cards can be plugged into in-car hi-fis and other music playback devices with USB slots. Again, SanDisk reckons the format will appeal to people already using these methods.
A Micro SD card rebranded
We're not convinced there's a long-term future for SlotMusic, but it's certainly the case that CD sales - purchases of physical, tactile media - still outweigh downloads. If plenty of punters still buy CDs rather than downloads, it's plausible that SanDisk can persuade them to buy memory cards instead. Plenty of CD buyers don't rip their discs as soon as they get them home.
CD, of course, is supported by a huge array of players, and most folk own a CD playback device of some kind. But there are a fair few phones out there with Micro SD slots, and SanDisk sees SlotMusic appealing to owners of these devices as much as anyone else.
Will it work? It might, and it's going to be interesting to see how SanDisk promotes the platform. It seems a crazy idea to people who download at the drop of a hat, but they're not the target audience. As we say, there a lot of music consumers who aren't downloading. Maybe now they never will.
We're sceptical, but SlotMusic is going to make an interesting experiment.
Think before you type
Techies say it's not for them? Ever thought that you might not be the market they are after?
The fact that it uses regular batteries makes it obvious they they are going for the non-techie market. For teenage girls whose limit of technology is using Facebook at college, this is ideal. Looking good always comes over features for them, so something they can customise would be popular. A cheap player, with media that can be bought in the shops. It's like a tiny CD player that never skips and you don't need a PC. If it breaks, gets lost or stolen, you buy a new one for a tenner. When you look at all the other places you can use the microSD cards (many phones, in anything that accepts USB, in anything that accepts SD cards) the player actually becomes less significant than the media. If they put uncompressed wav on there too (loads of spare space, seems silly not to) then they pretty much have all the benefits of CDs but you can take anywhere in a tiny wallet, lending them without fear of them getting scratched.
If you realise you want more memory then you can buy one of the mp3 players that has a microSD slot or get a techie friend to copy them over (only has to be done once), still better than the DRM crap of itunes.
The thing that will hold this back is getting the market penetration. It looked like soemthing similar was going to happen with xD cards, but the high cost of them was too much back then. It's not something I'd ever buy for myself, but my daughter is into music a lot and I'd get her one of these cheap things over an expensive ipod anyday. If they could make the player half the size and with a radio for the same price then I might get one for myself as something that doesn't matter if I drop it in the river/mud/off a cliff. I can already use microSD in my mp3 player and my phone so it would just give me more flexibility.
upgrade and recharge: model fitting
1)All the good bits from my 100 CDs fit as mp3 downloads on a shuffle (728 Kb).
2)Currently (2008 - 2010) I'm downloading my vinyl at about 10 per week to mp3. And cursing the big 4 distributors, who don't have an upgrade policy (Actually its a downgrade but the mp3s are okay over headphones). I'll be blowed if I'll pay full CD price for the conversion, but perhaps 10% for nuisance value and 5% for better quality, and I'd willingly take them on micro SDs, even better on a few multi-Mb SDs.
3) A question: I assume home-recorded SDs also fit? Its not clear from the article. Most PC have an SD slot, and you can get a micro SD converter.
4) I'm not going back to rechargable batteries either, that's just as fiddly as ripping mp3s.
So all in all, maybe Sandisk can tweak their product to fit my profile
At 1GB of storage who says the music HAS to be compressed? The little chip stores more than a conventional CD. If the chip/media price continues to decline I could see this becoming a real alternative to buying CDs. Actually, I could see this replacing DVDs if the 8GB cards ever drop in price. No need to rip, it's already in digital form. If RIAA is telling the truth *cough cough* and you're paying for music, why NOT make it available in the form everyone already uses?
The SlotMusic player is still a FAIL. My SANSA View can do everything this thing does plus play movies (on a teeny tiny screen).