Comments on “Feds kills ATI and Nvidia price-fix probe” • The Register

Comments on: Feds kills ATI and Nvidia price-fix probe

Back to the article
Comments on this article are now closed

No case? #

By Henry Wertz Posted Tuesday 14th October 2008 01:23 GMT

Well, NVidia and ATI really don't have much competition* so I could see the DOJ looking into it. But, I think DOJ dropped it because they didn't have a case. ATI & Nvidia do have a natural duopoly right now simply because it's so expensive to get into the serious GPU-making business, If anything it seems like ATI and NVidia are in a massive price war, cranking out new modelss and dropping the old ones so fast to sub-$100 prices so fast.

*Competition: As far as I know, there's Intel's onboard, Via's onboard (which is more or less S3 Unichrome + extra MPEG-2 or H.264 decoding.. so not usable for 3D but nice for video playback). Matrox makes video cards for like medical, financial, and video wall use.. they basically specialize in multihead, the 4-head card with 3x splitters gets you a 12-head setup at 1280x1024 per head. What else is there for desktops right now? I haven't heard from XGI in a while (they were spun off of SiS's graphics division).

Just Me? #

By Anonymous Coward Posted Tuesday 14th October 2008 01:24 GMT

Is it just me or is this entirley wrong and tantamount to bribery.

U.S Gvmnt Legal Eagle: Hmm it appears to me that you have been artificially inflating you prices for shareholder gains.

Nvidia/Ati: No we haven't why we do shuch an underhand thing.

U.S Gvmnt Legal Eagle: Well on paper this all looks a bit shady.

Nvidia/Ati: But we've done nothing wrong, look, heres a hefty sum of cash we had floating around that proves it.

U.S Gvmnt Legal Eagle: Well it would appear you were right all along..... carry on.

Mines the one with unnusually large "slush-fund" in the pocket.

Where's the money? #

By Flocke Kroes Posted Tuesday 14th October 2008 04:45 GMT

Who got that $1.7M?

Waste #

By Anonymous Coward Posted Tuesday 14th October 2008 10:34 GMT

$1.7M to the FBI to pay for the investigation (lots of overtime, donuts etc.)

Virgin, BA et. al price fixed and left an audit trail. These "high tech" companies may have known better - just met in a Starbucks and agreed to fix prices.

Why is it so hard to enter this market - where are the Chinese / Indians when you need them ?

original class action plaintiffs only #

By Glyph Posted Wednesday 15th October 2008 12:55 GMT

Only the handful of straw men consumers and the lawyers you started it get the 850k, (looks like AMD may not have paid the settlement). It seems like class-action lawsuits occasionally give tiny handouts to all affected, but mostly just make a litigious few richer.

http://www.channelregister.co.uk/2008/09/30/nvidia_settles_lawsuit/