The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: Judge bans European-wide online music rights

Way to go 

Posted Friday 22nd August 2008 15:43 GMT

Joke

Way to go there, screwing up something that would have been good for the customer. Nice one !

European or Europe-wide? 

Posted Friday 22nd August 2008 16:44 GMT

Boffin

From the no-one's-more-pedantic-than-me dept. "European" doesn't have a width. Europe does, though. You can't, therefore, have something "European-wide". It's "Europe-wide".

Good for the customer? What the hell? 

Posted Friday 22nd August 2008 19:16 GMT

Wait, selling the rights to something they don't own is good for the customer? Huh?

Pyrhhic victory 

Posted Friday 22nd August 2008 19:43 GMT

You just know judgement will be overturned at a European level. And rightly so.

@Charlie Clark 

Posted Friday 22nd August 2008 22:13 GMT

"You just know judgement will be overturned at a European level."

Ah, so there is more to this European wide thing after all.

If all the Dutchmen go to a brown cafe, can we expect a European High as well?

@Ed 

Posted Sunday 24th August 2008 14:11 GMT

Boffin

It's not about selling something they don't own. Regardless of which "collection society" sells the license, the copyright holder gets their royalty. It's about which "collection society" gets a cut of the sale. The European Union competition commissioner Neelie Kroes's point is that under the traditional system, the artist was forced to use the collection society of their home country, who might not offer as good a deal as the collection society in another European country offers its artists. He wants some competition in the process, and under new EU rules, artists can shop between collection societies to get the best deal for themselves.

Translation time. 

Posted Monday 25th August 2008 11:41 GMT

Pirate

"PRS said that multi-territorial licensing is better left to market developments."

Or, put another way:

We'd prefer it if people just went off and did this to satisfy market demand with no legal backing. That way we get to sue the shit out of them and get paid twice instead of just the once.

Ar-har. Welcome to nuPiracy. We steal your booty *and* make you walk the plank.

PRS collections dept 

Posted Tuesday 26th August 2008 08:53 GMT

PRS are useless grasping fuckwits. They keep asking for money from my business that ceased trading years ago despite being told so by email. Once again, fuckwits.

Fit summation 

Posted Monday 1st September 2008 11:13 GMT

Pirate

@JIM: Stop SHOUTING and go back to bossing your ward: we're talking BUMA, not Burma -- the formely named country renamed by its military dictators to ghastly Myanmar -- and certainly not the BRUMA issued from your foggy head...

As for the newspiece, nothing to see here -- only the real pirates fighting for a piece of the loot...

The Black Jack, 'cause it's fitting.

JIM isn't going to get to Mars 

Posted Tuesday 2nd September 2008 20:19 GMT

I thought uneducated JIM was a prime example of why the Brits lost out in the space race.

One day he may realise his dream and become a man from mars.

Don’t Miss