The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Feeds

CE giants pitch yet another wireless HD standard

Will you welcome Wireless HDMI WiHD WHDI

Just what the world needs: another consortium promoting a wireless technology for the transmission of HD content in the home.

The latest is the Wireless Home Digital Interface (WHDI), launched today by Sony, Samsung, Hitachi, Motorola and Sharp.

WHDI's technology comes from Israeli company Amimon. It uses the 5GHz band to transmit uncompressed 1080p video, audio and control signals around the home from multiple sources to multiple receivers. All this data is beamed at up to 3Gb/s.

Amimon claimed WHDI's range is 30.5m. It can go through walls and has a latency of less than a millisecond.

The technology was developed specifically for video, Amimon said. It "takes the uncompressed HD video stream and breaks it into elements of importance. The various elements are then mapped onto the wireless channel in a way that give elements with more visual importance a greater share of the channel resources".

Audio and control data are "secured" against errors, so the video stream takes the impact when there's a transmission glitch.

How WHDI works

How WHDI works

"Any errors in the wireless channel are not noticed as they only affect the less important bits. Very high rates of video information can be transmitted because the human eye can tolerate the errors that fall on the less important bits."

That's what Amimon brings to the table - the other, rather bigger consumer electronics companies will oversee a Special Interest Group (SIG) that will develop the technology as a licensable, branded standard. They hope to offer it to other vendors sometime this year.

That will pitch it against the WirelessHD (WiHD) group, whose backers include Intel, LG, Matsushita, NEC, SiBEAM, Toshiba, and... er... Samsung and Sony. Clearly these two are hedging their bets on what is widely seen as the Next Big Thing in home entertainment: HD-capable wireless networking.

WiHD is based on technology developed by SiBEAM and operates in the 60GHz band to provide 5Gb/s of bandwidth for uncompressed HD video. But it requires a line of sight between transmitter and receiver, which rules it out as a multi-room system, at least in its own right.

Alongside WiHD, we have a selection of offerings that are essentially being used to deliver HDMI signalling over a wireless link, of which various types are employed by the different initiatives. Many are using the WiMedia Alliance's ultrawideband (UWB) infrastructure, so there's a measure of cross-vendor interoperability, though it's not guaranteed, which is probably why major vendors are looking at other initiatives, like WiHD and now WHDI, that can deliver true interoperability.

Wireless HDMI solutions, like Tzero's ZeroWire HDMI, use UWB to gain a broader range but offer a much smaller bandwidth: 300-480Mb/s. It'll send a signal up to 10m and provides a "perfect replication of high definition visuals", according to one backer, Gefen. The use of the word 'replication' is the giveaway - you're not getting the original image out of the receiver.

Is the difference noticeable? Wireless HDMI supports say no, just as Amimon is adamant that its wireless resilience system doesn't degrade the picture in a way that's perceivable by human eyes. Movie buffs sold on the prospect of perfect picture reproduction offered by 1080p 'full HD' may not be willing to chance it.

Latest Comments

@Will

It's not like Powerline is of much use. Even if you get it working, you still risk interference with your neighbours or terrestrial (i.e. shortwave) radio. Powerline is a solution for some situations, but nothing even remotely reliable. Many people will still find themselves in the need to install new power cabling to make Powerline work.

The better solution would be to just simply use Cat. 5 or 6 cabling. I don't see any use for long cables in cosumer electronics anyhow. Most devices now have remote controlls, and unless you have some aincient braindead technology like BlueRay, placement of your equipment is fairly irrelevant. You can just use a cabinet next to your screen/projector.

0
0

It Wont Work!

Cos i'll be parked outside with a 10W+ jammer killin your signal...ded :)

now, get back to plugging in that CAT5/6 cable and let the neighbours have a decent nights piece and quiet.

anyone noticed that even M$ has started drifting more over to HomePlug type connectivity around the home.

illuminatus

ECM 4tW!!!

when tin-foil just wont do, A 100W YAGI JAMMER ALWAYS WILL :D

0
0

If WiFi is anything to go by...

It'll be slow, barely fit for purpose and a general pain in the arse. Add to it about 3 or 4 neighbours with their own setup and that's one wireless link down the drain.

Wireless is rubbish.

Conflict of Interest: Spent a whole weekend a few weeks ago installing Cat6 cable all over my house and an Ethernet port in each room (kitchen included).

0
0
Anonymous Coward

Just a thought...

why don't we use the low-bandwidth wireless link for the low-bandwidth data (eg DVD-type data off ROM or hard drive, or streamed data off the Internerd) so that particular bit can be done with existing technology (WiFi, HomePlug, etc) and the new-fangled high-bandwidth link can use real wires and/or be real short, then there's no need to worry about "visually less important bits" (I thought the whole point about HDTV was that every pixel was sacred, every pixel must show).

Someone kindly explain the flaw in this logic please.

0
0

Wireless versus mains.

Erm.....i am not plugging my DS into the wall everytime i want to slaughter a spotty teenager halfway around the world.....

Wireless has its uses, just because you lot have all got rubbish implementations, doesnt mean i have to rewire my frikkin house!

0
0

More from The Register

Is the next-gen console war already One?
Microsoft’s new Xbox - and more
 breaking news
Apple cored: Samsung sells 10 million Galaxy S4 in a month
Beware of South Koreans bearing Android
US boffin builds 32-way Raspberry Pi cluster
Beowulf cluster built for the price of a single PC
STROKE this mouse to make apps POP, says Microsoft
Windows 8 Start button comes to Redmond's rodents
Nintendo throws flaming legal barrel at YouTubing fans
All your walk-through vid revenue are belong to us
Fairphone goes on sale to all
The Android handset that's PC can be yours
Microsoft reveals Xbox One, the console that can read your heartbeat
Upgrades Live service – and no always-on requirement

Hands on with Hyper-V 3.0 and virtual machine movement

Our award-winning Regcasts have teamed up with training provider QA for the deepest of deep dives into Hyper-V, including a live demo.

Understand VM movement - just click to play, or go here for a bigger version.