The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: Putting a mule on a cloud: one man's battle with Amazon S3

"computing" is a "doing" word David 

Posted Monday 14th July 2008 20:01 GMT

Happy

which makes it a .......... ? Yes David, a verb not a noun. Now everyone lay their heads on their desks and we'll have sleepy time.

Re: "computing" is a "doing" word David 

Posted Monday 14th July 2008 20:15 GMT

(Written by Reg staff.)

I knew this was coming and, as editor of the story, will address now to stop a flurry of comments.

As I see it, computing is often used as a noun as well. High performance computing being on example. Business computing being another.

Perhaps I have gone too far, but am sticking with it for the time being.

Computing is a gerund, Dave 

Posted Monday 14th July 2008 20:23 GMT

Actually, "computing" is a gerund in the sense that the author uses it in the opening sentence of the article, so "cloud computing" is a noun and a gerund.

-- David the Amusingly Pedantic

Isn't Cloud Computing to Computation 

Posted Monday 14th July 2008 20:39 GMT

Joke

like Pissing into the Wind is to Urination?

non technical 

Posted Monday 14th July 2008 22:26 GMT

Interesting that someone capable of using FTP and updating a web site is today called a "non-technical" person.

@jim 

Posted Tuesday 15th July 2008 01:45 GMT

Boffin

Those are "skills" any 10-year-old can do today. If that's your profession, you might want to get in line behind the buggy whip makers.

Gerund... 

Posted Tuesday 15th July 2008 05:55 GMT

Paris Hilton

Would Gerund Computing be any better? HPC code to take the load off of all of those marketing folks (who brought us the term "inputting") usually tasked with creating new technical terms.

Formatting 

Posted Tuesday 15th July 2008 07:37 GMT

Dead Vulture

Good grief, that code sample looks awful! And that's even before you realise it's PHP...

Can I suggest that "computing" is a pedund - a special class apt to cause pedantic grammarian arguments over what kind of word it is?

Download tracking... 

Posted Tuesday 15th July 2008 07:41 GMT

Use the webservers log... or anything that doesn't make it damn near impossible to automate the downloading easily...

EPIC FAIL

S3 very useful 

Posted Tuesday 15th July 2008 09:03 GMT

Heart

I recently started using S3 to backup important files from the dedicated server I administer.

I searched around for a while before deciding the most straightforward method was using some open source software called s3fs. This enables you to have an s3 account mounted as just another directory under Linux. Making backups is now as simple as copying the files to that directory. For added security I also encrypt them before copying.

Yay, I get to be that person 

Posted Tuesday 15th July 2008 10:51 GMT

Your PHP is horrible!

Shome Mishtake 

Posted Tuesday 15th July 2008 11:52 GMT

Coat

You don't get clouds on the gerund, they're in the air.

Already on.

Clouds on the gerund 

Posted Tuesday 15th July 2008 14:23 GMT

Coat

Misty computing? Fogging the issue?

Too hot for a coat especially for running away.

Code sample got all bashed together 

Posted Tuesday 15th July 2008 15:59 GMT

Paris Hilton

Sorry lads, the code got a little screwy. I will get Ashlee to fix it. I can also post the full PHP if anyone wants it

Re: Code sample got all bashed together 

Posted Tuesday 15th July 2008 16:10 GMT

(Written by Reg staff.)

Aye, that was my fault. Should be better now, you whiney bitches.

"Cloud Computing" Is The Correct Term 

Posted Wednesday 16th July 2008 13:36 GMT

Paris Hilton

I assume that, in future articles, the author will talk about the full scope of Amazon's cloud computing, but in the meantime, my British cat, Mr. Fluffer Wickbidget, III, is meowing quite discontentedly at the above comments. "Computing", regardless of what English language labels and rules apply to it, is definitely a part of the "cloud", although it's not obvious from this story, which covers only S3, the storage portion of the cloud computing services Amazon provides. You can also use EC2, the computing portion, which allows you to do pretty much anything you can do with your own systems. I don't really understand why the author even continues to use his own.

As an example of pure computing, you could create a virtual machine to calculate the digits of pi, provision one of Amazon's EC2 machines to run it, and just let it go, without storing the digits, or even serving them up to anyone. Amazon will charge you for every hour the machine is assigned to you. S3 is billed by how much data you store, and how much you transfer, in and out. EC2 is connected to S3, such that S3 stores all of your virtual machines, which are booted and executed, by EC2, only when necessary. Data transfer between S3 and EC2 is free. Basically, except maybe for backups, you can run your entire business from Amazon, which is the promise that "cloud computing" delivers, today.

Paris, because she's also clueless about the cloud.

Apple has some unused Clouds..... 

Posted Wednesday 23rd July 2008 15:05 GMT

With Apple's recent ME generation product rollout going a bit slow I am sure they could spare a few clouds.

Jim