Microsoft denies Zune copyright cop
We play both sides of the IP fence
As an example, he pointed to Microsoft’s Soapbox video-sharing service. "We put in a technological filtering process from Audible Magic to keep people from uploading and making available copyright content. We were interested only in content that’s user-generated - Web 2.0." Well, they were interested only in user-generated content after shuttering the non-filtered version of Soapbox for two months and relaunching the entire service with filters in place.
In any event, Sigall said that Microsoft only goes so far where copyright filters are concerned. "We have to look at these things from all perspectives, because we have real businesses in all areas. We have real users who will really complain if we push too far in one direction. If we’re too much pro-copyright, we’ll hear it from Zune and Xbox owners."
He also said that Microsoft is opposed to heavy government regulation where digital copyrights are concerned, arguing that the net evolves far too quickly for the government to keep up. "I spent 17 years in Washington," he said. "There's nothing positive or affirmative the government can do [beyond basic copyright law]."
The best way to handle the situation, Sigall said, is for the industry too keep throwing solutions at its problems until something sticks. "So, solutions that are open source and non-proprietary, and solutions that are proprietary. Solutions that rely on copyright filters, and solutions that don't. The government should stand back and make sure there's room in the market for all of those solutions."
The panel also included Patrick Ross (executive director of the Copyright Alliance) and Mike Godwin (general counsel for Wikimedia Foundation, the not-for-profit behind Wikipedia), and both joined Sigall in calling for a copyright world free of government regulation.
That said, all three argued the tech industry needs to make an even greater effort to play the Washington game. "I agree with what Jule and Patrick are saying about not pushing for government intervention," Godwin said. "It may seem contradictory that I'm telling you that the government shouldn't intervene and [the industry] should spend more time Washington. But that is exactly how it should be. You have to show up to make sure that when the government does do something, it's well considered and balanced." ®