The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: US Army cyber colonel in call to network arms

"stay out ahead of the speed of megabytes" 

Posted Wednesday 9th April 2008 16:14 GMT

Thumb Down

We must be faster than gallons.

We must hurry more than grams.

We must stay ahead of the speed of a millimeter.

Colonel. Sorry, It just doesn't work man.

Forwarned is forearmed 

Posted Wednesday 9th April 2008 16:36 GMT

Black Helicopters

In *theory* anyone that they recruit into the Armed Forces is considered a "soldier"--even the ones that are overweight, indulge in WoW raids from time to time, live in their parent's basement. and have some form of anti-social defense (acne, BO, glasses, etc.)

Guess who'll shove to the front when the chips are down and they need cannon fodder. At least they'll let us train with the real guns for a change.

Black helios, because I'm THAT sort of pessmist in general. Now where's the keys to my off-shore island bunker?...

Where's SGT Rosenberger when we need him?! 

Posted Wednesday 9th April 2008 17:10 GMT

Stop

Our vaunted US military is one of the worst addicts to 'conventional' anti-virus technology on the planet. Even worse, they continue to buy conventional AV when they know that their vendors give viruses to their enemies: the People's Republic of China.

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2001/04/03/chinese_feds_demand_computer_virus/

Lewis, ask your co-worker John Leyden about this one.

And our cyber-colonel needs to read this:

http://www.vmyths.com/column/1/2001/10/30/

InfoWar=? 

Posted Wednesday 9th April 2008 17:16 GMT

Gates Halo

Well, the Psyops people should be well prepared for the chat boards. All they need is additional training in hacking websites...

The "speed of megabytes"... 

Posted Wednesday 9th April 2008 17:30 GMT

Paris Hilton

...and that is?

I think that someone needs some "education"...

'Murcca's finest 

Posted Wednesday 9th April 2008 17:54 GMT

"We have to ...be proactive enough to stay out ahead of the speed of megabytes...Now we're moving at cyber speed."

What the *fuck* is this twat on about? He's spouting meaningless gobbledegook.

If he is the best person the world's foremost superpower can come up to run its Computer Network Operations and Electronic Warfare Dept then what does it tell us about his colleagues with their fingers on the red button? If they are anything like him, it's a wonder we haven't all been nuked. There's still time...

Guess none of you have served in the US Army. 

Posted Wednesday 9th April 2008 17:57 GMT

Not surpised...not surprised at all.

Officers are not that bright. If you really want to know what's happening "on the ground" (Army lingo for How things really are) then you should ask a Specialist or a Sergeant.

Please tell me this is a counter-intel op 

Posted Wednesday 9th April 2008 18:39 GMT

"stay out ahead of the speed of megabytes"

I can only hope that this is some carefully planned operation to make the Chinese think that we don't know squat about 'cyber-warfare', making them think that they can steal Our Pure Essence.

As a U.S. Army vet, I'm not that certain of that however.

Re: The "speed of megabytes"... 

Posted Wednesday 9th April 2008 19:10 GMT

Coat

"...and that is?"

This is a well known quantity. The unit of measurement is light-years per milli-furlong.

Have you forgotten 911 people? 

Posted Wednesday 9th April 2008 19:16 GMT

As Chertoff says, Cyber risk equals 911 threat!

Crashing planes is no different from crashing webservers. Remember how the people ran around in a kernel panick? How the firewalls fell?

Seriously, he can't top Chertoffs 911 verbal garbage from yesterday.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/technology/7335930.stm

Make no mistake the biggest threat to the USA dollar collapse and that's entirely of their own making. Pumping money into domestic security projects will not fix it. They're going down, and it's entirely the fault of Cheney and his 'deficits don't matter' policy.

Sounds like lyrics from an Andrew Lloyd Webber musical 

Posted Wednesday 9th April 2008 19:21 GMT

"There was a day when we were operating at foot speed,"

"Now we're moving at cyber speed."

Think Tron on rollerskates.

We need armour for the internets! 

Posted Wednesday 9th April 2008 19:24 GMT

Coat

"Now we're moving at cyber speed."

Thats one of the funniest things i've read on this site in a while.

Quick! To the cyber-humvees, we've detected an attack on the West Internet, fire the anti-virus missiles at the enemy bytes!

Reminds me of PA's take on Die Hard 4: http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2007/07/16/

Thanks Lewis 

Posted Wednesday 9th April 2008 20:07 GMT

Unhappy

You were fairly gentle, it's really really embarrassing . I wonder if anyone in the position to do anything is aware of colonel ding-dongs lack of clarity.

<hangs head in shame>

well hell... 

Posted Wednesday 9th April 2008 22:15 GMT

Paris Hilton

I don't even understand wtf he's saying an ah is frum heyar.... He damn sure doesn't need to be in charge of cyber-anything. Reminds me of an Lt. we had in the Army back in the 80's, he was supposed to be an Army photographer but ended up "commanding" a platoon of M1 Abrams tanks - fucking worthless with glasses an half inch thick. Couldn't see a damn thing.

Not too smart but now you understand the right way, the wrong way, and the Army way.

On a side note, I have you British bastards figured out now:

http://www.peevish.co.uk/slang/a.htm

Paris, because she and the Colonel understand each other....

There are decision-making two ranks in the army 

Posted Wednesday 9th April 2008 22:20 GMT

Generals, of course, and corporals. Everyone else are messengers and ladder climbers, trying to seem smart enough to get promotion, yet unwilling to do anything that could attract problems.

When I was in the army (as a corporal), one of the things I did was help the computer service people. Most staff officers were as thick as planks and were incapable of basic computer usage and would make really stupid calls.

We had all the staff officers using the same password so that we could remind them when they called in. It was something like "force" or so, something that stirred the warrior within, but was easy enough to spell.

Once I had this call helping a colonel through a data entry. The conversation went something like this:

Me: "Type T".

wait a few seconds

Me: "Well what do you see?"

Cononel: There's a long row of Ts across the screen. Wait, now it's covering two rows"

Me: "Take your finger off the T"

Real or Unreal? 

Posted Wednesday 9th April 2008 22:38 GMT

Linux

So the recruits of the future start their day with a brisk jog through SecondLife and then head to the Unreal training grounds for some weapons and tactics session. In the afternoon, some Social Skills Advancement at Facebook followed by R&R watching gory movies online. Should solve the recruitement problems!

If you don't believe it, head over to they guys who've seen the future: http://www.unitedmedia.com/comics/dilbert/archive/dilbert-20080409.html

Ooh, he's relaxed allright, that penguin.

@Obed, from (a real) SGT Rosenberger: "Get Real." 

Posted Thursday 10th April 2008 02:23 GMT

Stop

You asked for insight from a front line soldier? In the age of "cyber warfare" it doesn't get better than the insight of a member of the 609th Information Warfare Squadron of the USAF. Yes, he's real. No, he's not active; he retired shortly after 2005.

I was looking for this one earlier... it made more sense than the link I posted earlier.

http://www.vmyths.com/column/1/2001/10/11/

Our vaunted U.S. military:

* will run like a helpless damsel to the antivirus industry if a "virus war" breaks out;

* gives millions of dollars each year to turncoats who supply virus technology to the Chinese government;

* regularly self-cripples its global command & control networks as a precaution;

* remains vulnerable to any wannabee who wants to cripple their global command & control networks;

* doesn't care enough to demand a secure operating system in its PC contracts;

* suffers virus outbreaks as a result of their addiction to inferior antivirus technologies; and

* deletes its virus outbreak data every single day of the week.

And that's just our cyber-colonel's vaunted US military!

Maybe it was a call for help? 

Posted Thursday 10th April 2008 04:48 GMT

I would assume that if they had the staff needed to address the issues they are facing they would not have to be asking for such help.

As for : 'We need to be faster than megabytes'

Maybe what this person is trying to say is they have a large amount of data they have just been forced to parse, and are having trouble keeping up.

I am sure if anyone was able to help with such an issue, they would.

-Maybe they already are ;)

It is more fun to poke at someone asking for help, rather than to provide the help itself.

Maybe... 

Posted Thursday 10th April 2008 04:53 GMT

Boffin

They should just contact the people they want via email / tele, or show up in plain clothes asking if they want such employment. Direct and to the point should work?

Somehow... 

Posted Thursday 10th April 2008 07:53 GMT

Paris Hilton

I just don't envisage even your most 'patriotic' hacker being enticed into volunteering for Uncle Sam.

Now, coercion, that's a different story.

As for " not the kind of folks that perhaps you want to march to breakfast in the morning,” I have a wonderful image of some buzz-cut drill sgt screaming himself purple trying to get your archetypal hacker to fall into line.

There's a movie in that, I think.

No, wait, been done, just with a *rich dumb blonde* and called Private Benjamin.

Paris, coz (see * * above!)

Don't be so hard on the guy 

Posted Thursday 10th April 2008 07:55 GMT

Joke

Didn't anyone ever watch Reboot? Megabyte is a genuine threat!

It's another great Quantum Leap 

Posted Thursday 10th April 2008 08:20 GMT

Alien

I remember being amused as a child when Sinclair launched the Sinclair QL or Quantum Leap computer. Quantum means 'very small', so why was he trying to promote a very small advance in technology I asked myself?

Another one is Lightyear or Parsec. You'd get idiots trying to look intelligent by using the word as a measure of speed whilst anyone knows it's a distance measurement.

The character Han Solo of Star Wars shocked many a true Sci-Fi fans back in 1978 by using this term incorrectly. Didn't George Lucas know anything about Science?

Memetic and... er... doubly entendric potential 

Posted Thursday 10th April 2008 08:44 GMT

Paris Hilton

"Now we're moving at cyber speed."

Oh, exploitable. So did the Colonel conclude his speech by putting on his robe and wizard hat? Har har har.

Have you forgotten? 

Posted Thursday 10th April 2008 08:52 GMT

Cyber warfare is a real threat! Don't you remember when those giant dicks flew into the Virtual Trade Center? Nevar 4get.

I have an idea - round up all these tossers who think that extorting $x billion from individuals and spending it on flashy gizmos will protect against some sort of imaginary threat, and tell them that they've specially chosen to be uploaded into The Matrix and do battle with virtual Al-Qaeda in slow-motion kung fu. Lead them into a room with hanging wires and random furniture everywhere - pretty much any IT department will do - and lie them down on some futuristic couches. Then stab them in the back of the neck with a wire until their eyes glaze over. Dead, jacked in, meh, either way.

Megabytes are not so bad 

Posted Thursday 10th April 2008 08:58 GMT

Black Helicopters

Lest we forget the threat posed by Killerbytes in the 90s.

The war or Terrorbytes is just beginning.

Colonel Gadget? 

Posted Thursday 10th April 2008 09:21 GMT

Go

"GO GO CYBER-SPEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEED!"

This raises serious questions 

Posted Thursday 10th April 2008 10:23 GMT

Dead Vulture

Deeper philosophical questions are raised by this thinkering:

--What is the sound of one bit shifting?

--If a megabyte moves with cyberspeed, but there's no spyware present, does it still move?

--Can a megabyte at cyberspeed ever overtake another at footspeed?

The army's answer to Bill Gates' speed of thought? 

Posted Thursday 10th April 2008 11:11 GMT

After all, didn't it turn out that thought travels at 2 meters per hour or something equally slow?

Now the speed of megabytes. Well gee the megabytes in my hard drive mostly go in circles, pretty fast but not getting anywhere. I like this analogy.

we are interbutts soldiers 

Posted Thursday 10th April 2008 15:01 GMT

and we must untangle the tubes! The internet is not a truck, but a series of tubes.

At Least they're making the Effort ......Phishing for IT Sharks 

Posted Thursday 10th April 2008 16:02 GMT

Alien

"They should just contact the people they want via email / tele, or show up in plain clothes asking if they want such employment. Direct and to the point should work?"....Maybe... By Anonymous Coward Posted Thursday 10th April 2008 04:53 GMT

Should work a Real Treat, AC, although that via tele thing needs some TEMPEST awareness which is maybe more ESPecialised than you imagine.

"and we must untangle the tubes! The internet is not a truck, but a series of tubes."... By Anonymous Coward Posted Thursday 10th April 2008 15:01 GMT

AC2,

That must be the Yin to IT Quantum Communication Entanglement Yang.

Drinking is good for you. 

Posted Friday 11th April 2008 07:00 GMT

{ Should work a Real Treat, AC, although that via tele thing needs some TEMPEST awareness which is maybe more ESPecialised than you imagine.}

Last time I checked, TEMPEST implementation was only required (or maybe even in real life an afterthought) when data of a set classification was in transit over the transport medium.

So, a "Hello, we would like to talk to you at XXX location at XXX time about some computer help - and we are not out to get you" should travel just fine over any regular POTS, CDMA/TDMA/GSM, or VOIP connection just fine right?

That is unless the person pulls something stupid.

-Suppose that happens too...

Last time I check the US Coast Guard was violating COMSEC requirements on a regular basis, maybe I am misinformed.

And just maybe, the sharks are hunting for the fishermen, and for a damn good reason.

Rather than joining the winning side, sometimes one would make the side they are on win without failure.

Even if they fight it tooth and nail.

Bold as Brass for AIDiamond Geysers 

Posted Friday 11th April 2008 16:12 GMT

Alien

"So, a "Hello, we would like to talk to you at XXX location at XXX time about some computer help - and we are not out to get you" should travel just fine over any regular POTS, CDMA/TDMA/GSM, or VOIP connection just fine right?" ... By Fuion

Posted Friday 11th April 2008 07:00 GMT

I agree, Fuion.

Sometimes KISS is much more Effective than any Stealthy Madness which actually impedes Communications.

Give a man/woman what you know they want, and you will Control them?

Property Rights 

Posted Saturday 12th April 2008 07:34 GMT

Go

{ Give a man/woman what you know they want, and you will Control them? }

--> Yes

Don’t Miss

email symbolStill sending naked email? Get your protection here

Security How-to Buckle your seatbelt, encrypt your bits

Google's Satan phoneT-Mobile G1 Google Android-based smartphone

Review Operating System 1, Hardware 0

Ubuntu teaser Ubuntu 8.10 - All Hail new Network Manager

Review The good kind of UI theft

OpenOffice_logoOpenOffice 3.0 - the only option for masochistic Linux users

Review And linear optimizing Mactards