The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: HP launches Linux-loaded Eee PC rival

Nice, but not small 

Posted Tuesday 8th April 2008 09:44 GMT

It's only about two inches narrower than my brick of a Toshiba, and hardly any thinner. Nice machine, but still no Eee beater for sheer slip-in-your-travel-bag portability.

Excellent choice of SUSE 

Posted Tuesday 8th April 2008 09:49 GMT

Looking forward to the Isaiah CPU powered version

Impressed 

Posted Tuesday 8th April 2008 09:49 GMT

Thumb Up

WXGA? Express card slot for my HSDPA card? Don;t give a rat's about bluetooth, so consider one bought. The Aluminium case should look pretty too.

Which (and I don't care what anyone else says) is important.

Price too good to be true? 

Posted Tuesday 8th April 2008 09:55 GMT

I guess for $500 you get the low side of the spec but it does look good.

In the UK its bound to be at least £300, so maybe on par with the low-end 15" laptops but with a much more portable form factor.

Battery life and actual screen size will be key though.

price 

Posted Tuesday 8th April 2008 10:15 GMT

Thumb Up

£230 - looks like the eeePC is not only revolutionising linux desktop sales , but price of these laptops as well!

Well done HP - I was sure it would be a very expensive offering.

Noisy CPU? 

Posted Tuesday 8th April 2008 10:18 GMT

Surely it's the fan that's noisy, which would be down to the manufacturers of the case rather than the CPU?

Just one Question 

Posted Tuesday 8th April 2008 10:18 GMT

Paris Hilton

Where's the Bird On The Beach angle?

Paris, because.

Wheres the beach lady? 

Posted Tuesday 8th April 2008 10:27 GMT

Paris Hilton

I am very disappointed that some manufacturers still think it's acceptable to release a new product without a shot of a blonde using it whilst sunbathing. How will I know that the product is sand & water resistant and completely immune to the effects of direct sun on its screen .... erm.

Re: Wheres the beach lady? 

Posted Tuesday 8th April 2008 11:13 GMT

Thumb Up

Yeah, too right. I think we need Jessica Alba in a _very_ small bikini to convince us about several technical aspects of this HP PC.

('Specially after that nasty multifunction printer of theirs I've just thrown out).

Less is more 

Posted Tuesday 8th April 2008 11:48 GMT

Stop

Asus hit the nail on the head with the EEE becuase they followed the less is more approach and HP are in danger of (accidentally) killing off the ultra-low-cost-ultra-mobile market before its matured. Whilst the HP looks like a good balence (and yes, I do want one) if the next announcement in this class is "a bit more spec, a bit bigger and a bit more £" then low and behold they will haev invented the laptop, like everyone already has.

I already have a BIG laptop thats a desktop replacement spec, great for taking to a few offices and at home, but currenly im stomping round London 3 days a week and dont want to carry a big beast, but still neeed to to a bit of remote desktop, email client and web brwosng. The EEE looks ideal and so does the HP but if they get more expensive it will be hard to justify having 2 laptops, which im sure is a market for these. Still, im off to find one to buy now!

@Dave - Me too! 

Posted Tuesday 8th April 2008 12:09 GMT

Thumb Up

Yeah, I too was very disappointed not have seen our favourite sub-notebook user, in situ on said beach blanket!

Pencil? 

Posted Tuesday 8th April 2008 12:56 GMT

Dead Vulture

What's the point of the pencil? Why not a piece of string?

Something like a dummy credit card would have been a whole load more useful.

8.9inch screen = root(L + W) + edges. 

Posted Tuesday 8th April 2008 17:03 GMT

Coat

25.6 centimeter = 10.1 inch

16.5 centimeter = 6.5 inch

Diagonal = root(102 + 42) = 12.0 inch

so an 8.9 inch screen seems right, with an inch and a half at either end for the case.

Normally i'd post an interesting comment. At least to me. Can't help it, see some numbers and an unanswered question, had to do it. Now where's my coat?

Looks neat... 

Posted Tuesday 8th April 2008 18:50 GMT

So it seems that for $500 this thing is higher performance than my 4 year old Fujitsu ultra portable.

Pending an in person test of that keyboard, looks like I'm going to need at least one.

I noticed one thing... 

Posted Tuesday 8th April 2008 21:22 GMT

I saw an article in a local newspaper here, and while the $500 price tag is for the box with Linux, the price for one with Vista was $600. Maybe they can sell more without the Microsoft TAX!

I don't know if they added anything to make it Vista OK, but $100 sounds about right for a Microsoft License.

Asus 4315 

Posted Tuesday 8th April 2008 21:57 GMT

I recently considered buying an EEE PC, but ended up buying a Asus 4315 with factory loaded Ubuntu. Cheaper than an EeePC (after cashback), better specced (except the size).

Battery Life 

Posted Tuesday 8th April 2008 23:10 GMT

Thumb Up

Considering that the VIA PICO-ITX (Same processor and chipset) consumes 10W of power under full load, I bet the battery life is excellent.

I really want one of these, However SUSE will need to be replaced by Mandriva.

Reminded me 

Posted Wednesday 9th April 2008 00:47 GMT

Paris Hilton

Reminded me of the ultra light weight P2 & P3 Toshiba Portege 3000 series of the late nineties but fed a large dose of cpu steriods to spice the performance !

Eedora 

Posted Wednesday 9th April 2008 04:42 GMT

I personally think these subnotebooks are utter crap. I was first interested in the ASUS Eee PC because it had linux pre-installed, but when I found out that Xandros was the OS I was immanently turned offf. Guy's, a customized OS with limited functionality is not going to sell, might as well have Windows XP pre-installed on these notebooks. What would really make these subnotebooks more "quality like" is a user friendly version of Eedora, hell even the typical version of Eedora is better than Suse or Xandros. A subnotebook with crappy specs and limited functionality, where all you do is use the interent and certain programs is a rip-off, give me a real notebook anyday.

User-replacable keyboard? 

Posted Wednesday 9th April 2008 06:35 GMT

It's a US keyboard layout, but I'd rather have the two-row enter and <>| right of left shift, i.e., Scandinavian/UK(?) keyboard.

Is it known if the keyboard will be replacable easily afterwards, or if we're stuck with the US one? (If one would buy the lappie from the US /today/).

Win XP 

Posted Wednesday 9th April 2008 08:34 GMT

would be a massive turn-off for me, I am very glad they picked SUSE linux.

Clove want a tad bit more then "$500" 

Posted Wednesday 9th April 2008 10:24 GMT

http://www.clove.co.uk/viewproduct.aspx?product=860C3DBF-F77D-4B2D-9FED-3302166CA743

Don't play the manufacturers Lying Game 

Posted Wednesday 9th April 2008 12:53 GMT

Stop

The CRT makers got their asses sued off for playing this 14.9"=15" game and I thought the lesson had been learned with all the new LCD monitors. Please don't start back down this road, if their monitor is 7.9" call it 7" and shame them into providing the full amount.

Its bad enough the HD guys are still getting away with defining their own custom units. I'm just waiting for the day when I go to the grocery for a dozen eggs and there's fine print on the carton: "For the purposes of this sale, 1 dozen has been defined as 10"

USB? 

Posted Wednesday 9th April 2008 20:14 GMT

How many USB connections?

@Eddie Johnson 

Posted Thursday 10th April 2008 09:18 GMT

Alert

Legally speaking, "inch" is now a slang term. The old definition of 25.4mm. is no longer binding. As long as the specifications clearly state the correct size in official measuring units (i.e., centimetres or millimetres) they can call it however the hell many inches they like.

It's actually fun to check out different manufacturers' "exchange rates" .....

boyz & toyz 

Posted Friday 11th April 2008 10:06 GMT

Linux

What are you guys like, so it doesn't matter how 'good' a product is, as long as there is a blonde 'babe' using it, you'll buy it? suckers!

It is good to see another manufacture taking Linux seriously and putting it on their devices, I'll give them a point for that.

bloody marketing depts 

Posted Wednesday 16th April 2008 09:05 GMT

Unhappy

"That's the front thickness - HP didn't say how much bigger the 2133 gets at the back"

WTF would one want to know the thickness of the thinnest edge? I want to know the thickness of the thickest edge TYVM. Bloody tw@ts.