The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: Rogue trader sues SocGen for unfair dismissal

Lawyers 

Posted Thursday 3rd April 2008 11:03 GMT

Linux

Wonder why lawyers are so hated around the world.

Kerviel's Lawyer states: "no court proceedings have been launched" 

Posted Thursday 3rd April 2008 11:07 GMT

Dead Vulture

Kerviel's Lawyer, Elisabeth Meyer, has told Reuters that no court proceedings have been launched. So unless he has got a new lawyer without telling his old ones etc it is just the Times jumping the gun or not checking their facts properly.

http://www.reuters.com/article/businessNews/idUSL0332624720080403?feedType=RSS&feedName=businessNews

Good Luck to him 

Posted Thursday 3rd April 2008 12:37 GMT

Thumb Up

It's quite clear that SocGen were either grossly incompetent in not spotting what was going on and having such lax procedures as to allow it OR, as he asserts, they knew full well what was going on, were chuffed to bits when it was making them money (and huge fat bonuses!) and he has just taken the wrap now it's all gone tits up.

I suspect he'll just get screwed over anyway but, hey, at least he's having a go at trying to bring some of the bastards down with him!

scapegoat 

Posted Thursday 3rd April 2008 12:47 GMT

Coat

This poor guy has been used as a scapegoat for SocGens poor performance last year, remember they lost the 5bn euro this year not last and claim that this 5bn has made them fail to meet their targets last.

Besides, this guy did NOT sell the stock in question, it was SocGen that sold the stock at a ridiculous point in time, causing 5bn losses.

Easy to blame one poor sod (with a nice salary) for the companies failings ....

Go on Kerviel, sue them American style!

yehbutnobut 

Posted Thursday 3rd April 2008 13:23 GMT

IT Angle

"Easy to blame one poor sod (with a nice salary) for the companies failings"

IIRC, Kervier got paid sod-all, not "a nice salary" - less than €80k per year...

So... 

Posted Thursday 3rd April 2008 13:59 GMT

Stop

Letting someone do something he shouldn't have been doing in the first place SocGen should have to pay? That makes sense... who cares if the guy had made them money when he started, he shouldn't have been trading period!

Corporate hypocrisy 

Posted Thursday 3rd April 2008 14:00 GMT

Paris Hilton

Break the rules and win and you're lauded as a high-flyer, a visionary, an astute player and everyone is happy to turn a blind eye.

Break the rules and lose and you're pilloried as a rogue trader, a fraudster or a criminal by the same people who were previously quite happy to pocket the proceeds of your risk-taking activities!

re. Corporate hypocrisy 

Posted Thursday 3rd April 2008 14:50 GMT

Thumb Down

Except in UK banking, where you seem to get a fat payout win or lose...

http://www.thisismoney.co.uk/news/article.html?in_article_id=436232&in_page_id=2

@AC 

Posted Thursday 3rd April 2008 15:28 GMT

"Except in UK banking, where you seem to get a fat payout win or lose..."

except that case wasn't illegal, just not clever. CEOs of companies who do stupid things traditionaly get paid off, nomatter what business sector they work for. They at least seem to employ clever lawyers when their contracts are written.

bigger picture 

Posted Thursday 3rd April 2008 15:34 GMT

Boffin

It's actually pretty wise from his POV to go after SocGen ; not doing it would imply he accepts dismissal for "gross misconduct", and would give some "flesh" to the SocGen story when time comes of a possible criminal trial. Without streching hair too much, the admitted fault in the realm of working laws could very well be the same one he would face in the criminal court ; it would be a bad idea not to have already disputed it.

But suing them to the contrary is a good move as it is a way to suggest that he wasn't alone in the scheme and that at least, by turning a blind eye, SocGen shares a level of guilt with him. This could lessen his criminal liability in the future.

@ John Band 

Posted Thursday 3rd April 2008 15:41 GMT

""Easy to blame one poor sod (with a nice salary) for the companies failings"

IIRC, Kervier got paid sod-all, not "a nice salary" - less than €80k per year..."

€80k is currently just under £63k - sounds pretty nice to me.

@Steve 

Posted Thursday 3rd April 2008 19:45 GMT

Pirate

You make a company about 1.4 bn euros, that's about 1 *BILLION* pounds, or just over 2 *BILLION* dollars, and all you get is a £63K paycheck?

i'd be in my boss's office threatening him with GBH and the russian mafia if i did not get a 1% bonus of that!

Only in France... 

Posted Thursday 3rd April 2008 20:02 GMT

...where employers have no right to dismiss anyone, even in the most extreme of circumstances - quod erat demonstrandum.

Guilty or not inocent? 

Posted Friday 4th April 2008 09:16 GMT

Jobs Halo

SocGen may be guilty of being lax but, come on this guy knew what he was doing. If he is innocent so was Hitler.

Icon? That me.

@Sascha Zierfuss 

Posted Saturday 5th April 2008 12:57 GMT

Excuse me, but his job is as a *TRADER* !! His "crime" is not that he should or should not have *traded* but that he traded way over the limits imposed on him !! When he was making money, the management were quietly pocketing their bonuses. When the times got hard, they panicked and forced the unwinding of the trades he had done at an extremely bearish time !! *THAT* caused the losses !! If they had kept their nerve and hung on, they may have have ridden out these bearish times and the trades may have been fine.

I strongly that SocGen had (and still have) troubles elsewhere within the bank and they are using this poor sod as the scapegoat for their sins !! I support his suing the pantalon off them, if only to expose the sins they were trying to sweep under the carpet !!

Don’t Miss

email symbolStill sending naked email? Get your protection here

Security How-to Buckle your seatbelt, encrypt your bits

Google's Satan phoneT-Mobile G1 Google Android-based smartphone

Review Operating System 1, Hardware 0

Ubuntu teaser Ubuntu 8.10 - All Hail new Network Manager

Review The good kind of UI theft

OpenOffice_logoOpenOffice 3.0 - the only option for masochistic Linux users

Review And linear optimizing Mactards