The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: Motorola cuts off gangrenous right arm

Making your mind up 

Posted Wednesday 26th March 2008 14:36 GMT

> the firm's insistence on supporting every software platform

"Insistence" implies there was a strategy. "Indecision" would be a better word, surely?

Too bad. 

Posted Wednesday 26th March 2008 14:40 GMT

Goodbye, Moto...

maybe... 

Posted Wednesday 26th March 2008 15:34 GMT

...they'll finally put out a phone with a usable UI.

Maybe not.

Blood on the iPhone's touchpad... 

Posted Wednesday 26th March 2008 15:46 GMT

Jobs Halo

Let the flame war begin...

Lost the plot 

Posted Wednesday 26th March 2008 15:49 GMT

Unhappy

When they were dropped by Apple, for the CPU the Mac, surely that should have told them that they had lost the plot.

What?! 

Posted Wednesday 26th March 2008 15:57 GMT

Surely all they need to do is paint an old, rubbish phone pink and it'll sell like hotcakes, making them a profitable company... oh.

Erm... gold then?... oh.

This looks like the beginning of the end.

Goodbye Moto..... 

Posted Wednesday 26th March 2008 16:07 GMT

Stop

hopefully those stupid "Hello moto" ads will disappear as well.

Their mobile lineup is bad... 

Posted Wednesday 26th March 2008 16:11 GMT

It's not just that they support so many platforms - but the only compelling Motorola phones I have seen in years has been the RAZR V8/V8i, which was good for while it lasted. Plus, the lineup is very patchy and they aren't present at some crucial price points - which I think matters in developing economies like India.

They need to emulate Nokia - a lot of phones, at every price point in the market.

Gash 

Posted Wednesday 26th March 2008 16:21 GMT

Their phone UI has been awful for years. The handsets always look nice, and have some good ideas - but the overall look and feel makes me never ever want another Moto handset ever again.

@Lost the plot 

Posted Wednesday 26th March 2008 17:11 GMT

Flame

"When they were dropped by Apple, for the CPU the Mac"

Hello? Not every item of news related to technology is about Apple. Besides, Motorola spun out their semiconductor business a while back; this has barely anything to do with that.

@Andy Barber 

Posted Wednesday 26th March 2008 17:14 GMT

"When they were dropped by Apple, for the CPU the Mac, surely that should have told them that they had lost the plot."

It was the other way round. Moto fired Apple after a Steve Jobs screaming fit at Chris Galvin.

And Moto screwed Apple royally. They had to overclock the G4 (remember the Wind Tunnel?) until the G5 came along (for desktops) and until they moved to Intel (for notebooks).

G5 

Posted Wednesday 26th March 2008 19:36 GMT

I believe the G5 was made by IBM

@Anonymous Coward 

Posted Wednesday 26th March 2008 21:15 GMT

Motorola just didn't screw Apple, but themselves and their investors as well. Lose a customer and lose revenue.

The RAZR's a good device 

Posted Thursday 27th March 2008 03:08 GMT

Thumb Up

I use a year-old pre-3G RAZR. It's an ok phone and of better build quality than most. The lack of software functionality lets it down, but I personally wouldn't consider anything that's either bigger or doesn't have a flip.

The two big non-software bugs are the way it has outside mounted buttons that stay live when its closed (why!) and it's refusal to recharge off a vanilla USB cable.

I wonder what will happen to the old Symbol business in this deal?

No great loss 

Posted Thursday 27th March 2008 06:55 GMT

I've never seen a Motorola phone that was worth squat. Crap UI makes it next to useless. They'd be better off selling the unit to the Chinese.

Nortel - Motorola merger 

Posted Thursday 27th March 2008 12:59 GMT

It's apparently on the cards for wireless network infrastructure, so maybe now it might happen for the rest of the business. Depends what the canadian government says though.

Sign up, sign up for The Register's weekly mobile & wireless newsletter - click here

Don’t Miss