Skip to content

Biting the hand that feeds IT

The Register ®

Comms:


Related Whitepapers

Comments on ‘Motorola to offload half its Birmingham staff’

Job losses to stem money losses

Published Wednesday 19th March 2008 07:02 GMT

« Back to article page

That's unfortunate.. 

By Andy Worth
Posted Wednesday 19th March 2008 08:21 GMT

While I sympathise with those who will lose their jobs, I can hardly say that it's a surprise given that Motorola make perhaps the worst phones on the market. They were once the "top of the pile" back a couple of decades ago but fell behind by releasing phones with poor features and interfaces, concentrating solely on "fashion". I know hardly anyone who uses a Motorola and most people seem to regard them as very poor phones, even those who work in the industry.

They've attempted to redress the balance more recently, with their most recent releases having an updated (and thankfully slightly more intuitive) interface but it's very hard to get the mud off a name. There are too many good phones on the market to bother with the poor ones.

Sadly I doubt this will be the last of the job cuts, unless they pull their finger out.

Former Sendo Site 

By Ian
Posted Wednesday 19th March 2008 09:13 GMT

I presume that this is the building on the A45 as you approach the airport. In which case, it's the former Sendo operation, so it's already been through one death and resurrection.

No surprises 

By Tom Richardson
Posted Wednesday 19th March 2008 11:43 GMT
Thumb Down

As a former Test Engineer for moto mobiles I can hardly say I'm surprised. Testers have no feedback into the design process and the designers I'm sure don't actually use their products. Lots of things that are great 'on paper' are horrible to use in practice. I've worked for a couple or carriers as well and Motorolas are pretty much a running joke in test departments these days. And yes, the Birmingham site is from the acquisition of Sendo, which was a bloody stupid move in the first place.

More unemployed 

By James Pickett
Posted Wednesday 19th March 2008 12:43 GMT
Thumb Down

Given that Vodafone is also firing, you have to wonder what industry in the UK is making any money. I'm not surprised at Motorola, though. I bought a new PAYG mobile recently, and some of their models were available for under £20...

user interface ok, crap OS and baseband control software 

By pctechxp
Posted Wednesday 19th March 2008 13:28 GMT

I made the mistake of buying a V600 SIM free a few years back.

Had to constantly reset it as it would stop receiving texts and then I'd get a shedload once I'd reset it.

Also when making a call it could often not decide what frequency to use, just used to go dead when dialling and would take up to three attempts to make a call.

I hear that the RAZR had the same issues, of course I feel sorry for anyone losing their job but its not surprising when you cant get the basics right.

Moto phones are rubbish 

By Giles Jones
Posted Wednesday 19th March 2008 16:08 GMT

People only bought the Razr because it was thin, the actual interface was awful.

Motorola could get away with simple phones back in the days of mono LCD screens and mono ringtones. I had a Timeport and it was an ok phone if dull compared to Ericsson.

Motorola need good designs, a decent OS in the phone and to vastly improve their image in the mobile arena. As it stands they may as well pull out and just become a chipset vendor.

Low expectations 

By Jim Benn
Posted Wednesday 19th March 2008 19:00 GMT
Coat

I've never desired all the features of a modern phone, so for me Motorola has always been about the 'connection'. I would hate to see them leave the market, because (here in the US) their phones have always worked better (as a phone) than any other cell phones I've seen. I've mistakenly dropped them, and they still worked, and they usually pick up signal better than the folks around me (on other makes of phone). I guess I expect much less from a cell phone.

(I left my coat in the car.)

decimation x 6.577!!! 

By Anonymous Coward
Posted Wednesday 19th March 2008 22:37 GMT
Coat

decimate 6.577 times =

0.9 ^ 6.577 = 0.50009554366664035927846079510926

=~50%

so there :P

mines the one with "loggarivems 4 preskoolerz" in the pocket

Hmmmmm... how times change 

By Anonymous Coward
Posted Wednesday 19th March 2008 23:16 GMT
Coat

I may be misremembering, but wasn't it Motorola's handset people who led the trend for (a) "zero defect" and (b) "offshoring", way back in the 20th century (mid 1980s maybe) when their handset design and manufacturing went from the USA to the subcontinent?????

Doesn't look like it did them much good medium term then? Current promoters of offshoring and promoters of the natural heir of zero defect, "six sigma", please note... some people know what you're up to, and you're up to no good.

Better than the States 

By Anonymous Coward
Posted Friday 21st March 2008 19:20 GMT
Alert

I would consider the folks at Birmingham fairly fortunate still, with the 90 day "warning" you can really make the necessary life changes or at least be thoroughly prepared for it. It appears that similar actions are considered for the Plantation facility and others in the U.S. according to http://thelaidoff.com but probably they'll see the axe only when it's about to hit their neck instead.

On the other hand, one could argue everyone at Motorola can see this coming for about 1/2 ~ 1 year now so whether it's 90 day warning or 2 weeks warning, it's all fair games.. One thing we know for sure is not to believe in the management straight talk of no layoff :P They'll do what's needed to turn things around (or at least try to save their own behind)..

whitepaper title

How IT Management Can "Green" the Data Center

This Gartner research provides managers with an outline of the trends affecting datacenters and offers strategies with which to address these changes..
whitepaper title

Gartner Paper: US Data Centers

U.S. enterprise data centers face considerable space and energy constraints over the next few years. Download this free independent report to read more..

Top 20 storiesAll The Week’s HeadlinesArchiveSearch