The Foundation for Information Policy Research (FIPR), a leading advisory group on internet issues, has written to the Information Commissioner arguing that Phorm's ad targeting system is illegal.

In an open letter posted to the think tank's website today, the group echoes concerns voiced by London School of Economics professor Peter Sommer that Phorm's planned partnerships with BT, Virgin Media and Carphone Warehouse are illegal und the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000 (RIPA).

"The consent of those who host the web pages visited by a user is also required, since they communicate their pages to the user, as is the consent of those who send email to the user, since those who host web-based email services have no authority to consent to interception on their users' behalf."

Phorm claims that all sensitve data will not be profiled, but FIPR argues its "restricted sites" blacklist system will be ineffective because of the vast array of webmail and social networking sites web users now visit.

Bohm uses the letter to urge the Information Commissioner, Richard Thomas, to ignore the conclusions of the Home Office, which advised BT and the other ISPs that Phorm's technology is legal. Thomas' office first said it planned to look into Phorm on 29 February. It told El Reg it only learned of the ISPs' data pimping plans two days before they were publicly announced on 14 February.

Earlier today web inventor Sir Tim Berners-Lee said he would personally not want his traffic to be profiled by Phorm, and called on BT, Virgin Media and Carphone Warehouse to make the "service" opt-in only. ®

Related stories

• Phorm unleashes legal attack on critics (27 February 2009)
• BT's Phorm small print: It's all your fault (3 October 2008)
• Phorm losses shoot up by half (1 October 2008)
• Virgin Media distances itself from Phorm 'adoption' claims (1 May 2008)
• Anti-Spyware Coalition probes data pimping (25 April 2008)
• Updated Home Office defends 'dangerously misleading' Phorm thumbs-up (24 April 2008)
• BT's secret Phorm trials open door to corporate eavesdropping (17 April 2008)
• American ISPs already sharing data with outside ad firms (10 April 2008)
• Updated Information Commissioner: Phorm must be opt-in only (9 April 2008)
• FIPR: ICO gives BT 'green light for law breaking' with Phorm (7 April 2008)
• Updated BT: 'We did not let anyone down over Phorm... it was not illegal' (3 April 2008)
• Exclusive BT and Phorm secretly tracked 18,000 customers in 2006 (1 April 2008)
• MPs pile pressure on ISPs over Phorm (28 March 2008)
• Updated The Guardian ditches Phorm (26 March 2008)
• BT 'security upgrade' causes email headaches (25 March 2008)
• Phorm agrees to independent inspection of data pimping code (19 March 2008)
• BT admits misleading customers over Phorm experiments (17 March 2008)
• Security firms split over Phorm classification (14 March 2008)
• Top security firm: Phorm is adware (12 March 2008)
• CPW builds wall between customers and Phorm (11 March 2008)
• Comment Dear ISP, I am not a target market (10 March 2008)
• Interview Phorm launches data pimping fight back (7 March 2008)
• BT targets 10,000 data pimping guinea pigs (5 March 2008)
• Data pimping: surveillance expert raises illegal wiretap worries (4 March 2008)
• Updated The Phorm files (29 February 2008)
• Exclusive How Phorm plans to tap your internet connection (29 February 2008)
• Broadband big boys waiting on data pimping (29 February 2008)
• Exclusive BT pimped customer web data to advertisers last summer (27 February 2008)
• ISP data deal with former 'spyware' boss triggers privacy fears (25 February 2008)