The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: CERN completes 'world’s largest jigsaw puzzle'

NNoooooooo 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 10:29 GMT

I've read Angels and Demons and I know that this will oinly lead to the Vatican being blown up. Foolish, foolish, scientists!

Two Words 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 10:54 GMT

Joke

Resonance Cascade.

@ Ash 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 11:00 GMT

Boffin

Get the crowbar.

@Richard 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 11:04 GMT

I haven't read the book, but you seem to be implying that blowing up the Vatican would be a *bad* thing.

Chewy says 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 11:05 GMT

Alien

It isn't a jigsaw, they're building the Millennium Falcon.

Ahh, that will be why there was a power blackout last night... 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 11:05 GMT

The whole of Saint-Genis Pouilly (French town very close to CERN) went black last night, several times. Everything, including all street lights, went out.

Clearly, someone couldn't wait to play with their new toy...

I think I'll wait 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 11:06 GMT

for some clever oriental to bring out the pocket-portable version.

"ATLAS's role is to measure particles produced in proton-proton collisions within its 7000 tonne, 28,750 cubic metre bulk packing 100 million sensors"

A title should not be required 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 11:10 GMT

They're going to end up creating a black hole, and sucking the whole solar system into it, which'd be a bit of a laugh really.

This sounds familiar 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 11:30 GMT

Go

Isnt this familiar with Half Life ? And Another World? Get ready.

@Ash 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 11:33 GMT

Boffin

John doesn't need to hear this, he's a trained professional.

WORLDS LARGEST JGSAW WHAT? 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 11:37 GMT

Coat

Do we never learn? Did they not play Fade to Black?

NOOOOOOO CHARLES, NOOOOOOOooooooooooo

Mine is the one that haz Cheeezeburger in pokets..

(Phew - meme'd out)

All done then? 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 11:48 GMT

Alert

And when the first sports-car driving idiot scientist decides to play with it at 3am during a stoem and gets himself blasted into another world?

The end of the world is nigh.. 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 12:11 GMT

Happy

Go nuts, before we all get sucked into that Black Hole they are about to create...

I normally... 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 12:17 GMT

Alert

... have to search around the house for the last piece of any jigsaw I do. I'd hate to see the size of the sofa they found that stuffed down.

"They're waiting for you, Gordon... 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 12:40 GMT

Paris Hilton

... in the *test chamber*."

Is it me or.... 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 12:42 GMT

Alert

Are they being a bit slap dash

ATLAS's role is to measure particles produced in proton-proton collisions within its 7000 tonne, 28,750 cubic metre bulk packing 100 million sensors.

CERN explains: "As particles pass through a magnetic field produced by superconducting magnets, this detector has the ability to accurately track them to the width of a human hair."

Proton Size ~ 0.000000000000001 m

Human Hair ~ 0.0001 m

Anybody see some difference in scale?

The previous posters were right it going to be Another World/Fade to Black/Half Life - do these scientist never play games???

The 7 TeV war. 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 12:44 GMT

Joke

Well, it's going to be October at least until you see first pp collisions.

At http://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?p=660, Peter Woit writes:

_So, most optimistically, it looks like mid-late October is the earliest that 7 TeV collisions could be happening, right around the date of the official inauguration: October 21. More realistically, this may very well take until early 2009._

No need to rush to your do-it-yourself store for that crowbar yet.

Looks very familiar 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 12:56 GMT

Boffin

Crowbar? Straight to the Gravity Gun I say ;-)

Better than Global Warming 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 13:17 GMT

At least we all get a quick death - err how long does it take to get sucked into a black hole?

Two points 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 13:23 GMT

[The LHC will, once operational, allow scientists to probe the mysteries of the universe, including dark matter, matter "as it existed close to the beginning of time" and possible extra dimensions of spacetime]

Hands up if you think it's a good idea to do that on the planet you live on...

[CERN explains: "As particles pass through a magnetic field produced by superconducting magnets, this detector has the ability to accurately track them to the width of a human hair."]

Which is about as impressive as saying we have spent £x billion on a system that can track a car to within the width of the planet. Seriously, how many subatomic particles can you fit in the width of a human hair? By my (very poor research and maths) I make it 100,000,000,000. For a nucleon that is. This is my impressed face -> -.-

PETA protest 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 13:34 GMT

Alien

People for the Ethical Treatment of Atoms feel that this research could be performed perfectly well without killing innocent atoms.

Show that you care for atoms by taking off your kit now.

That's no moon... 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 13:39 GMT

http://www.pearl-jam.com/starwars/swpixnot/milfalds.jpg

Go Han, go!

@sports cars at 3am 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 13:55 GMT

Go

actually the Machine Operators (who do extensive shift-work) are the ones usually driving the sports cars. (It helps that with a 431K CERN number plate you can get a tax-free sports car!)

I have done machine experiments at 3am with <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yuri_Feodorovich_Orlov> Yuri didn't drive a sports car.

I prefer Ferney Voltaire to St.Genis-Pouilly (what will happen to the protons in November when the Swiss/EU border is dissolved??) (they currently have to pass the Douanes every 45microseconds!!)

/don't need a coat, the skyshine keeps me warm

My god... It's full of stars... 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 14:13 GMT

Paris Hilton

Christ's sake - for an IT related site there sure are a whole lot of scientifically challenged reprobates out there!

'We're all going to get sucked into a black hole' - I suspect not.

'How long does it take to get sucked in to a black hole?' - well... I guess that kind of depends how big it is... and also whether you're observing someone fall into a black hole or falling in to it yourself etc, etc, etc...

As good as Half Life is, I can' really see some physicists playing it and suddenly worrying "Oh my god! What are we doing? I've gotta stop this crazy experiment.!"

Are we all still so luddite that when any major technology comes round the corner we all start declaring the end of the world? Oh my god - It's a digital watch! This is where Skylab started! Run to the nuclear bunkers now!

Paris - Coz I know where I'd like to accelerate my hadrons!

Outcast 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 14:33 GMT

Coat

was another game involving me fixing the rift created by an accelerator accident. And voxels.

Anyone?

I'll get my coat.

@ those who don't like the accuracy 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 15:00 GMT

Happy

"As particles pass through a magnetic field produced by superconducting magnets, this detector has the ability to accurately track them to the width of a human hair."

Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle, anyone? The LAC is optimised to measure momentum, therefore delta-p is small and delta-x is correspondingly big.

I can't be arsed to look anything up or calculate it though. Perhaps a bored Physics undergrad may wish to have a go?

Dust off. Nuke the site from orbit. 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 15:08 GMT

Coat

It's the only way to be safe.

Mine's the one with the Weyland-Yutani insignia. Yes, I'm a Corporal. What of it?

Re: My god... It's full of stars... 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 15:22 GMT

Umm it's a joke. They took a science story and added a computer angle to it. Geeks eh?...

PS Computers != physics. Totally different areas.

Unfolding 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 15:26 GMT

Paris Hilton

strange, charm, top, bottom... all inspired by me (and by my acting)

what's to bet they name the force carrier for the next dimension a "Hilton"

see me unfold in six dimensions (download available)

Measuring angles 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 15:51 GMT

> Proton Size ~ 0.000000000000001 m

> Human Hair ~ 0.0001 m

That doesn't matter. What they're measuring are the angles at which the debris from the collision diverge. Being able to measure to of the order of microns at a distance of metres from the point of the collision gives a pretty fine angular resolution. Any imbalance in the angles may indicate "lost" energy due to undetected particles.

Just in case... 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 15:52 GMT

Black Helicopters

I, for one, welcome our new Higgs boson overlords.

Think of the poor Swiss 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 18:31 GMT

The Swiss'll all be swept into an alternate reality. No need to worry about the French though, they are already in an alternate reality.

good odds on the destruction of switzerland 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 19:47 GMT

Pirate

Anybody interested in a little bet on the outcome? My money's on the end of life on earth:

http://www.hubdub.com/e/Market/What_will_be_the_result_of_the_switching_on_of_the_Large_Hadron_Collider_in_May_231/view

None of you know what you are talking about 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 20:41 GMT

Stop

How can you argue about accuracy when you are not even using the correct units of measurement.

"ATLAS's role is to measure particles produced in proton-proton collisions within its 7000 tonne, 28,750 cubic metre bulk packing 100 million sensors."

Should read

"ATLAS's role is to measure particles produced in proton-proton collisions within its 1666.6667 Kilo Jubs, 49916660.8792 bulgarian funbags - (C Cup Posh Spice bulk) packing 100 million sensors."

Please pay attention to the details guys!!

@Ross 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 20:47 GMT

Thumb Up

I beg to differ. Writing code for BNFL I interpreted physycysts' (can't spell won't spell) specs and wrote code. In C++, no less. Blimey. Divide by zero errors happened. Phyzzy: But there will always be neutrons! Me: What, even when you havn't comissioned the reprocessing plant?

But, for my 2p worth, I put my faith, and that of the entire world's humaity, in the fact that Hawking got it right and the micro-black holes will dissipate. Phew!

Hello, Gordon... 

Posted Monday 3rd March 2008 21:29 GMT

Thumb Up

...it's good to see you!

Are the stars right yet? 

Posted Tuesday 4th March 2008 07:29 GMT

Alert

"...The LHC will, once operational, allow scientists to probe the mysteries of the universe..as it existed close to the beginning of time and possible extra dimensions of spacetime..."

ph'nglui mglw'nafh Cthulhu R'lyeh wgah'nagl fhtagn

mwahahahahahaaaa!!

All Bets are on. 

Posted Tuesday 4th March 2008 08:42 GMT

I am giving odds of 10 million to one on the ends of the earth , any body what a dabble.

Mind you you may have to wait a while for the sun to expand and engulf us.

Re: microns vs protons 

Posted Tuesday 4th March 2008 10:06 GMT

Boffin

I was curious about the microns/protons difference too; I put it down to uncertainty and that they need to measure the speed too. Deriving root mean squares feels like work, but the AC suggestion of angles being of prime importance (and m vs µm) is pretty convincing as well.

Waste of Space-Time 

Posted Tuesday 4th March 2008 10:17 GMT

Jobs Horns

In an electric universe you don't need black holes, dark matter or any other wierd, invented, non-provable stuff. I think the only black hole they'll find is the one they're pouring money into.

How long to get sucked in 

Posted Tuesday 4th March 2008 11:47 GMT

Boffin

The answer, as someone points out, is different if you're doing it or watching it. If you're being sucked into a black hole, time dilates for you as you approach the event horizon, so that it may feel like a *very* long time. This is likely to be more unpleasant than boring; due to tidal forces your feet will weigh vastly more than your head (supposing you fall feet first, YMMV).

I was going to contrast how different this would be to being sucked in by a Dan Brown novel, but I changed my mind.

Listen to your mother!!!!!!! 

Posted Tuesday 4th March 2008 14:27 GMT

Coat

Remember when you mother told you not to mess with things you don't understand......Well this sounds like the perfect time to listen to her advice as this surely can only end in tears with some smug scientist saying "See I told you not to do it"

Mine is the full charged HEV suit with the gravity gun.

"Nostradamus ate my hamster" 

Posted Tuesday 4th March 2008 22:04 GMT

Gates Horns

Robert Rankin's "Nostradamus ate my hamster" has nothing on this. scary

I'm hoping... 

Posted Tuesday 4th March 2008 23:44 GMT

Some careless twat of a janitor leaves his cheese-and-egg sandwich and thermos in the middle of the thing so that when they switch it on flukish conditions cause it to function as a stable fusion generator, pumping out more energy than the initial charge they put in it (and remains pumping out power after they shut off the power feed to it) so the whole "renewable power source" argument gets consigned to the scrap-heap for good.

Hey, it might happen... Bell was merely trying to make a more responsive telegraph when he accidentally revolutionised our lives.

Don’t Miss