The Register®

Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: Star Wars animation heads for the silver screen

Cartoon series was... 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 10:10 GMT

...excellent - really enjoyed it.

Not sure about a 3D affair though, looks a bit odd..

Patience, young Padawan 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 10:45 GMT

Anakin was allowed to *teach*? No wonder the Jedi were failing.

Excellent! 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 10:45 GMT

Thumb Up

the cartoon microseries was awesome, now all I need to do is dust off my jedi cloak, re-energise my lightsaber and i will be fit to mind trick, and use all the memorable lines from the films

[jedi mind trick] this is not the post you are looking for [/jedi mind trick]

Live action? 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 11:10 GMT

Forget 3D cartoons, bring us the live action TV series, damnit!

Also, I hope the people doing the voices are bloody good, as the old cartoon was a bit of a let-down in that area...

Why am I reminded of... 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 11:25 GMT

Coat

... Spaceballs 2: The Quest for More Money

@ Why am I reminded of... 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 11:51 GMT

Thumb Down

Hmm, possibly because Spaceballs was a pretty piss-poor piss-take of Star Wars? Um, in order to make money. Think what you're saying here, if you don't want Lucas to have your money, don't go and see it. But no, you're saying you've seen Spaceballs 2????? Which no one else (correct me if I'm wrong) has ever heard of? O right, I see, you're making a joke, there never was a Spaceballs 2. So how come you're reminded of it? Are you mental or something? If you don't think people should have the freedom to make money out of film-making maybe you should move to some communist country or something.

@ac 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 12:13 GMT

Paris Hilton

Satire? AmanfromMars posting as an AC? I dunno, but it seems that you obviously missed the little joke in Spaceballs about Hollywood's obsession with producing sequels to big hitters in the hopes of making more money from the same idea.

Did you even *watch* the film?

Is Paris going to be voice-acting in this one?

Oh well... 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 12:26 GMT

Flame

At least George Lucas is unlikely to direct these. The man couldn't direct traffic along a one-way-street.

In the hands of a competent director, Ep I, II & III would have been a lot better, with fewer useless (franchise) characters, better/tighter script, and no pathetic dialogue between Padme and Anakin...

... so here's hoping for something cool.

Correction 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 12:30 GMT

George Lucas concluded: "I felt there were a lot more Star Wars properties left to milk. I was eager to start cashing some of them in through animation and, at the same time, begin driving the final nails into the coffin of my legacy."

more money... 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 12:51 GMT

Unhappy

..for old rope. I feel a disturbance in the Force, ah no, it's me wallet being prised open for another cr4ppy Saturday afternoon at the local Odeon :(

@AC 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 12:52 GMT

Aren't you a little short for a stormtrooper ?

No 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 12:52 GMT

I, II and III needed a Script Writer. George CAN Direct. He just can't write dialogue.

Live Action???? 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 13:05 GMT

Coat

"Forget 3D cartoons, bring us the live action TV series, damnit!"

Hells, Eps1-3 only just classed as "live action" with all the CGI characters....

Mine's the brown hooded cloak, thanks...

When is Clone Wars not Clone Wars? 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 13:26 GMT

Stop

Clone Wars was awesome, mostly because of the production and artists involved. I think George has seen this and will try to emulate it, badly.

well 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 13:58 GMT

So those prequels weren't bad enough that we actually need MORE star wars? I bet they'll come up with something more annoying than Jar Jar Binks just so the kiddies will like it

@ Graham * 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 15:01 GMT

Flame

"Did you even *watch* the film?"

Why, is there there some deep philosophical point you think I missed, assuming that's what you're meaning by the emphasis, as if watching isn't enough, I have to *watch* it to really *get* it. Get a grip.

It was years ago I watched so I don't specifically remember that part of it no, but it's not exactly hard to imagine. So apologies for the original assumption.

My other point stands though. Sequels are bad but "comedy" pastiches of original (sic) works aren't?

I see your Swartz is as big as mine 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 15:32 GMT

Coat

Graham : Don't worry, your not the only one to recall that film in all it's glory.

I was always a little disappointed they never released Spaceballs : The Flamethrower myself.

Any guesses as to what the combination on my luggage is set to?

Oh and this is an unlisted wall...

I didn't wear a coat, but the dark helmet is mine, thanks.

@AC Re: @ Why am I reminded of... 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 16:22 GMT

Joke

I'm glad to note that at least some people have a sense of humour...

(Joke alert icon because... oh figure it out yourself)

Homer Simpson said it best 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 16:42 GMT

Coat

Why would we pay to see something we've been seeing for free on the TV?

(no quotes, because I know I bunged up the quote...)

Lucas' Follies 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 17:15 GMT

Thumb Down

I oppose anything George Lucas is doing by the overwhelming evidence that everything he has done since the original trilogy is mindless cotton candy. That includes the special editions. The release of yet another Star Wars self-parody does little to excite me.

Can someone tell me... 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 17:34 GMT

Coat

Is this the place where I can post a comment about the "Starwars Animation" news?

Gennady Tartakovsky is brilliant 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 17:39 GMT

Thumb Up

Gennady did the clone wars animated series. He & Craig McCracken were the creators of Dextor's Laboratory. After that, he did Samurai Jack while Craig went on to do Powerpuff Girls.

Link to sneak peek 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 21:10 GMT

here: http://www.starwars.com/video/view/000478.html

looks like they're using all the main characters. there's a new dark apprentice as well.

Anonymous Clones... 

Posted Wednesday 13th February 2008 00:42 GMT

....get back to work 'Anonymous Coward'. You seem to post a lot to these boards, or are you cloned?

(NO PICTURE, NO SENSE OF HUMOUR)

Darth Sidious, Count Dooku and General Grievous 

Posted Wednesday 13th February 2008 01:39 GMT

Unhappy

Surely they jest?

Who's next; Darth Doofus?

I stopped being a SW fan after Episode V - Empire Strikes Back

Forget that, check out this... 

Posted Wednesday 13th February 2008 02:39 GMT

IT Angle

The ultimate animated Star Wars: http://www.asciimation.co.nz/

@AC re: Darth Sidius... 

Posted Wednesday 13th February 2008 04:59 GMT

Flame

Stopped being a fan after episode *V*? When the series lost the deep plot, meaningful dialog, and intricate emotional interplay of A New Hope and Strikes Back?

And wait a minute - you're complaining about General Grievous but you didn't have a problem with Darth Vader and Luke Skywalker? You didn't notice that half of the characters have modern US names and the other half have fantasy names?

Jesus Christ, people. You don't watch ANY of the Star Wars movies because they're good. None of them are "good". But some of them have the advantage that you SAW THEM WHEN YOU WERE NINE!

Don’t Miss

Warning: roadworksNetbooks and Mini-Laptops

Buyer's Guide They're little and we love 'em. But which ones are best?

SSL covers security embarrassments with EV figleaf

Whitepaper Helping you know scammers from Adam

Emails show journalist rigged Wikipedia's naked shorts

Overstock's Byrne vindicated amidst economic meltdown

Warning StopYours truly, angry mob

Book extract Bringing Nothing To The Party: Cleaning up the net, one satirical vigilante page at a time