The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: Adobe Reader Trojan predates mystery update by two weeks

pishhh 

Posted Monday 11th February 2008 16:20 GMT

Thumb Up

Use Foxit Reader, allot better than the Adobe bloatware

Is Acrobat 5 vulnerable? 

Posted Monday 11th February 2008 16:55 GMT

Thumb Up

'Cos that's what I find appropriate, due to lack of bloatware. It occasionally warns "this file may container newer shinier stuff than your Acrobat can read" (paraphrased) but so far everything I've read has worked just fine.

Woo, I'm scared. No really.. 

Posted Monday 11th February 2008 17:42 GMT

Hope I don't catch it. Sounds naasty.

No, version 5 shouldn't be affected 

Posted Monday 11th February 2008 17:51 GMT

AFAIK only 7 and 8 are affected.

And even Acrobat 5 can be de-bloated 

Posted Monday 11th February 2008 20:28 GMT

Paris Hilton

Find out where it's hiding and start stripping out the dll's one by one. It's amazing how few of them are needed to read PDFs -- and how fast Acrobat loads once it's been leaned down.

I suppose you lose some function, but I've never noticed anything.

Paris, because she's so skinny and lean.

Followup needed 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 01:24 GMT

Anyway, what happened to that mystery website exploit mentioned a few weeks back?

@anon 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 06:58 GMT

Foxit ftw. It has constantly amazed people when I open pdfs fast. Though, of course now I'm using KPDF, but that's a different story.

Defending Adobe Reader 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 09:28 GMT

Stop

OK, so "reading PDFs" is easily done by lots of other software that's a lot leaner. But I work in publishing and there are lots of features of the PDF format that are only supported properly (or at all) by Adobe Reader, such as layers, scripting and animations. Now, these aren't necessary in many applications (a software manual is a software manual, and a form is a form) but they are extremely useful in many others. A lot of our new publishing for schools is taking advantage of these features of later PDF versions - and hence of Adobe Reader.

Adobe Reader isn't just a "PDF rasteriser", as many other programs are. It's a full PDF engine. Yes, it's big but that's because it's powerful.

(It may be bloated as well, I couldn't comment on that. But it's not all bloat by any means.)

Acrobat Reader 

Posted Tuesday 12th February 2008 17:52 GMT

Other annoying defences of Acrobat Reader:

It has an API, which means it's extensible. Lots of others aren't extensible. If there is one extension you need, then you're stuck with Acrobat Reader.

Webcast: Jumpstart your Application Security initiatives