The Register®

Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: Couple sue over Shanghai metro snog vid

Harsh punishments 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 11:37 GMT

The Chinese normally mean it, too. They executed the head of their food and drug watchdog because of corruption.

Over here that would net you early retirement with a healthy pay-off.

"severe punishment" 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 11:41 GMT

Alert

Eek, given the Chinese record for um, human rights abuses, that could be severe indeed!

Good on them 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 11:44 GMT

Thumb Up

I hope they win, people are entitled to a bit of privacy and not to be splattered all over the web (despite what uk police may think)

Makes you wonder... 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 12:19 GMT

... What people do with CCTV footage over here.

Particularly given the SIA's recent scandal over not checking whether their operatives are entitled to work in the UK or not.

severe flogging 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 12:30 GMT

Joke

or severe snogging?? you decide....

@Stu Reeves 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 12:41 GMT

Well, it's better than being splattered all over the train, as the UK police are likely to do...

We're safe in the UK... 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 12:53 GMT

our government would never put anything inappropriate posted on the net...they can't hang onto it long enough <_<

Privacy? 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 13:06 GMT

Stop

Yes, we all expect privacy when we go out in public, don't we?

Be fair, guys 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 13:06 GMT

Thumb Up

They might be Chinese athletes practicing their secret moves for the Olympics. Now their secret is out, they may lose their event and be punished by being sent for re-education with the London Underground !!

I'd give her a 10 for effort and a 9 for location !!

Lucky bloke 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 13:59 GMT

Thumb Up

She's a bit of a hottie

Re: Privacy? 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 14:05 GMT

"Yes, we all expect privacy when we go out in public, don't we?"

There's a difference between being observed while out in public and having your actions recorded and broadcast to millions of people around the world. And having comments posted about them.

Who watches the watchmen?

meh 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 14:10 GMT

Paris Hilton

I've seen better stuff on the interwebs... the paris icon, well, just because! ;)

@ Eddie Edwards Re: "Privacy?" 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 14:12 GMT

Heart

"Yes, we all expect privacy when we go out in public, don't we?"

Yes. Yes we rightfully expect "a bit of privacy and not to be splattered all over the web" (which is what Stu said in the first instance). We rightfully expect not to have our random moments digitally rendered in the public domain unless commiting an offence.

It's a sad day indeed when you can't give your sweetheart a loving kiss goodbye without being mocked for it on a worldwide platform.

I suspect that you'd change your tune if a clip of you scratching your hairy arse whilst waiting for the bus (or whatever) were to be subjected to a voicover, subsequently turning you into a minor YouTube celebrity accompanied by the baggage of grief that can often come with unsolicited minor levels of 'fame'. For all your colleagues to see.

[Icon is for all you young lovers out there...]

Hope they win 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 14:12 GMT

There is a difference between snogging in public, in front of people you don't know but are comfortable with being in an enclosed space with, and snogging on Internet video for the entire world to see, There are more than two levels of privacy. A gym is a public place as well, but if someone started taking pictures of sweaty cleavage and buttocks you'd still expect them to be thrown out at the very least.

If someone started filming me in a train, I'd ask them what the hell they were doing. If they were filming me in the act of kissing someone or something similarly intimate, I wouldn't bother asking questions, I'd just lamp them, since I already know the answer. Which is "I'm a disgusting bottom-feeding pervert who thinks that because I have no private life worth thinking about, nor should anyone else". The fact that it was done via CCTV adds Kafkaesque helplessness to an already sick situation.

If the Chinese catch the dreck responsible and string him up, it'll take some deep breathing and long meditation on the evils of an unaccountable and corrupt government having the power of life and death over individual citizens before I feel even the smallest smidgeon of sympathy.

Jealous Geeks 

Posted Tuesday 22nd January 2008 20:09 GMT

Thumb Down

Your average geek (myself included apparently :-( ) hasn't a hope in hades of getting such lovin' themselves, so of course they are going to post derogatory comments on U-bend about those who do!

Another "Hope They Win" vote 

Posted Wednesday 23rd January 2008 09:57 GMT

Black Helicopters

A private moment of intimacy shared by two people is not a legitimate target for interwebnet upload. Hardcore sloppy invasions between groups of paid actors/actresses, on the other hand, is quite fine. The perpitrator is a voyeur, a nasty piece of flotsam in society and yes, the harsher the punishment met out in this instance, the better: unless of course the perp is his wife; or her husband.

Mmmm - a fate worse than a fate worse than death... that's pretty nasty.

Good one Register... 

Posted Wednesday 23rd January 2008 13:14 GMT

Thumb Down

...perpetuate the poor couple's lack of privacy!

@Russell Preece 

Posted Thursday 24th January 2008 14:36 GMT

There is no such thing as "a little bit pregnant". Once that clip is out on the web, it does not matter whether 2 million or 2 billion people watched it !! El Reg is just carrying on its journalistic function as best it can !!

Don’t Miss

Warning: roadworksNetbooks and Mini-Laptops

Buyer's Guide They're little and we love 'em. But which ones are best?

Warning: roadworksIntel shakes AMD's chip-fabbing baby

Cross-licensing custody battle

Emails show journalist rigged Wikipedia's naked shorts

Overstock's Byrne vindicated amidst economic meltdown

Warning StopYours truly, angry mob

Book extract Bringing Nothing To The Party: Cleaning up the net, one satirical vigilante page at a time